9 Fractures of the Foot
Overview of Foot Fractures
Anatomic Features
The foot is made up of a total of 26 bones of different shapes, which are supported by a network of approximately 32 muscles and tendons, 109 ligaments, and 45 articulations. The foot is divided into three sections: the forefoot, midfoot, and hindfoot. The forefoot is composed of 5 metatarsal bones and 14 phalanges which make up the toes. The midfoot consists of five out of a total number of seven tarsal bones, including three cuneiforms, one tarsal navicular, and one cuboid bone. The hindfoot includes the calcaneus and talus bone. There are five metatarsal bones (labeled 1–5 starting at the big toe), each consisting of a shaft or body, and a base and head. The base is wedge-shaped, expanding posteriorly. The head presents a convex articular surface, articulating distally with the phalangeal bones. There are 14 phalangeal bones in the foot, 3 in each toe except the big toe which has 2, and each bone consists of a base, a body, and a head (▶ Fig. 9.1).
OTA Classification and Coding System for Foot Fractures
According to the Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA) classification, a foot fracture is coded as number “8” for its anatomic location; the talus, calcaneus, tarsal navicular, cuboid, cuneiforms, metatarsals, and phalanges are coded as numbers “81,” “82,” “83,” “84,” “85,” “87,” and “88,” respectively. In addition, multiple fractures of the foot are coded as number “89.” The classification varies with individual bones of the foot due to complex anatomic features of each bone (▶ Fig. 9.2).
Epidemiologic Features of Foot Fractures in the China National Fracture Study
A total of 201 patients with 202 foot fractures were investigated in the China National Fracture Study (CNFS). The fractures accounted for 11.40% of all patients with fractures and 11.02% of all types of fractures. The population-weighted incidence rate of foot fractures was 38 per 100,000 population.
The epidemiologic features of foot fractures in the CNFS are as follows:
• More males than females
• More right-side injuries than left-side injuries
• The highest risk age group is 15–64 years
• Injuries occurred most commonly via falls and crushing injury
Foot Fractures by Sex
See ▶ Table 9.1 and ▶ Fig. 9.3.
Sex | Number of patients | Percentage |
Male | 132 | 65.67 |
Female | 69 | 34.33 |
Total | 201 | 100.00 |
Fig. 9.3 Sex distribution of 201 patients with foot fractures in China National Fracture Study (CNFS).
Foot Fractures by Injury Side in CNFS
See ▶ Table 9.2 and ▶ Fig. 9.4.
Injured side | Number of patients | Percentage |
Left | 98 | 48.76 |
Right | 102 | 50.75 |
Bilateral | 1 | 0.5 |
Total | 201 | 100.00 |
Fig. 9.4 Injury side distribution of 201 patients with foot fractures in China National Fracture Study (CNFS).
Age and Sex Distribution of 201 Patients with Foot Fractures in CNFS
See ▶ Table 9.3 and ▶ Fig. 9.5.
Fig. 9.5 (a) Age distribution of 201 patients with foot fractures in China National Fracture Study (CNFS). (b) Age and sex distribution of 201 patients with foot fractures in CNFS.
Foot Fractures by Location in CNFS
See ▶ Table 9.4 and ▶ Fig. 9.6.
Segment | Number of fractures | Percentage |
81–85 | 65 | 32.18 |
87 | 51 | 25.25 |
88 | 40 | 19.8 |
89 | 46 | 22.77 |
Total | 202 | 100.00 |
Fig. 9.6 Segment distribution of 201 patients with foot fractures in China National Fracture Study (CNFS).
Foot Fractures by Causal Mechanisms in CNFS
See ▶ Table 9.5 and ▶ Fig. 9.7.
Fig. 9.7 Causal mechanisms distribution of 106 patients with humeral fractures in China National Fracture Study (CNFS).
Clinical Epidemiologic Features of Foot Fractures
A total of 39,867 patients with 41,136 foot fractures were treated in 83 hospitals of China over a 2-year period from 2010 to 2011. All cases were reviewed and statistically studied; the fractures accounted for 9.61% of all patients with fractures and 9.53% of all types of fractures. Among these 39,867 patients, there were 2,466 pediatric patients (2,502 foot fractures) and 37,401 adults patients (38,634 foot fractures).
