Treatment of Tarsal Coalitions
Scott J. Mubarak, MD
Dr. Mubarak or an immediate family member has received royalties from Rhino Pediatric Orthopedic Designs, Inc. and has stock or stock options held in Rhino Pediatric Orthopedic Designs, Inc.
PATIENT SELECTION
Patients who present with tarsal coalitions have myriad presenting symptoms, but the most common include foot pain, foot deformity, and a history of an injury or multiple injuries to the ankle or foot. The orthopaedic surgeon must always be suspicious of a tarsal coalition in a teenager with multiple ankle sprains.
The history should alert the orthopaedic surgeon to the possibility of a coalition, but the physical examination will all but confirm its presence. A stiff flatfoot is the hallmark of a foot with a tarsal coalition. This is especially dramatic in presentation when the pathology is unilateral (Figure 1). The findings for a calcaneonavicular coalition are (1) restricted subtalar motion; (2) a palpable, often tender, bony ridge in the sinus tarsi; and (3) restricted plantar flexion of the affected foot compared with the unaffected side1,2,3 (Figure 1, B). A patient with a talocalcaneal coalition may present with a (1) bony prominence around the sustentaculum tali (just below the medial malleolus)10 and, of course, (2) restricted subtalar motion. Any of these findings should prompt further diagnostic imaging, as discussed below.
In my opinion, nonsurgical treatment of a symptomatic tarsal coalition does not benefit the patient long term. Periods of immobilization may provide temporary relief but do not address the altered mechanics that can cause adjacent joint degeneration. I also believe that patients with coalitions are at risk for future foot/ankle injuries due to the coalitions. I recommend excision in all young patients of age 21 years and younger.
PREOPERATIVE IMAGING
Much has been written about diagnostic imaging of tarsal coalitions. Both the calcaneonavicular and talocalcaneal coalitions have radiographic signs named for them: the anteater sign (Figure 2, A) and the C-sign (Figure 2, B), respectively.2,9 Plain radiographs can be helpful screening tools, but I believe that all patients going to the operating room for resection of a coalition should have a CT scan of both feet and, if at all possible, three-dimensional reconstructions of those images. These images are extremely useful not only to delineate the extent of the coalition in three dimensions but also to ensure that multiple coalitions are not present. MRI may be useful for a patient
with stiff talar motion but no obvious evidence of a coalition on a CT. Sometimes MRI will show fibrocartilaginous coalitions not seen on CT scan.
with stiff talar motion but no obvious evidence of a coalition on a CT. Sometimes MRI will show fibrocartilaginous coalitions not seen on CT scan.
The spectrum of each type of coalition as seen on diagnostic imaging is detailed in two articles. Upasani et al3 described calcaneonavicular coalitions (Figure 3), and Rozansky et al4 described talocalcaneal coalitions (Figure 4).
PROCEDURE
Room Setup/Patient Positioning
The patient’s foot should be positioned near the end of the operating table in such a way that the surgical team can be seated for the procedure. The patient’s entire limb is prepared and draped from the anterior superior iliac spine distally.
Special Instruments/Equipment/Implants
A C-arm should be available if needed to identify the subtalar joint with a talocalcaneal coalition and for complete removal of a calcaneonavicular coalition. Useful instruments include Kerrison rongeurs (3 or 4 mm), osteotomes, and a high-speed burr (3 or 4 mm), which is helpful for a large talocalcaneal coalition. Additional helpful instruments include Freer elevators, small Hohmann retractors, Bovie electrocautery, and an Allis clamp.
FIGURE 3 Classification of calcaneonavicular coalition (circled) according to Upsani et al3 based on three-dimensional CT reconstruction images. |
Surgical Technique
A sterile tourniquet is placed on the proximal thigh. After Esmarch exsanguination and tourniquet inflation, the initial foot incision is made.
Calcaneonavicular Coalition Resection
The approach for calcaneonavicular excision follows the technique described by Mubarak et al.1 An oblique modified Ollier incision is made over the site of the coalition, along the Langer lines (Figure 5, A). The location of this incision is just distal to the sinus tarsi overlying the coalition. This incision is taken down to the level of the extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) fascia, with careful dissection to avoid the lateral branches of the superficial peroneal nerve. After releasing the origin, the EDB is elevated from
proximal to distal. The coalition should be visible beneath the reflected EDB (Figure 5, B). The three-dimensional CT reconstructions obtained preoperatively should be available in the operating room to aid in delineating the appropriate plane of dissection (Figure 5, C).
proximal to distal. The coalition should be visible beneath the reflected EDB (Figure 5, B). The three-dimensional CT reconstructions obtained preoperatively should be available in the operating room to aid in delineating the appropriate plane of dissection (Figure 5, C).