Open Reduction and Internal Fixation of the Tibial Plafond
Stephen K. Benirschke, MD
Patricia Ann Kramer, PhD
Dr. Benirschke or an immediate family member serves as an unpaid consultant to Synthes and Zimmer. Neither Dr. Kramer nor any immediate family member has received anything of value from or has stock or stock options held in a commercial company or institution related directly or indirectly to the subject of this chapter.
PATIENT SELECTION
Indications
Patients who present with articular surface as well as gross metadiaphyseal malalignment of the tibial plafond are candidates for open reduction and internal fixation. Plafond injuries are characterized by an axial load applied to the tibia by the talus. Intrinsic articular surface impaction depends on the position of the foot at the time of impact and can occur across the entire joint surface. The medial edge of the plafond is injured preferentially when the foot is internally rotated/supinated, whereas the lateral edge is injured when the foot is externally rotated/pronated. Fibular involvement is common, and a Volkmann fragment with or without ligamentous avulsion is possible.
Contraindications
The most important concern related to surgical treatment in this patient group is evidence of noncompliance, especially with physician-directed changes in riskprone psychosocial habits. Among these habits are nicotine (via smoking or chewing) and intravenous drug addictions, which can create serious postoperative complications with wound healing. Other potential issues include vascular status, venous insufficiency, and systemic disease, but these situations should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, because with careful management these patients can be treated surgically. Neither extensive articular comminution nor open wounds should in and of themselves be contraindications to surgical repair.
PREOPERATIVE IMAGING
A standard series of radiographs should be taken of the injured limb, including lateral and mortise views of the ankle, to determine the extent of injuries. When a tibial plafond fracture is diagnosed, imaging should be obtained throughout the course of treatment. In this chapter, we describe three cases of tibial plafond fractures. The lateral and mortise radiographs of the first patient (A) are shown in Figure 1. These radiographs demonstrate the standard progression through treatment. The mortise radiographs of patient B are shown in Figure 2. This patient had a medial open wound; the injury required medial buttressing with screws. The radiographs of patient C are shown in Figure 3. Definitive fixation hardware failed in this patient and revision surgery was required.
PROCEDURE
Room Setup/Patient Positioning
A similar surgical setup is used for both the index and definitive surgeries described here. The patient is placed supine on a pressure-relieving mattress on a radiolucent operating table without metal rails. A flank wedge is used under the ipsilateral hip to allow both external and internal rotation positioning of the ankle with a straight knee. For the index surgery, a more internally rotated position is used; for the definitive surgery, the leg should be able to rotate both internally and externally. The hip flank wedge creates a pressure point on the contralateral greater trochanter, which necessitates the use of the pressure-relieving mattress. A ramp pad is used under the ipsilateral limb to elevate the foot and ankle above the level of the contralateral foot. This positioning allows unimpeded access to the ankle by the surgical team and allows intraoperative radiographs to be taken without patient repositioning.
Surgical Technique
Two surgical interventions are generally necessary for management of a tibial plafond injury. The goal of the index surgery is to provide gross reduction of the ankle through distraction, which allows the talus to obtain a central position under the tibia, via application of the external fixation. Once this gross reduction has occurred, CT scans are taken, and planning for the definitive reduction and fixation can proceed. The definitive surgery occurs 10 to 21 days after injury.
Index Surgery
The index surgery is usually performed within hours of presentation, whether the patient is seeking initial treatment of the injury or has been referred from elsewhere. Early external fixation allows for earlier definitive
treatment and better surgical outcome, but the Schanz pins must be placed carefully, avoiding neural and vascular structures. Open fractures have external fixation applied at the time of initial irrigation and débridement.
treatment and better surgical outcome, but the Schanz pins must be placed carefully, avoiding neural and vascular structures. Open fractures have external fixation applied at the time of initial irrigation and débridement.
Any fibular injury present is addressed first, using standard techniques. The key to the restoration of fibular anatomy is achieving correct fibular length, orientation, and rotation with the application of appropriate implants.1 To restore normal ankle mechanics, most displaced fibular fractures require reduction, but fibular reduction is especially critical when these fractures are associated with tibial plafond injuries because the posterior (Volkmann) fragment is connected to the fibula via the posterior tibiofibular ligament. Unless this ligament is avulsed, reduction of the fibula will grossly reduce the Volkmann fragment, facilitating treatment of the tibial plafond. Consequently, fibular reduction is a critical step in the treatment of these fractures, and a less than anatomic fibular reduction is detrimental to the patient’s outcome. Nonanatomic reductions must be revised, and the initial incision damages the soft-tissue envelope, making the revision more difficult. Although external fixation should be applied as soon as possible to minimize soft-tissue trauma, fibular fixation can wait until personnel with adequate training and equipment are available, which may require transfer from the referral center.
After the fibular fracture has been treated, an external fixation frame is attached. No tourniquet is used. The most basic frame is one applied along the medial column (Figure 4, A), but lateral injuries may require the addition of an additional bar, which makes a bicolumnar frame (Figure 4, B). The medial column frame is attached to the tibia, calcaneus, and cuneiforms. Four pins are placed to support the bar(s) through small incisions that follow the line of distraction. All pins are located outside of the anticipated location of the surgical incisions for definitive fracture treatment.
The calcaneal pin is inserted first. For medial column frames, the calcaneal pin is terminally threaded; for bicolumnar frames, the pin is centrally threaded (no
threads on the ends). No predrilling is required. The pin is inserted from the medial surface of the calcaneus and, for bicolumnar frames, protrudes through the lateral surface of the foot. The calcaneal pin is placed in the posterior portion of the calcaneal tuberosity, posterior to a line that connects the superior and posterior edges. Placement of the calcaneal pin through this region will avoid the sural nerve and calcaneal branch of the tibial nerve.
threads on the ends). No predrilling is required. The pin is inserted from the medial surface of the calcaneus and, for bicolumnar frames, protrudes through the lateral surface of the foot. The calcaneal pin is placed in the posterior portion of the calcaneal tuberosity, posterior to a line that connects the superior and posterior edges. Placement of the calcaneal pin through this region will avoid the sural nerve and calcaneal branch of the tibial nerve.
The second pin is then inserted into the tibia; this is located at the proximal middle third junction of the tibia through its anteromedial surface, avoiding the saphenous nerve and vein. The proximal tibial pin is a 5-mm Schanz half pin (designed for bicortical applications). Predrilling is required for both tibial pins.
The third pin is inserted via a percutaneous stab wound through the medial surface of the medial cuneiform. This pin goes through the medial and intermediate cuneiforms and into the lateral cuneiform, but it does not transgress the base of the second metatarsal. No predrilling is required.
The final pin is the distal tibial pin, which is similar to the proximal tibial pin. Its location is determined by
the tibial fracture. The pin should be located as distally as possible while remaining outside of the fracture area and forthcoming internal fixation.
the tibial fracture. The pin should be located as distally as possible while remaining outside of the fracture area and forthcoming internal fixation.