Epidemiologic features of foot fractures are as follows:
• More males than females
• Slightly more left-side than the right-side fractures
• The high-risk age group is 36–40 years, the same age group for males, whereas the high-risk age group for females is 46–50 years
• The most common foot fractures among adults are calcaneus fractures, in contrast to children, where the most common fractures are metatarsal
Fractures of Foot by Sex
See ▶ Table 9.6 and ▶ Fig. 9.8.
Sex | Number of patients | Percentage |
Male | 28,385 | 71.20 |
Female | 11,482 | 28.80 |
Total | 39,867 | 100.00 |
Fractures of the Foot by Fracture Side
See ▶ Table 9.7 and ▶ Fig. 9.9.
Fracture side | Number of patients | Percentage |
Left | 19,331 | 48.49 |
Right | 19,628 | 49.23 |
Bilateral | 908 | 2.28 |
Total | 39,867 | 100.00 |
Fractures of the Foot by Age Group
See ▶ Table 9.8 and ▶ Fig. 9.10.
Fig. 9.10 (a) Age distribution of 39,867 patients with foot fractures. (b) Age and sex distribution of 39,867 patients with foot fractures.
Foot Fractures in Children and Adults by Individual Foot Bone
See ▶ Table 9.9 and ▶ Fig. 9.11.
Fig. 9.11 (a) Distribution of 41,136 patients with foot fractures by individual foot bone. (b) Distribution of 38,634 adult patients with foot fractures by individual foot bone. (c) Distribution of 2,502 pediatric patients with foot fractures by individual foot bone.
Talar Fractures (Segment 81)
Anatomic Features
Examining its anatomic region, the talus bone can be subdivided into three parts: head, neck, and body. Between 60 and 70% of the talar surface is articular, forming seven articulations with adjacent bones. The head is semicircular in form, carrying the articulate surface of the navicular bone. The neck, the constricted area between the body and head, is roughened for the attachment of the joint capsule. The irregular body is cuboid in shape, wide in the front and narrow in the back, which gives stability when the ankle is dorsiflexed. While its superior, medial, and lateral articulate surfaces join together to make up the trochlea of the talus, the posterior surface (facies articularis calcanea posterior) is separated by a furrow, the sulcustali, which, together with the sulcus calcanei, forms a cavity, the sinus tarsi. Behind the trochlea is a posterior process with medial and lateral tubercles separated by a groove for the flexor halluces longus tendon. The medial and lateral tubercles provide attachment for the medial talocalcaneal ligament and the posterior talofibular ligament, respectively. The medial articulate surface of the body, which is semilunar in shape, is only half the area of the lateral triangle surface of the body. The lateral surface projects laterally as a broad-based, wedge-shaped prominence, referred to as the lateral talar process, from which the lateral talocalcaneal ligament originates and passes immediately beneath its fibular facet to the lateral surface of the calcaneus.
The subtalar joint consists of three articulating surfaces: the anterior, middle, and posterior facets, with the posterior facet representing the major weight-bearing surface. The anterior and the middle facets usually conjoin as one anterior articulation facet (▶ Fig. 9.12).
OTA Classification of Talar Fractures
Based on the OTA classification, the talus is coded as number “81” for its anatomic location. According to fracture location, talar fractures can be divided into three types: 81-A, avulsion, process, or head fractures; 81-B, neck fractures; and 81-C, body fractures (▶ Fig. 9.13).
Clinical Epidemiologic Features of Talar Fractures
A total of 1,140 adult patients with 1,143 talar fractures were treated in 83 hospitals of China over a 2-year period from 2010 to 2011. All cases were reviewed and statistically studied, including 561 patients with left-side fractures, 576 with right-side fractures, and 3 with bilateral fractures. There were 803 males and 337 females, with a male to female ratio of 2.38:1.
Epidemiologic features of talar fractures are as follows:
• More males than females
• The high-risk age group is 26–30 years, the same age group for males, whereas the high-risk age group for females is 36–40 years
• The most common fracture type is type 81-A, the same type for both males and females
• The most common fracture group is group 81-A2, the same group for males, while the common fracture group for females is group 81-A1
Talar Fractures (Segment 81) by Sex
See ▶ Table 9.10 and ▶ Fig. 9.14.
Sex | Number of patients | Percentage |
Male | 803 | 70.44 |
Female | 337 | 29.56 |
Total | 1,140 | 100.00 |
Talar Fractures (Segment 81) by Age Group
See ▶ Table 9.11 and ▶ Fig. 9.15.
