Percutaneous In Situ Fixation of Slipped Capital Femoral Epiphysis
Randall T. Loder, MD
Neither Dr. Loder nor any immediate family member has received anything of value from or has stock or stock options held in a commercial company or institution related directly or indirectly to the subject of this chapter.
INTRODUCTION
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is an adolescent hip disorder defined as a posterior and inferior slip of the proximal femoral epiphysis relative to the metaphysis. However, the relationship of the epiphysis and its articular surface relative to the acetabulum is not altered, and the movement is better defined as an anterior and superior slip of the proximal femoral metaphysis (neck) relative to the epiphysis. The technique of internal fixation is much easier to comprehend when this is understood.
The vast majority (>95%) of SCFEs are stable.1 A child with a stable SCFE is able to walk, with or without crutches; a child with an unstable SCFE is unable to walk, with or without crutches. The prognosis for a child with a stable SCFE is very good, with an incidence of osteonecrosis approaching zero. The prognosis for a child with an unstable SCFE is guarded due to the increased risk of osteonecrosis, which may be up to 50%.
A child with a stable SCFE has a history of intermittent limp for several weeks to months. It may or may not be associated with thigh, knee, or groin pain. Hip pain is variably present, often resulting in diagnostic delay. Physical examination demonstrates a loss of internal rotation and spontaneous external rotation with hip flexion. Abduction and flexion are usually decreased, especially in more severe cases (>50°). In the long-standing case, shortening of the lower extremity with varying degrees of thigh atrophy is noted; the parents will also describe a gradually increasing external rotation gait and limb-length discrepancy.
PATIENT SELECTION
Any child with a stable SCFE and open physes needs treatment. Without stabilization, progression is highly likely. The goals of treatment are to (1) prevent further slipping until physeal closure; (2) avoid complications, primarily osteonecrosis and chondrolysis; and (3) maintain adequate hip function. Four main treatments have been described: (1) internal fixation, (2) epiphysiodesis, (3) proximal femoral osteotomy, and (4) spica cast immobilization. Today, most authors advocate an in situ fixation with a single screw for any mild or moderate stable SCFE. The initial treatment of severe SCFE is more controversial. Primary osteotomy has been advocated by some to improve joint mechanics, motion, and hip function. However, the incidence of complications is higher with osteotomy than in situ fixation, so most surgeons recommend in situ fixation as the primary treatment for severe SCFE. In situ fixation allows the synovitis to subside, which will in itself result in improved motion. After complete physeal closure (usually 1 or 2 years later), the child’s functional limitations, gait pattern, and pain can be more leisurely assessed. A decision regarding the need for osteotomy can then be made after a thorough discussion of the risks and benefits with the child and parents.
Circumstances for bilateral pinning (ie, prophylactic fixation of the opposite hip) include patients with underlying endocrinopathies (hypothyroidism, renal insufficiency, growth hormone supplementation) and the very young child (open triradiate cartilage and/or age younger than 9 years in girls or 11 years in boys).
PREOPERATIVE IMAGING
In a stable SCFE, the diagnosis is confirmed with AP and lateral pelvis radiographs (Figure 1); both views are needed because an early SCFE is often seen only on the lateral view. Both hips should always be visualized, as the incidence of simultaneous bilateral SCFE may approach 20%. Either frog-lateral or cross-table lateral radiographs may be used. Proponents of the cross-table lateral view argue that the variability in positioning for the frog-lateral view due to the limitation of hip motion inaccurately represents the SCFE. The frog-lateral view can also theoretically convert a stable SCFE to an unstable SCFE. Proponents of the frog-lateral view argue that the lateral epiphyseal-shaft angle, commonly used to assess slip magnitude, is measured on the frog-lateral view. It is also the view on which many of the preoperative osteotomy plans are dependent. Comparisons between literature series are also possible with this view due to its common use.
