Studies



Case Studies


This unit presents a unique perspective for a textbook. The unit is written more like a series of stories that chronicle the clinical practice of massage therapists specializing in sport and fitness massage. The content is technically correct and is presented in an interpersonal context of experienced massage therapists who are continually learning. The client profiles are often composite characters drawn from the author’s actual experience, designed to represent accurately the real-world application of information presented in this text. The goal is to involve the reader in a clinical reasoning outcome-based massage approach that is a realistic representation of the sport and rehabilitation environment and the persons involved. This is the best way for me, the author, to shift from teacher to mentor.


Each case in this unit is a composite of many different clients, but all the situations are ones with which I have been involved personally. As I reflect on all the sport stories I have read or watched, the underlying story is about the personal sacrifices and triumphs and the persons behind the scenes—doctors, trainers, coaches, family, and massage therapists, and others who contributed to the outcome, be it regaining fitness, ability to overcome injury, winning, or losing. Shakespeare coined the metaphor of the “play within the play,” and these vignettes can be thought of as the play within the competition. I purposely have used a variety of formats for these case studies so that the reader can become familiar with different narrative and documentation styles.


First, I will describe each of the clients, and then the text will follow a period of time using a charting format of the therapeutic massage session for each client. Individual methods such as lymphatic drainage or joint play will not be described. Instead, the reader needs to refer to those areas in the text or other textbooks that are recommended to support this text. Because there is no way to develop precise protocols, a clinical reasoning model is used. At the end of each case, critical thinking activities are provided to expand your critical thinking skills. Answers to the critical thinking questions are provided on the Evolve website, along with four additional case studies.


imageLog on to your Evolve website for a slide show of an example of a general protocol approach to massage:





Case One Tom—Golfer



image



Tom is a professional golfer. He turned pro in 1990. Tom is 38 years old, is in good health, and usually is actively involved in effective strength and conditioning programs. He will slack off periodically and then overtrain to compensate. His core strength is excellent, and firing and gait patterns are usually normal. Tom occasionally gets fatigue-induced gait and firing pattern changes if he has to play on an extremely hilly course, has to play back-to-back rounds, or has overtrained at the gym. When this occurs, he complains of heavy legs, tight calves, and achy feet. He has had plantar fasciitis in both feet successfully treated with cortisone injection and orthotics. He is an intense, emotional competitor and has a tendency toward breathing dysfunction. He recently fell while skiing and broke his left fibula near the ankle. The fracture did not require surgery.


Like most golfers, Tom has a pelvic rotation and a shoulder girdle rotation that is sport-related and asymptomatic. His forearm muscles co-contract on the golf club and become short and tight. He is prone to an occasional migraine headache and has seasonal sinus headaches and periods of tension headaches.


Tom travels a lot during the tour season, sleeping in different beds. This interferes with restorative sleep. Most of his complaints are related to being stiff, restless, and unable to relax. He relies on massage for tissue pliability and normal muscle resting length because he is not consistently compliant with a flexibility program, even though he is consistent with aerobic and strength training. Tom sees a chiropractor regularly. He prefers massage 2 times a week when in town, with outcome goals concentrating on the restorative properties of the general protocol. Each session, he identifies a different focus area. Sometimes the focus is his left shoulder or mild low back pain. Often his hamstrings, calves, and feet are the focus.


Tom is ritualistic, as are many elite athletes, and wants everything as sequential and familiar as possible when he gets ready to play. He is also accommodating and understands his demands on the massage therapist. He only travels with the massage therapist if he is especially tired or has some nagging, achy areas that are interfering with his golf performance. Otherwise, when on the road, he will get a massage from a massage practitioner in the area, based on other local golfers’ recommendations. He was hurt once by a massage that was aggressive and too deep, and he was sore the day of that tournament. Most of the time, if the massage is ineffective, he complains that the massage does not really make him feel looser. When Tom is at home, his massage therapist goes to his residence for the massage sessions. He usually watches the golf channel on ESPN on television during the massage. Occasionally, he will fall asleep.






Current Assessment and History: Client is 3 weeks post injury and is still in a cast. Surgery was not required. He complains of tension headache and low back pain, and is restless. He is not sleeping well. Client is home recovering. He is not taking any pain medication. Healing progress for the fibula is on schedule. He is obviously overbreathing and is out of sorts. Client seems to be experiencing increased sympathetic dominance in response to reduced activity. He is frustrated about missing tournaments because he is losing opportunities for professional advancement and finances. Overall, he is miserable.