Fig. 9.15 (a) Age distribution of 1,140 patients with talar fractures. (b) Age and sex distribution of 1,140 patients with talar fractures.
Talar Fractures (Segment 81) by Fracture Type
See ▶ Table 9.12, ▶ Table 9.13, ▶ Fig. 9.16, and ▶ Fig. 9.17.
Fig. 9.16 (a) Fracture type distribution of 1,143 talar fractures. (b) Sex and fracture type distribution of 1,143 talar fractures.
Fig. 9.17 (a) Fracture group distribution of 1,143 talar fractures. (b) Sex and fracture group distribution of 1,143 talar fractures.
81-A1 Avulsion 209 fractures M: 117 (55.98%) F: 92 (44.02%) 0.06% of total adult fractures 0.54% of adult foot fractures 18.29% of talar fractures 39.36% of type 81-A | 81-A1.1 Anterior |
81-A1.2 Other | |
278 fractures M: 190 (68.35%) F: 88 (31.65%) 0.07% of total adult fractures 0.72% of adult foot fractures 24.32% of talar fractures 52.35% of type 81-A | 81-A2.1 Lateral |
81-A2.2 Posterior | |
81-A3 Head fracture (without neck fracture) 44 fractures M: 29 (65.91%) F: 15 (34.09%) 0.01% of total adult fractures 0.11% of adult foot fractures 3.85% of talar fractures 8.29% of type 81-A | 81-A3.1 Noncomminuted |
81-A3.2 Comminuted | |
81-B Talus, neck fractures | |
81-B1 Nondisplaced 107 fractures M: 69 (64.49%) F: 38 (35.51%) 0.03% of total adult fractures 0.28% of adult foot fractures 9.36% of talar fractures 29.48% of type 81-B | 81-B1 Nondisplaced |
81-B2 Displaced with subluxation of subtalar joint 146 fractures M: 122 (83.56%) F: 24 (16.44%) 0.04% of total adult fractures 0.38% of adult foot fractures 12.77% of talar fractures 40.22% of type 81-B | 81-B2.1 Noncomminuted |
81-B2.2 Comminuted | |
81-B2.3 Involves talar head | |
81-B3 Displaced with subluxation of subtalar and ankle joints 110 fractures M: 85 (77.27%) F: 25 (22.73%) 0.03% of total adult fractures 0.28% of adult foot fractures 9.62% of talar fractures 30.30% of type 81-B | 81-B3.1 Noncomminuted |
81-B3.2 Comminuted | |
81-B3.3 Involves talar head | |
81-C1 Ankle joint involvement, dome fractures 62 fractures M: 44 (70.97%) F: 18 (29.03%) 0.02% of total adult fractures 0.16% of adult foot fractures 5.42% of talar fractures 24.90% of type 81-C | 81-C1.1 Noncomminuted |
81-C1.2 Comminuted | |
81-C2 Subtalar joint involvement 75 fractures M: 56 (74.67%) F: 19 (25.33%) 0.02% of total adult fractures 0.19% of adult foot fractures 6.56% of talar fractures 30.12% of type 81-C | 81-C2.1 Noncomminuted |
81-C2.2 Comminuted | |
81-C3 Ankle and subtalar joint involvement 112 fractures M: 94 (83.93%) F: 18 (16.07%) 0.03% of total adult fractures 0.29% of adult foot fractures 9.80% of talar fractures 44.98% of type 81-C | 81-C3.1 Noncomminuted |
81-C3.2 Comminuted |
Injury Mechanism
Neck fractures are the most common talar fractures. The usual mechanism is associated with hyperdorsiflexion of the ankle as the talar neck impacts the anterior margin of the tibia, as may occur in an automobile accident or a fall from a height. The body of the talus locks in the ankle mortise following a talar neck fracture, and the remaining portion of the foot, including the head and calcaneus, is displaced medially. The continuous axial load may rupture the interosseous talocalcaneal ligament, the posterior talofibular ligament, and the posterior talocalcaneal ligament, causing the body of the talus to move out of the ankle mortise posteromedially. The resultant fracture line will run obliquely upward and laterally.
Body fractures of the talus occur most commonly as a result of axial compression load, as seen in a fall from a significant height. Ankle joint fractures may also accompany this injury. Fractures of the posterior and lateral processes are often results of violent contraction of nearby attached muscles as the injury occurs.