Slip magnitude is best measured using the epiphyseal-shaft angle.2 This angle is measured on the frog-lateral pelvis radiograph (Figure 2). A line is drawn between the anterior and posterior tips of the epiphysis at the physeal level; a line is then drawn perpendicular to this epiphyseal
line. A line is next drawn along the midaxis of the femoral shaft. The epiphyseal-shaft angle is the angle formed by the intersection of the perpendicular line and the femoral shaft line. It is measured for both hips, and the magnitude of slip displacement is the angle of the involved hip minus the angle of the contralateral normal hip. Using this angle, SCFEs can be classified as mild (<30°), moderate (30° to 50°), or severe (>50°). In the case of bilateral SCFEs, 10° to 12° is used as the normal hip angle.
line. A line is next drawn along the midaxis of the femoral shaft. The epiphyseal-shaft angle is the angle formed by the intersection of the perpendicular line and the femoral shaft line. It is measured for both hips, and the magnitude of slip displacement is the angle of the involved hip minus the angle of the contralateral normal hip. Using this angle, SCFEs can be classified as mild (<30°), moderate (30° to 50°), or severe (>50°). In the case of bilateral SCFEs, 10° to 12° is used as the normal hip angle.
PROCEDURE
The most common technique for in situ single central fixation of a stable SCFE uses a cannulated screw system.3,4,5,6,7,8 Unless there are extremely extenuating circumstances, only stainless steel (never titanium) screws should be used. Titanium screws have a much higher complication rate if screw removal is ever needed (eg, breakage, stripping of the head, inability to remove the screw). A single screw is placed into the center of the epiphysis in both the AP and lateral planes. In the stable SCFE, there is never a need for two screws.
Either a fracture table or a radiolucent table can be used. I prefer a fracture table, although there has been no demonstrable difference between the two table types.9,10
Room Setup/Patient Positioning
The patient is positioned supine on a fracture table, so that the image intensifier can be moved rather than the lower extremity. If the hospital has the luxury of two image intensifiers, simultaneous biplanar fluoroscopy can be used. Care must be taken when transporting the patient onto the fracture table that no reduction maneuvers are performed and forceful traction is not applied to the lower extremity. The fracture table is used only as a “positioning device,” allowing the involved limb to lie comfortably in its natural position of rotation. The opposite limb is placed into abduction with the hip extended, and the image intensifier is moved into position between the two lower extremities.
Prior to surgical draping, the ability to obtain adequate AP and cross-table lateral images is confirmed (Figure 3). A guide pin is then placed onto the skin overlying the proximal femur, and an AP image is obtained. The pin is
positioned in the center of the epiphysis and perpendicular to the physis. A line is drawn on the skin to record this guide pin position in the AP projection (Figure 4, A). A similar skin line is drawn for the lateral image (Figure 4, B), again positioning the pin so that it is in the center of the epiphysis and perpendicular to the physis. With an SCFE, the epiphysis is posteriorly displaced relative to the femoral neck, and the guide pin in the lateral projection angles from anterior to posterior. This is opposite to that of a femoral neck fracture, where it angles from posterior to anterior. Thus, the two skin lines intersect on the anterolateral aspect of the thigh (Figure 4, C and D); as the slip becomes more severe, the intersection point becomes more anterior. Because of the retroversion of the posteriorly displaced epiphysis in SCFE, the osseous entry point of the guide pin is on the anterior aspect of the femur. In mild SCFEs, it is often at the anterior intertrochanteric line; in severe SCFEs, it moves up onto the anterior femoral neck.
positioned in the center of the epiphysis and perpendicular to the physis. A line is drawn on the skin to record this guide pin position in the AP projection (Figure 4, A). A similar skin line is drawn for the lateral image (Figure 4, B), again positioning the pin so that it is in the center of the epiphysis and perpendicular to the physis. With an SCFE, the epiphysis is posteriorly displaced relative to the femoral neck, and the guide pin in the lateral projection angles from anterior to posterior. This is opposite to that of a femoral neck fracture, where it angles from posterior to anterior. Thus, the two skin lines intersect on the anterolateral aspect of the thigh (Figure 4, C and D); as the slip becomes more severe, the intersection point becomes more anterior. Because of the retroversion of the posteriorly displaced epiphysis in SCFE, the osseous entry point of the guide pin is on the anterior aspect of the femur. In mild SCFEs, it is often at the anterior intertrochanteric line; in severe SCFEs, it moves up onto the anterior femoral neck.