The following revised treatment plan and series of massage sessions will support final healing of the fracture and beginning stages of rehabilitation before return to competition.





Analysis of Assessment and History to Develop Treatment Goals: This client previously has responded to massage, as described in the general protocol in this text. Assessment information is influenced by the fibular fracture and compensation and does not necessarily indicate his post-rehabilitation status.


Until the cast is off and rehabilitation begins, it is ineffective to specifically address the gait dysfunction. Two weeks into rehabilitation likely would be an appropriate time to assess gait and firing patterns and to begin to provide specific intervention. Firing patterns that would influence shoulder function and breathing would be addressed, even if the results were temporary.


The main immediate goals are to address the breathing pattern and reduce aching caused by adapting to the cast and having to reduce activity. Treatment in these areas should support better sleep, reduced irritability, and productive healing.






Session One:



Massage consists of general protocol with regional contraindication for the area of the fracture. The entire breathing protocol is integrated into the general massage session. The left leg receives lymphatic drainage. The foot not covered by the cast is addressed with rhythmic compression and active and passive range of motion.


Reflexively, the right forearm and wrist are massaged specifically to influence the area of the fracture.


Scalene, sternocleidomastoid, psoas, and quadratus lumborum releases are performed bilaterally.


The vascular and tension headache sequence is performed.


Energy work over the cast, combined with rhythmic passive range of motion of the left knee, targets the area of the fracture.


Abdominal massage addresses constipation.



Observation and palpation reveal 75% improvement in breathing function; edema is reduced in left leg by 50%. Client is sitting still and talking slowly. He is laughing and joking. Massage duration was image hours. This is typically too long, but client seemed to respond well.




Session Two:



General massage protocol is performed with sufficient pressure applied to support increased serotonin release. Lymphatic drainage is performed on left leg. Scalene, sternocleidomastoid, psoas, and quadratus lumborum releases are performed to address low back aching. Direct connective tissue methods, bend, tension, and torsion are used to increase pliability in fascia. Energy-based modality is used over cast between left lower leg and ankle and between right forearm and wrist. All breathing strategies are incorporated.




Session Three:



Left hip remains elevated and anteriorly rotated but not as pronounced. Breathing is generally good for this client. He is sleeping better and is less restless.


General massage protocol: Avoid the left leg; no specific focus, and target general support of parasympathetic dominance.




Session Four:



General massage is done with a focus on breathing and increased connective tissue pliability; do not address thigh muscle tension specifically, which seems to be guarding response. Will monitor. Incorporate passive mobilization for sacroiliac joint.


Full sequence of lymphatic drainage and venous and arterial circulation is performed, but no passive movement of left ankle. Ask client to move ankle during lymphatic drainage.


Specifically address right forearm and wrist to affect left leg and ankle reflexively.




Session Five:



S—Client is sore from rehabilitation, especially cardiovascular workout and weight training. Client is beginning proprioceptive training. Physical therapist okays massage in fractured area as long as it does not result in pain or inflammation, with caution given against heavy pressure over fractured area. Client has a tension headache but is sleeping well. He reports that he is anxious to get back to golf. Because the fracture occurred during a nonrelated activity (skiing), the doctor feels that he should be able to begin golf-related activity as long as there is no pain during or after activity in the area of the fracture. Physical therapist manipulated sacroiliac joint.


O—Range of motion in left ankle is 90% normal. Atrophy there is beginning to reverse. Tension in both thighs is reduced. Breathing is mildly disrupted. Left calf tissue pliability is reduced. Gait reflex assessment indicates that opposite side function is normal, but unilateral assessment indicates that arm and leg flexors do not inhibit in response to activation of corresponding flexion pattern. Also adductors do not inhibit when abduction is activated. Trunk firing is normal, but hip extension, hip abduction, and knee flexion are synergistically dominant. Knee extension and sacroiliac joint movement are normal.


General massage protocol used: Address all firing patterns and gait reflexes. Begin kneading (torsion force) of left calf to increase tissue pliability. Include breathing protocol and tension headache strategies. Apply lymphatic drainage to all areas of delayed-onset muscle soreness.




Session Six:



General massage is performed, including correcting firing patterns, gait reflexes, and eye/neck reflexes. Muscle energy (contract-relax-antagonist-contract) used on forearms, and compression used with active movement of forearms.


Scalenes, quadratus lumborum, and sternocleidomastoid/psoas were released. Kneading (torsion force) applied to calves bilaterally. Addressed breathing.


