The Weil Lesser Metatarsal Osteotomy
Richard J. Zirm
The Weil osteotomy has become a popular technique for the surgical treatment of resistant lesser metatarsalgia. Metatarsalgia is a vague term that represents tenderness and pain in the plantar forefoot. The etiology varies widely from soft tissue to osseous, with neurologic, vascular, or dermal manifestations. It is a common presenting complaint that can interfere with normal ambulation, work, fitness, and recreation.
There is a considerable body of literature attesting to both the effectiveness and complications of this osteotomy. Bevernage and Leemrijse et al (1) studied 63 patients (73 feet and 177 metatarsals) with persistent metatarsalgia who underwent forefoot reconstruction by Weil osteotomies intended to restore a more normal metatarsal parabola. Sixty-two (85%) of the 73 feet were pain-free after recovering from surgery. The mean preoperative AOFAS score of 36.2 improved to 82.2 postoperatively. The mean metatarsal shortening was 5.71 mm. Preoperative metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) luxation was 30%, whereas postoperative luxation was 8.24%.
Vandeputte et al (2) documented the average metatarsal shortening to be 5.9 mm with 59 operative metatarsals in 32 patients. Postoperative metatarsophalangeal motion was significantly diminished; however, toe strength was maintained. There were no nonunions, delayed unions, or malunions.
Hofstaetter et al (3) concluded that the Weil osteotomy significantly reduced plantar forefoot pain, diminished isolated plantar callous formation, and increased the patient’s capacity for walking. Patients rated their surgical results as good or excellent in 21 feet (84%) at 1 year and in 22 feet (88%) at 7 years. Their findings include a reduction in plantar metatarsal head callous formation but a relatively high nonpurchasing toe rate of 68%.
EVALUATION
Physical and radiographic examination of the patient can determine the underlying etiology. Metatarsalgia most often results from structural or functional abnormalities. A different combination of these underlying factors can characterize symptoms that occur during the stance phase of gait versus the propulsive phase. The Weil osteotomy was developed primarily to treat the symptomatic, dysfunctional forefoot with an unbalanced metatarsal parabola. This is characterized by an elongated metatarsal with a propulsive-type hyperkeratotic lesion. Chronic submetatarsal phalangeal joint bursitis or a secondary soft tissue contracture may be present as well.
INDICATIONS AND CONTRAINDICATIONS
The surgical treatment of metatarsalgia has been somewhat controversial. In most instances, conservative treatment should be attempted before surgical options are considered. To date, over 25 different lesser metatarsal osteotomies have been described. Lowell Scott Weil, Sr. was the first to describe an osteotomy of the metatarsal neck, parallel to the weightbearing surface. This allowed the metatarsal head to slide proximally, thus providing axial decompression (Fig. 21.1). In 1992, Weil first performed this procedure in Europe. The osteotomy quickly gained momentum in Europe where it was primarily utilized for surgical correction of severe deformities associated with metatarsal phalangeal contracture due to excessive metatarsal length. Some of these deformities had been previously treated by joint destructive procedures such as pan metatarsal head resection. The Weil osteotomy has recently gained popularity in North America based upon the simple technique, stable fixation, excellent union rates, and predictable results.
The Weil osteotomy is generally indicated for recalcitrant metatarsalgia, refractory to conservative care. Long metatarsals with or without transverse plane digital deformities, crossover toes, and subluxations/dislocations of the MTPJs are all specific indications for this procedure (Fig. 21.2). It has also been utilized to correct rheumatoid deformities at the MTPJ. The Weil osteotomy may be employed on one or more metatarsals based on the complexity of the forefoot deformities and overall length pattern of the adjacent metatarsals.
The Weil osteotomy, as any forefoot osteotomy, is not recommended in patients with severe sensory neuropathy as well as in patients with significant peripheral arterial disease. Surgically induced Charcot joint and abnormal healing have been reported following forefoot osteotomies in the presence of diabetic neuropathy. A partial or total metatarsal head resection may be preferred in these cases (1). There are no specific contraindications to the Weil osteotomy making it a very versatile and useful osteotomy.
PREOPERATIVE CONSIDERATIONS
The overall physical examination must include the evaluation of concomitant deformities such as hammertoe contractures, hallux valgus, and hypermobility of the first ray. These deformities, if present, most often need to be surgically addressed as well.