Aperture Fixation in Primary Arthroscopic Double-Bundle, Single-Bundle, and Single-Bundle-Augmented ACL Reconstruction
Peter U. Brucker
Andreas B. Imhoff
INTRODUCTION
The native anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) consists of two functional bundles, which have synergistic, yet distinct biomechanical functions with respect to anterior tibial translation and combined rotatory load. Conventional ACL reconstruction techniques have focused on restoration of the structurally stronger anteromedial bundle, while the rotatory stabilizing function of the posterolateral bundle was neglected for years. In ACL reconstruction, graft placement is considered one of the main factors for successful treatment of ACL ruptures (3). Therefore, single-bundle ACL reconstruction techniques have accomplished this dilemma by modified tunnel placement more centrally within the common and widely spread anatomical footprint of both bundles femorally and tibially. Since a substantial group of patients present unsatisfactory results following single-bundle ACL reconstruction, various double-bundle ACL reconstruction techniques have been introduced recently for respecting the complex anatomy of the native ACL more closely.
Graft fixation was recognized as another essential factor for successful ACL reconstruction (3). Indirect extra-anatomical and extra-articular fixation techniques have potential disadvantages, such as graft-tunnel motion (4), windshield wiper effect (6), and suture stretch-out (10). In contrast, anatomical aperture fixation by direct tendon-to-bone contact adjacent to the joint space using bioabsorbable interference screws may overcome these problems. Additionally, aperture fixation seals the exits of both the femoral and the tibial tunnels toward the joint preventing or, at least, reducing a synovial fluid leakage into the tendon-bone interface.
ACL ruptures do not only represent one single entity, since various rupture patterns have been recognized (13). Strictly speaking, complete and partial ruptures of the ACL may need differentiated reconstruction techniques especially in autologous hamstring tendon graft techniques for reduction of hamstring donor site morbidity (5,9). This seems to be relevant, because the hamstring muscles are known to protect the ACL graft due to their synergistic function (8). Consequently, a concept of differentiated anatomical ACL reconstruction techniques using hamstring autografts has to be implemented.
DIFFERENTIAL INDICATION FOR DOUBLE-BUNDLE, SINGLE-BUNDLE, AND SINGLE-BUNDLE-AUGMENTATION ACL RECONSTRUCTION
Surgical treatment options for an individually adapted ACL reconstruction depend on various parameters such as age, profession, concomitant lesions (cartilage, meniscus, ligaments), comorbidities (prior meniscus surgery, osteoarthrosis, malalignment), sports and pivoting activities, and level of sports. In addition, the rupture pattern of the ACL must be also taken under consideration (13). Objective instability signs of the Lachman, pivot shift, and anterior drawer test may help the orthopaedic surgeon to differentiate between complete and partial ACL ruptures. ACL ruptures can therefore be addressed surgically in a single-bundle (complete ruptures), double-bundle (complete ruptures), or in an augmentation technique (partial ruptures).
Low-demanding recreational athletes or patients performing nonpivoting sports activities, though complaining of considerably subjective and objective instability, patients with higher age, or “knee abuser” patients with signs of instability and moderate osteoarthrosis may be sufficiently treated with a single-bundle ACL reconstruction (7). However, young and high-demanding athletes with pivoting sports activities may need an anatomical double-bundle ACL reconstruction addressing both the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundles of the ACL.
SURGICAL TECHNIQUE FOR PRIMARY ACL RECONSTRUCTION USING APERTURE FIXATION
Double-Bundle ACL Reconstruction
Patient Positioning, Surgical Setup, and Portal Placement
Under general (including complete muscular relaxation for secure hamstring tendons harvest) or spinal anesthesia, the patient is placed supine with both lower extremities in a straight position. A lateral thigh pillar is used for stabilization of the knee flexed to 90 and 130 degrees. A nonsterile tourniquet at 250 to 300 mm Hg is routinely applied in the most proximal part of the thigh.
In addition to a standard high anterolateral camera and standard anteromedial instrument portal, a secondary accessory anteromedial instrument portal is established 1.5 cm medially to the primary anteromedial portal. For correct placement of this accessory portal, a needle may be utilized for control of the optimal direction angle for later positioning of the femoral posterolateral bundle tunnel. Both anteromedial portals should be directly superior to the basis of the medial meniscus.
Graft Harvesting and Preparation
In cases of clinically unambiguous diagnosis of an ACL rupture, harvesting of the autologous hamstring tendons is performed prior diagnostic arthroscopy. In rare ambiguous cases, the diagnostic arthroscopy is accomplished in advance of the tendon harvest for detailed assurance of the rupture extension, for example, in potential partial ACL ruptures. Usually, both the larger semitendinosus and the smaller gracilis tendon were harvested for reconstruction of the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundles of the ACL, respectively. Alternatively, only the semitendinosus tendon may be utilized for reconstruction of both bundles if the length of the harvested tendon exceeds 28 cm.