Used indirect function technique to reduce anterior pelvic rotation.





Session Eight:



S—Client is 10 weeks post injury and is doing well. Doctor and physical therapist are pleased with his progress despite the setback from overexerting last week. No more cautions are in effect for the fracture area. Client has a sinus headache.


O—Client’s firing patterns continue to show synergistic dominance but correct easily. Gait reflexes are normal. Eye reflexes do not inhibit in flexion when eyes are rolled back. Client displays familiar golf pattern: low back pain, pelvic rotation, and high shoulder on the left, with inhibited scapular retraction with attachment tender points and short pectoralis minor and anterior serratus. Client displays co-contraction of wrist flexion and extension, short calves, inhibited gluteus maximus, dominant hamstrings during hip extension, and binding plantar fascia.


General massage protocol targets each area as needed.




Session Nine:



General maintenance massage will be done with connective tissue focus on calves, addressing knee flexion firing patterns.





The Rest of the Story: This client occasionally will experience aching in his left ankle if he is on his feet a lot, especially if the golf course is hilly. He continues to play competitively in the PGA. He still gets headaches, overbreathes, and has forearm tension, low back ache, and golf-related musculoskeletal imbalance. He is a typical professional golfer. He maintains a solid conditioning program and still does not stretch as he should to counterbalance effect of the golf swing. This client will want massage regularly his entire career and beyond.




Case Two Darrel—Baseball Player



image



Darrel is a 23-year-old minor league baseball pitcher. He played Little League, high school, and college baseball. He is intent on moving up to the majors. The only major physical problem is recurring bursitis in his right shoulder. This is problematic because it is in his pitching arm. The trainer has used ice and various other treatments, and the pain is reduced, although the pain returns if he plays consecutive games. Darrel had one cortisone injection 12 months ago that was helpful, but additional injections are not advised at this time. He is taking celecoxib (CELEBREX). Darrel also has modified his pitching style somewhat so that his shoulder is not bothering him as much. Lately, he has noticed increased tension in his forearm. Massage has not been used specifically to address the underlying factors causing the bursitis. Goals for massage intervention will be targeted on reducing the irritation causing the bursitis and providing general athletic performance support. Darrel received therapeutic massage occasionally when on vacation. Darrel will come to the office for the massage sessions.








Physical Assessment:



Posture: Mild rotation of shoulder girdle to the right, pelvic girdle to the left, which is common training and performance adaptation for right-handed pitcher. Externally rotated right leg and mild forward head position.


Gait assessment: Arm swing is limited on the left. Left hip flexors do not inhibit when assessed against right shoulder extensors.


Range of motion: Right arm internal rotation limited by 20%. Flexion and abduction are normal but painful at end range. Right ankle is hypermobile. Sacroiliac joint is restricted on the left, with medial hip rotation limited with hard end-feel.


Muscle testing: Right arm abductors are painful to resistance testing but do not test weak. Hip flexors are weak at maximal pressure bilaterally.


Firing patterns: Hamstring dominance is bilateral, and calf is dominant for knee flexion on the right. Trunk firing is rectus abdominis dominant. Shoulder firing on the right is upper trapezius dominant. Hip abductors on the left show quadratus lumborum dominance.


Palpation: Right shoulder is warm with reddening and increased sweating during drag palpation. Left and right forearms are taut and binding with increased tension in flexion groups. Pain, point tenderness, and heat are displayed at medial epicondyle on the right. Pain and point tenderness are noted on the medial head of the right gastrocnemius. Calf muscles are adhered on the right. Upper chest breathing pattern is noted. Fascial bind starts from occiput down spine to lumbodorsal fascia to right hip and iliotibial band. Mild edema is felt at bursae in right shoulder.



Analysis of History and Assessment: Darrel is highly focused on moving to the major leagues. He loves baseball and seems to overpractice. He has excessive caffeine intake, primarily coffee and soda, which may be contributing to the restless sleep and to the upper chest breathing. Darrell exhibits sympathetic dominance by being fidgety and talking loudly, with a description of a typical day as follows: up early, treatment by the trainer for bursitis and strength and conditioning. Often there is team practice and then more treatment by the trainer. Preseason begins in 4 weeks, with season consisting of around 120 games. Darrel wants to be ready for the season to show off his skills and to be called up to the majors by midseason if luck goes his way. He is healing but is beginning to show signs of reduced recovery.