Talar head fractures are relatively uncommon, usually resulting from force transmitted along the metatarsal rays to the talar head.
Diagnosis
Most talar fractures are marked by acute pain, considerable swelling and tenderness, and limited or partially limited motion. If fractures are displaced markedly or the injury results in dislocation, then deformity may be present. The anteroposterior (AP) view of the ankle joint can reveal most talar fractures, while the oblique view provides better visualization of the head and neck of the talus, even with small fragments. It is important to note the extension and direction of fracture displacement and the presence of fractures of adjacent articulations. Particular attention should be given to the ankle mortise, the distal tibia, and the remaining tarsal, to rule out possible fractures. Computed tomography (CT) scan and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can better reveal the nature of the fractures and provide accurate assessment of the articular involvement, as well as the degree of fracture displacement.
Treatment
Stable nondisplaced talar body fractures and avulsion fractures can be treated with immobilization by casting. Nondisplaced, unstable fractures and displaced talar body fractures can be managed by fixation of compression screws with minimally invasive techniques. Comminuted fractures can be treated with secondary arthrodesis if there is persistent pain or swelling. Stable, nondisplaced talar neck fractures can be treated nonsurgically, in contrast to displaced talar neck fractures, which require surgical intervention. A displaced talar neck fracture with associated dislocation may be treated first with closed reduction. Emergency open reduction and internal fixation may be indicated if closed reduction fails.
Other Common Classifications of Talar Fractures
Hawkins Classification of Talar Neck Fractures
The Hawkins classification of talar neck fractures is as follows:
• Type I: Nondisplaced
• Type II: Associated subtalar subluxation or dislocation
• Type III: Associated subtalar and ankle dislocation
• Type IV: Canale and Kelley
• Type IV: With associated talonavicular subluxation of dislocation (▶ Fig. 9.18)
Clinical Epidemiologic Features of Talar Fractures According to Fracture Location
A total of 1,143 adult talar fractures were treated in 83 hospitals of China over a 2-year period from 2010 to 2011. All cases were reviewed and statistically studied. Their epidemiologic features are as follows:
• Talar process fractures are the most common talar fractures
• Type II fractures are the most common type of talar neck fractures
• Talar head fractures are rare, only accounting for 3.85% of talar fractures
Talar Fractures by Fracture Location
See ▶ Table 9.14 and ▶ Fig. 9.19.
Fig. 9.19 (a) Fracture location distribution of 1,143 talar fractures. (b) Sex and fracture location distribution of 1,143 talar fractures.
Fractures of the talar process 487 fractures M: 307 fractures (63.04%) F: 180 fractures (36.96%) 0.13% of total adult fracture 1.26% of adult foot fracture 42.61% of talar fractures | Talar process fracture |
Fractures of the talar neck 363 fractures M: 276 (76.03%) F: 87 (23.97%) 0.10% of total adult fracture 0.94% of adult foot fracture 31.76% of talar fractures | Talar neck fracture |
Fractures of the talar head 44 fractures M: 29 (65.91%) F: 15 (34.09%) 0.01% of total adult fracture 0.11% of adult foot fracture 3.85% of talar fractures | Talar head fracture |
Fractures of the talar body 249 fractures M: 194 (77.91%) F: 55 (22.09%) 0.07% of total adult fracture 0.64% of adult foot fracture 21.78% of talar fractures | Talar body fracture |
Type I Nondisplaced 107 fractures 0.03% of total 0.28% of foot 9.36% of talus 29.48% of talar neck | Hawkins Type I |
Type II Displaced, with subluxation and dislocation of the subtalar joint 146 fractures 0.04% of total 0.38% of foot 12.77% of talus 40.22% of talar neck | Hawkins Type II |
Type III Displaced, with subluxation and dislocation of the subtalar and talotibial joints 87 fractures 0.02% of total 0.23% of foot 7.61% of talus 23.97% of talar neck | Hawkins Type III |
Type IV Displaced, with subluxation and dislocation of the talotibial, subtalar, and talonavicular joints 23 fractures 0.01% of total 0.06% of foot 2.01% of talus 6.34% of talar neck | Hawkins Type IV |
Calcaneal Fractures (Segment 82)
Anatomic Features
The calcaneus is the largest of the tarsal bones; rectangular in shape, it lies inferior to the talus. The calcaneus has six surfaces: superior, inferior, anterior, posterior, medial and lateral. It has three talocalcaneal facets on its upper surface, and one calcaneocuboid facet on its front.