In detail, an oblique transversal incision of 3 cm over the anserine pes is performed. The superficial anserine pes is cut in the direction of the collagen fibers following digital palpation of the semitendinosus and gracilis tendon. The identified tendons were secured by suture loop retention. The semitendinosus alone or both tendons were mobilized by release of soft tissue collaterals as well as adhesions and finally detached at their tibial insertion site. The ultimate harvesting of each tendon is accomplished using adequately sized tendon strippers (Arthrex, Naples, Florida).
At the back table, the muscle tissue of the harvested tendons is removed, and overlapping stitches of nonabsorbable sutures (e.g., Ethibond, Ethicon, Norderstedt, Germany) or absorbable sutures (e.g., Vicryl, Ethicon, Norderstedt, Germany) are applied at both ends of the tendons. Usually, the double-strand semitendinosus and the double-strand gracilis tendon graft measure 6 to 8 mm and 5 to 6 mm in diameter, respectively. If the diameter of one tendon graft is less than the aforementioned size, a triple-strand graft preparation is performed. Each graft is marked at 25 mm on the loop site. In cases of a single tendon harvest (semitendinosus), the minimally acceptable length of the double-looped graft is 8 cm for both the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundles.
Diagnostic Arthroscopy and ACL Footprint Preparation
Following standard diagnostic arthroscopy of all three compartments, concomitant intra-articular pathologies (meniscal lesions, cartilage defects) are addressed prior to reconstruction of the ACL.
The femoral dimensions of the footprint of the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundles at the intercondylar notch are identified and evaluated including mechanical probing since anatomical variations of the ACL and partial ACL ruptures may be present. Then, the torn and/or insufficient parts of the ACL are arthroscopically removed by sufficient exposure of the lateral femoral notch including their posterior osseous border and by preserving the tibial stump of the ACL due to its proprioceptive and vascular function. Usually, a notchplasty is not necessary in cases of later correct femoral and tibial tunnel positioning.
Femoral Tunnel Placement for the Anteromedial and the Posterolateral Bundles
On the femoral site, the tunnel for the anteromedial bundle is drilled first using mostly a 4-mm offset drill guide (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) via the anteromedial portal. In detail, the drill guide is placed at the posterior aspect of the notch at the 1:30 o’clock (left knee) or the 10:30 o’clock position (right knee) with respect to the coronal plane. The guide wire is positioned in 130 degrees of flexion and then overdrilled by an acorn drill of the corresponding graft size to a depth of at least 25 mm. A bony bridge of 1 mm between the posterior wall of the anteromedial tunnel to the posterior cortex of the notch should be preserved for avoidance of later tunnel blowout. An osseous notch is created in both femoral tunnels using a notching device (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) at the anterior-superior edge of the tunnels for aperture fixation by bioabsorbable interference screws (Fig. 29.1).
In contrast, the femoral tunnel for the posterolateral bundle is drilled through the accessory anteromedial portal. Therefore, a modified 4-mm offset drill guide is placed in the anterior-inferior aspect of the alreadyestablished femoral tunnel aperture for the anteromedial bundle representing a 2:30 o’clock in the left or a 9:30 o’clock position in the right knee for the posterolateral bundle. This posterolateral tunnel placement is performed in 90 degrees of flexion to preserve the peroneal nerve and the chondral surface of the lateral femoral condyle from iatrogenic damage. Then, the guide wire is overdrilled with an acorn drill of the corresponding graft size as well to a depth of 25 mm. This technical aspect allows a bony bridge of approximately 1 mm between both femoral tunnels (Fig. 29.2). The divergence of both femoral tunnels permits additional stability
of the bone bridge, which is accomplished by separate anteromedial portal utilization for each femoral tunnel placement. These notches reduce drive failure and screw breakage by decreasing peak screw insertion torque. A Fiberwire and a Tigerwire 2 (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) are pulled through the femoral tunnels of the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundles via standard anteromedial and accessory anteromedial portal, respectively.
of the bone bridge, which is accomplished by separate anteromedial portal utilization for each femoral tunnel placement. These notches reduce drive failure and screw breakage by decreasing peak screw insertion torque. A Fiberwire and a Tigerwire 2 (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) are pulled through the femoral tunnels of the anteromedial and the posterolateral bundles via standard anteromedial and accessory anteromedial portal, respectively.