Darrell’s overtraining coupled with the playing schedule is a concern—whether he is recovering well enough not to become injury prone and excessively fatigued, which will affect performance. He does not have major adaptation issues at this time, and the various changes in posture, range of motion, and tissue texture seem appropriate for the sport activity. Exceptions to this are the point tenderness at the medial epicondyle on his throwing arm and the sacroiliac joint restriction. The sacroiliac joint restriction may indicate excessive rotation at the pelvis. The firing patterns in general indicate a tendency toward synergistic dominance, and the trunk firing pattern indicates a weak core muscle function. The upper chest breathing pattern is a concern and could be contributing to the shoulder problems and the recovery issue. Stress and emotional issues are a likely cause. Massage can address the general sympathetic dominance, the firing patterns, and the connective tissue bind. Massage cannot address the bursitis specifically but can reduce rubbing, which is causing the problem.


Massage would have to be combined with an appropriate therapeutic exercise and flexibility program to be most effective.


Darrel is highly motivated, and the trainer is supporting massage if a treatment plan is provided for approval, because the massage therapist is not employed directly by the team.




Session One:



S—Client reports no change in bursitis pain since assessment. Forearms remain tight. Sleep patterns are the same as previously. Trainer does not want direct work on bursitis area. Client was hit with baseball on right hip.


O—No changes in assessment since intake session. Client has bruise on right hip. General massage protocol, including specific breathing pattern sequence. Normalize firing patterns. Perform lymphatic drainage over bruise.


A—Breathing pattern is improved as indicated by reduced movement of auxiliary breathing muscles during inhale. Range of motion of right arm has not changed. Bruised area on right hip is less swollen and painful. Firing pattern for right shoulder is normal, but other patterns have not changed.


P—Continue with full-body general massage. Reassess breathing and continue to address firing patterns. Add gait reflexes to assessment and treatment.



Session Two:



S—Client reports improved sleep for 1 night. Bruise feels better, and calves are tender to the touch 1 day after massage, but feel loose. No change in bursitis. Forearms feel relaxed for 1 day.


O—Upper chest breathing is improved slightly. Firing patterns remain synergistically dominant. Gait assessment continues to show right shoulder extension not signaling inhibition to left hip flexors. General full-body protocol performed. Specific attention given to calf/forearm patterns with connective tissue focus. Shear of right gastrocnemius off soleus done. Firing patterns and gait patterns addressed.


A—Forearms and calves are more pliable but may be sore to the touch for 24 to 48 hours. Trigger point activity is still present in gastrocnemius. Gait patterns are normalized. Shoulder, hip abduction, and left calf firing patterns are improved. Other patterns would not reset. Client appears to be sleepy and reports that he is sleepy.


P—Continue with general massage, targeting firing patterns, connective tissue pliability, and breathing dysfunction.



Session Three:



S—Client reports that calves were sore to the touch and during movement. Left forearm is better. Low back is aching around left lumbar area. Sleep is improving. Trainer is concerned about calves being sore during movement. Asks that massage intensity be reduced.


O—Upper chest breathing is improved, and auxiliary muscles are not active during relaxed breathing. Firing pattern for shoulder normal, but hip abduction and extension remain in synergistic dominance. Quadratus lumborum active on the left; point tenderness present at left sacroiliac joint. Calves pliable but mildly swollen. Right gastrocnemius beginning to move independently of soleus. Trigger point in gastrocnemius less tender. Forward head improved slightly. Right shoulder less tender to the touch, but right forearm muscle is tense with point tenderness at medial epicondyle.


    General massage protocol: Quadratus lumborum and psoas release done bilaterally, and scalenes and sternocleidomastoid addressed. Inhibitory pressure used on trigger point in multifidus near left sacroiliac joint, and lymphatic drainage performed over shoulder and calves. All firing patterns and quadratus lumborum and psoas addressed. Rectus abdominis is inhibited, and then trunk firing patterns are reinforced.


A—Psoas, quadratus lumborum, and rectus abdominis inhibition seems to allow firing patterns to respond to treatment. All but the right calf is normalized. Reassessed gait patterns, and they were normal. Forward head position is improved. Right forearm remains tight and painful. Range of motion of right shoulder increased by 10% before becoming painful. Left sacroiliac joint remains painful to touch, but lumbar aching is improved.


P—Next session: Address short muscles in right shoulder. Continue with general massage and firing patterns. Resume connective tissue work. Suggest that client begin scapular retraction exercises and core training. Referred client to trainer for strength exercise program. Also asked client to have trainer evaluate right forearm and elbow tendonitis.