• Superior: On its upper surface are three smooth facets, posterior, middle, and anterior, which articulate with the lower surface of the talus to form the subtalar joint. The middle one-third of the surface is the posterior facet, which is large and oval or oblong. It is anteriorly tilted, at an angle of 45 degrees from the midsagittal plane. The middle and anterior facets are located on the medial side of the upper calcaneal surface and are usually continuous with each other. On the medial side of the bone, below the middle talocalcaneal facet, is a shelf-like projection, the sustentaculum tali, which supports the talar neck and also serves for the attachment of several ligaments. The posterior one-third surface of the upper calcaneal surface is roughened and is in between the posterior aspect of the ankle joint and the Achilles tendon.
• Inferior: The inferior roughened area of the calcaneus gives attachment for the long plantar ligament and the quadratusplantae. The plantar-surface forepart of the calcaneus is a small rounded projection known as the small calcaneal tubercle, which gives attachment to the plantar calcaneocuboid ligament. The back part of the planter surface is an eminence called the calcaneal tubercle.
• Medial: The medial wall of the calcaneus is depressed. Under the surface of the sustentaculum tali of the calcaneus, there is a groove running obliquely downward from posterior to anterior, which contains the flexor hallucis longus tendon.
• Lateral: The lateral wall of the calcaneus is flat and smooth, except for a small ridge called the peroneal tubercle. Passing below the peroneal tubercle of the calcaneus is the groove for peroneus longus tendon.
• Anterior: The anterior surface of the calcaneus, which is square in shape, has the smallest surface of all and has a saddle-shaped articulation, forming the calcaneocuboid joint with the cuboid bone.
• Posterior: The posterior half of the calcaneus is an oval-shaped projection, which can be subdivided into three parts: upper, middle, and lower. The upper part of the posterior surface of the calcaneus is separated from the Achilles tendon by the subtendinous bursa and fat tissue; the middle part of the posterior surface, broad and rough, is the insertion point of the Achilles tendon; while the lower part is at a forward decline and continues with the calcaneal tuberosity. On the lower edge of the calcaneal tuberosity, on either side, are its lateral and medial processes serving as the origins of the abductor hallucis and abductor digit minimi (▶ Fig. 9.20).
OTA Classification of Calcaneal Fractures
Based on OTA classification, the calcaneus is coded as number “82” for its anatomic location. According to fracture location, calcaneal fractures are classified into three types: 82-A, avulsion, process, or tuberosity; 82-B, extra-articular body fractures; and 82-C, articular fractures involving the posterior facet (▶ Fig. 9.21).
Clinical Epidemiologic Features of Calcaneal Fractures (Segment 82)
A total of 11,008 adult patients with 11,720 calcaneal fractures were treated in 83 hospitals of China over a 2-year period from 2010 to 2011. All cases were reviewed and statistically studied, including 5,092 patients with fractures on the left side, 5,204 on the right side, and 712 bilateral. There were 9,228 males and 1,780 females, with a male to female ratio of 5.18:1.
Epidemiologic features of calcaneal fractures are as follows:
• More males than females
• The high-risk age group is 36–40 years, the same age group for males, whereas the high-risk age groups for female are 36–40 and 46–50 years
• The most common fracture type is type 82-C
Calcaneal Fractures by Sex
See ▶ Table 9.15 and ▶ Fig. 9.22.
Sex | Number of patients | Percentage |
Male | 9,228 | 83.83 |
Female | 1,780 | 16.17 |
Total | 11,008 | 100.00 |
Calcaneal Fractures by Age Group
See ▶ Table 9.16 and ▶ Fig. 9.23.
Fig. 9.23 (a) Age distribution of 11,008 patients with calcaneal fractures. (b) Age and sex distribution of 11,008 patients with calcaneal fractures.
Calcaneal Fractures by Fracture Type
See ▶ Table 9.17, ▶ Table 9.18, ▶ Fig. 9.24, and ▶ Fig. 9.25.
Fig. 9.24 (a) Fracture type distribution of 11,720 calcaneal fractures. (b) Sex and fracture type distribution of 11,720 calcaneal fractures.