Session Four:



S—Client reports that team chiropractor adjusted low back and sacroiliac joint and that they feel better. Trainer increased rotator cuff strengthening exercises and added scapula protraction sequence. Client indicated mild delayed-onset muscle soreness in the area. Calves are no longer sore. Sleep was restless, but client thinks this was the result of upper body aching caused by the increased exercise. Trainer did not increase core strengthening but intends to add exercises next week. Trainer thinks client is throwing too many pitches during practice and this is making his arm sore. He has been icing shoulder when it is sore.


O—Forward head position has returned to original assessment position. Shoulder remains rotated right, but pelvis has improved slightly since the chiropractic treatment. All firing patterns again are synergistically dominant. Gait pattern normal. Right forearm and medial epicondyle remain tight and sore to the touch. Bilateral muscle testing of wrist flexors and extensors indicates right side is overly strong—hyperresponsive to resistance pressure and painful at medial elbow. General massage with scalene/quadratus lumborum and psoas/sternocleidomastoid releases bilaterally. Deep lateral hip rotators and shoulder external rotators released (inhibited) and gently lengthened bilaterally. Pectoralis minor inhibited and lengthened bilaterally. All firing patterns addressed. Connective tissue work done on lumbodorsal and anterior thorax fascia. Lymphatic drainage performed on areas of delayed-onset muscle soreness.


A—Right shoulder strength and pain are improved according to shoulder abduction assessment. Firing patterns have normalized. Forward head posture is reduced by 90%. Shoulder rotation and pelvic rotation have improved, with shoulder rotation 10% from normal and pelvis asymmetry only slightly dysfunctional, but inflare on the right is identified in postmassage assessment. Wrist flexion on the right painful at normal resistance, but no longer hypersensitive. Point tenderness at medial epicondyle remains. Hip flexor strength is improved.


P—Continue with full-body massage with specific focus on normalizing and stabilizing firing patterns and connective tissue bind. Concern is expressed about forearm pain, and client is referred to trainer for reevaluation.



Session Five:



S—Client reports that upper pectoralis area and abdomen are sore to the touch but not to movement. Right shoulder does not hurt to sleep on it. Sleep is again better and not as restless. Delayed-onset muscle soreness is better. Client reports that he is a little stiff around his shoulder until he warms up. Client continues to receive chiropractic adjustment for lumbar and sacroiliac joints.


O—Firing patterns for hip abduction and shoulder are normal. Hip extension and trunk firing patterns remain synergistically dominant. Hip flexors and shoulder abductors are strong and nonpainful at normal resistance. Right shoulder cannot sustain pressure as long as left. Gastrocnemius adherence and trigger point activity are decreased by 75%. Shoulder rotation has regressed to previous position, but pelvis remains stable. Performed general massage with inhibiting pressure to release scalenes, psoas, sternocleidomastoid, rectus abdominis, infraspinatus, teres minor, triceps, pectoralis minor, and deep lateral hip rotators. Performed passive range of motion of acromioclavicular and sternoclavicular joints bilaterally. Also inhibited hamstrings and biceps while resetting firing patterns. Used positional release on the tender points in the right forearm. Also used positional release on anterior serratus to improve ability to retract scapula. Specifically addressed fascial pliability in anterior and posterior thorax into iliotibial bands bilaterally primarily with kneading (bend and torsion force). Addressed shoulder and elbow through reflexology points on the foot and hand. Applied compression along meridians in arms and legs. Used indirect functional technique on shoulder rotation and right pelvic inflare.


A—Positional release effective for anterior serratus and forearm tender points except at right elbow medial epicondyle. Firing patterns are all normalized. Shoulder rotation improved again to within 10% of normal. Inflare improved slightly. Connective tissue bind decreased in thorax but remains in lumbodorsal fascia.


P—Continue with current plan. Again refer client to trainer for right elbow pain. Also encourage chiropractic appointments, core strength training, and rotator cuff and scapular retraction strength exercises.



Session Six:



S—Client reports that he was restless for the last 2 nights and did not sleep well. He also feels like he is getting a cold. Preseason begins next week. Trainer continues to ice right shoulder and arm and is stretching shoulder, elbow, and wrist muscles. Core training began 2 days ago, and client is sore. He reports that he is in a bad mood.


O—Client again displaying an upper chest breathing pattern. Rib cage less mobile than typical for this client. Firing patterns are stable, but gait reflexes are not holding strong in the shoulder flexion/hip flexion diagonal pattern. Client not as cooperative as usual. General massage given to address lymphatic drainage, pain management, mood elevation, and parasympathetic dominance pattern, but no specific work targeted because of the cold.


A—Client falls asleep during massage and is groggy when he wakes up. Gave him some hot tea to drink. Also gave him eucalyptus and lavender essential oil to take home to inhale and rub on his chest. Did not perform post assessment.


P—Reevaluate: This was last session of 2 times per week schedule. Need to adjust treatment plan for once per week and to accommodate beginning of season.



Session Seven:



S—Client has a cold, but it is not in his chest, just in his head. He indicates that he has a minor sore throat and sinus headache but feels better than last session. He would like more of the essential oil to take home. His shoulder is better as long as he continues to ice it. The trainer told him that he was pleased with the progress. The right forearm remains sore and tight. He is stiff and slightly sore from the core and rotator cuff and scapular retraction strengthening exercises, but it is better than it was. Client says he is not sleeping well. He believes it is a combination of the cold and muscle aching, and that he is anxious and excited about the season starting. He is frustrated that he does not feel like practicing hard because of the head cold and headache.


O—Assessment indicates posture is forward head and shoulder/pelvis rotation stable. Firing patterns are slightly synergistically dominant. Client appears sluggish. Session includes full-body massage with lymphatic drainage focus and headache sequence for sinuses, release of psoas and sternocleidomastoid, and addressing the diaphragm. Performed inhibition by compression on hamstring and biceps and deep lateral hip rotators and lateral shoulder rotators; and deep compression on serratus posterior inferior bilaterally (tender from sniffing). Mobilized facet joints with rhythmic compression and decompression of ribs. Massaged sinus, neck, and head reflex points on feet. Applied rhythmic compression to L1 and L4 acupressure points in hand. Continued to focus on parasympathetic dominance and restorative sleep.


A—Client reports headache is better. Firing patterns have improved. Client wants to take a nap. Did not do revision of treatment plan this session. Client is fatigued and wants to relax during massage.


P—Do reassessment and treatment plan revision next session.



Session Eight:



S—Client reports that cold is better, but he still has a headache. He is going to be pitching in 2 days and asks for increased focus on his right arm. It has been sore but now is better.


O—Reassessment:



Forward head position is nearly normal.


Shoulder girdle right rotation is mild, and pelvic girdle left rotation is slight. Right leg external rotation has reduced to slight.


Arm swing still reduced on the left, but gait patterns are normal.


Internal shoulder rotation is limited by only 10%, which is acceptable. No pain occurs at end range of shoulder movement, but pain remains upon slight overpressure in the right shoulder.


Muscle strength testing is normal. Firing patterns continue to assess synergistically dominant but will correct easily, especially when obliques and transverse abdominis fire. Core training should continue to improve this situation.


Right shoulder at the area of bursitis is less point tender but continues to redden during drag palpation and remains slightly swollen.


Right forearm seems worse during persistent wrist flexion/extension, and there is point tenderness at the medial epicondyle.


Gastrocnemius trigger points have resolved, but mild fascial adherence remains in fascial planes. Fascial planes are more pliable but still bind. Upper chest breathing pattern is intermittent.



Overall Impression: The client has improved slightly to moderately in all target areas. Posture has improved, and antagonist/agonist patterns have balanced around the shoulder. Irritation on the bursae is reduced, and inflammation is improving and is responding to ice and antiinflammatory medication. Reduced shortening in flexion and rotational patterns is allowing the therapeutic exercise to be increasingly effective. The client has been fairly compliant but does display some symptoms of overtraining. Because the massage application thus far has been moderately successful for the original treatment plan goals, it would be prudent to continue and to add specific treatment for the pitching arm to attempt to reduce muscle tension and pain. A concern is that the arm is this dysfunctional, and the season is just starting. The shoulder is improving, but symptoms at the elbow are not improving. Although symptoms are not yet getting worse, the strain of competitive play may override current adaptive capacity. It would be best to speak with the trainer to coordinate a treatment plan to support performance during the upcoming session.


Results of conference with trainer: Client does have some form issues with his pitching style that worsened when he accommodated to the bursitis pain. The coaches are working now to adjust the pitching form. The bursitis is improving, and Darrel is encouraged.


Note: Not included in the chart was a discussion with the minor league coach indicating that Darrel will be called up within the next month. This information influenced the treatment plan in that the time frame is more urgent.


The trainer suggests that massage continue as before and that the flexor muscles in the right forearm should be kept loose. We agree that friction at the medial epicondyle is not appropriate at this time.



Session Nine:



S—Client reports that he is feeling good. His shoulder hurts only a little after practice, and ice takes care of the pain. His forearms are tight, but he can deal with that. He continues to see the chiropractor once a week. He will be pitching in 2 days and is sleeping well.


O—Assessment indicates that firing patterns are stable. Hip extension is a bit hamstring dominant, and the rectus abdominis wants to fire during initial trunk flexion but inhibits easily, and firing patterns normalize. Right elbow extension is painful during the last 20 degrees of extension, and the forearm remains tense and binding. Point pain at the epicondyle has improved slightly. General massage protocol given with reflex application at left hamstring to reduce pain in right elbow extension. Also, biceps and triceps are inhibited. Worked on reflexology points in the foot for the shoulder and elbow.


A—All firing patterns and gait reflexes normal, with breathing slightly from upper chest. Client excited about season starting. Client reports that forearms feel looser and elbow is less painful. Reports that full elbow extension feels stiff at end range.


P—Continue with current massage plan.



Session Ten:



General massage protocol performed with restorative/recovery focus: Applied indirect functional technique for shoulder and pelvic rotation; inhibited rectus abdominis, psoas, hamstring, and sternocleidomastoid; reset firing patterns; performed lymphatic drainage on right arm; provided positional release for tender point in forearm; and performed cross-directional tissue stretching of forearms and calves.



Note: Client called and is despondent. He pitched four games and blew out his elbow. He is on his way for surgery and will get a hold of me later.



The Rest of the Story: Darrel became dehydrated from excessive sweating. Potassium/sodium imbalance must have occurred, and his muscles cramped. The muscle pulled away from the medial epicondyle, and he tore his medial collateral ligament. The injury will be corrected with what is called Tommy John surgery. The muscles are reattached, and the palmaris longus tendon is used to reconstruct the medial collateral ligament. There will be a year of rehabilitation before the arm is healed completely.


The treatment plan will have to be revised to include postsurgical healing—acute/subacute/remodeling stages—along with the rehabilitation process. Darrel is depressed and angry but is determined to play again.


Massage will begin again about 1 week after surgery and will continue 1 to 2 times per week throughout the rehabilitation process. The massage approach will be similar to the previous 10 sessions, and as soon as the doctor and the trainer approve, scar tissue management will be incorporated.


The emotional state of the client is important to support healing. Energy-based modalities seem to support tissue regeneration and emotional well-being. Intentional and focused touch during massage needs to support well-being as well. Tissue regeneration; mood-elevating essential oils, homeopathy (particularly arnica), and magnets to support the healing process may be used. It would be wise for Darrel to see a sport psychologist during rehabilitation.


Finances are going to be a concern. Minor league players do not make a lot of money. The team will cover the surgery and rehabilitation costs and will pay Darrel’s contract, but the massage therapist and the psychologist are not paid, and Darrel will have to find resources to cover these costs. Working with an athlete through an extended rehabilitation process is taxing and requires commitment. Boundary issues need to be monitored, and once the healing has taken place, the injury mentality of the client and the massage therapist must return to supporting performance. Many athletes will not return to preinjury performance and will have to come to grips with a career-ending event. Many traumatic injuries become chronic and require ongoing care.


For the reader: Although this is a hypothetical case, it is based on clients with whom I have worked. The person I modeled this case after did recover and played again in the minors. He was called up to the majors briefly but did not perform well. He was traded and played a while in the minors and then moved on with his life. Currently, he coaches high school baseball.



Critical Thinking




1. Darrel is taking CELEBREX, a medication that has significant side effects, especially for certain populations. Based on Darrel’s history, is there a concern about the medication side effects. What should the massage therapist do if anything?


2. Darrel has multiple firing pattern issues. It is likely that part of the reason for this is training effect; however, it may be prudent to begin to normalize the trunk firing issue. How would you justify this action?


3. Based on Darrel’s complicated history, what would be a justifiable target for treatment goals, and why?


4. In Session Two, the calves and the forearms were worked with similar intensity. Why would this be an effective strategy?


5. In Session Three, Darrel’s calves were sore, indicating that the intensity of the work in Session Two was inappropriate. What else in the SOAP note confirmed this?


6. In Sessions Three through Six, it appears as if only short-term benefits are occurring, and the client’s body keeps fluctuating back and forth between symptoms. One area improves, and then something else gets worse, and so forth. Why do you think this is occurring?


7. At the point of reevaluation after Session Eight, Darrel has shown beneficial response to massage combined with medical treatment and the rehab plan of the training. Although the shoulder is improving, there is a concern about the elbow. Why?


8. Darrel’s injury occurred because of multiple issues. What are they?


9. What is the potential for the occurrence of chronic pain for this client?



Case Three Tania—Soccer Player



image



Tania is a healthy 32-year-old woman and a recreational soccer enthusiast. Her two children play in local youth soccer programs, and she plays year-round in an indoor and outdoor league. She plays on a competitive women’s recreational travel league and a coed home league. She also coaches soccer and participates in youth soccer camp. Tania played high school and college soccer. When she was in high school and college, soccer was just beginning to become popular in the United States. She has avidly followed the progress of amateur and professional soccer.


Tania is financially secure from an inheritance that she invested wisely. She is an accountant working part time. She uses the physical and competitive nature of soccer as a social interaction and for physical fitness and stress management. Tania has received massage for many years and wishes to continue weekly massage on a long-term basis as part of her wellness lifestyle. She is a sequential and logical person and expects results from massage that she can identify in a tangible manner. Tania is well educated about her sport. The anatomy, physiology, and approach of the massage must be presented to her in an analytic and scientific way. She has changed massage therapists often because they were not able to meet her expectations for pressure, focused outcomes, and symptom management for her active life. This is the third month (12 to 14 massage sessions) mark with her current massage therapist, and she is pleased with the results of the massage sessions so far. The treatment plan usually has followed the general protocol of this text with weekly focal areas indicated by Tania. Lately, she has had some pain around her pelvic bone. The pain is more of a nuisance than a constant pain. She has had osteitis pubis (pubalgia) before. She is a demanding but loyal client who has a weekly standing appointment at the office.






Overview of Client’s Current Condition: Client has had various traumatic injuries since childhood. Both ankles have been sprained, but never a grade 3 injury. She had osteitis pubis in college that was slow to respond to treatment because she would not rest long enough. It eventually cleared up. She had similar symptoms during the last month of each of her two pregnancies and for about a month afterward.


Her pelvis is rotated anteriorly on the right and posteriorly on the left, with a tendency for shearing at the symphysis pubis. Sacroiliac joints occasionally fixate, but chiropractic adjustment is effective treatment. Gait reflexes, firing patterns, and range of motion are generally normal. They become disrupted if she has become fatigued; then she complains of heavy legs or an aching back. She consistently shows erector spinae dominance during right hip extension. Strength assessment is normal except for the gluteus maximus on the right. She has adapted to overexercise by maintaining a consistent core stability and flexibility program.


She takes various nutritional supplements intelligently and in moderation. She is not vulnerable to sport fads and gimmicks. She does not take medication regularly; however, she occasionally will use ibuprofen (MOTRIN) or naproxen (ALEVE) for headache or muscle aching.


Breathing function is good if she can play soccer consistently, but she will have upper chest breathing if forced to be relatively inactive. This rarely occurs, but when it does, she is irritable and usually gets a headache.


An area of point tenderness currently exists near the rectus abdominis inferior attachment on the right. It seemed to get more irritated after she attended a series of business meetings and wore shoes with a 2-inch heel. No regional or general contraindications are present.




Session One:



S—Client reports that she has been functioning well. Sleep, breathing, and soccer performance are satisfactory. She is bothered by tenderness in her symphysis area. She has been using ice but has not been taking any antiinflammatory medication. She requests her typical full-body session with attention to the sacroiliac joints and muscles attaching to the symphysis pubis.


O—Client displays typical pattern of pelvic anterior rotation on the right, posterior rotation on the left, slightly longer right leg, symphysis pubis shearing, and point tenderness. Left lumbar muscles are dominant for hip extension on the right, and the gluteus maximus is weak. In addition, there are kinetic chain–related tender points in the left pectoralis major, pectoralis minor, and coracobrachialis. The muscles on the left posterior shoulder are long but asymptomatic. Full application of the general massage protocol included the following: inhibiting pressure on rectus abdominis attachments at ribs and pubis; bilateral psoas release, with bilateral stretching of sternocleidomastoid; and inhibiting left lower lumbar with broad-based compression in shortest area, combined with left hip extension (with knee flexed) active movement.

< div class='tao-gold-member'>

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 22, 2016 | Posted by in MANUAL THERAPIST | Comments Off on Studies

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access