Nutritional Guidelines for Football Players




© ISAKOS 2017
C. Niek van Dijk, Philippe Neyret, Moises Cohen, Stefano Della Villa, Helder Pereira and J. Miguel Oliveira (eds.)Injuries and Health Problems in Football 10.1007/978-3-662-53924-8_52


52. Nutritional Guidelines for Football Players



António Pedro Mendes1, 2  , Pedro Carvalho3 and Vítor Hugo Teixeira3, 4, 5  


(1)
Futebol Clube de Paços de Ferreira, Paços de Ferreira, Portugal

(2)
Food and Nutrition Department, Hospital Agostinho Ribeiro, Felgueiras, Portugal

(3)
Futebol Clube do Porto, Porto, Portugal

(4)
Faculty of Nutrition and Food Sciences, University of Porto, Porto, Portugal

(5)
Research Centre on Physical Activity Health and Leisure, Faculty of Sport, University of Porto, Porto, Portugal

 



 

António Pedro Mendes



 

Vítor Hugo Teixeira (Corresponding author)




Keywords
NutritionCarbohydrateHydrationNutritional intakeBody composition



52.1 Physiological Demands of Football


Football is an intermittent multiple-sprint sport characterized by repeated bouts of short duration high-intensity sprints in an endurance context that also requires the maintenance of skills throughout the match [1]. In a 90-min match, the distance covered by a football player ranges from 8 to 13 km, depending on factors like players’ fitness level, field position, difficulty of the game, tactics of the team, and weather conditions [25]. The majority of the distance is covered by walking and low-intensity running, and it is mainly the high-intensity exercise periods that distinguish top-class players from the others. International top-class players perform 28% more high-intensity running (2.43 vs. 1.90 km) and 58% more sprinting (650 vs. 410 m) than professional players at a lower level [1]. Although players perform low-intensity activities for more than 70% of the game, heart rate and body temperature measurements suggest that average oxygen uptake for elite football players is around 70% of VO2Max with an estimated energy expenditure of 16 kcal/min [6, 7]. Since football players perform 150–250 brief, intense actions during a game [1], this indicates that the rate of anaerobic energy turnover is high during periods of a game. Even though this has not been studied directly, intense exercise during a game would lead to a high rate of creatine phosphate breakdown, which to a great extent is resynthesized in the following low-intensity exercise periods [7, 8]. The energy substrate utilized during a football match is mainly glycogen, as seen by the depletion of glycogen in some muscle fibers that could be related to fatigue toward the end of the game [9]. In high-intensity activities, such as sprints and jumps, glycogen contributes approximately 50% to ATP turnover, and the repeated sprint activity that characterizes a football match leads to a reduction in glycogen concentrations, which in turn may impair performance in the latter stages of a match [10]. In one study employing Loughborough Intermittent Shuttle Test (LIST), a protocol mimicking the demands of team sports like football, the authors found a significant reduction in muscle glycogen concentrations from before to after exercise, both in type I and type II muscle fibers [11]. A study employing the Copenhagen Soccer Test (CST) [10] found similar results: type I and type II muscle fibers exhibited significant glycogen depletion, with ~80% of fibers being completely or almost depleted (<200 mmol/kg d.w) of glycogen after 90 min of intermittent activity. These low concentrations have been shown to decrease the glycolytic rate [8]. Type II fibers seem to be the main responsible for decreases in performance when their glycogen content is low [12]. Furthermore, the depletion of muscle glycogen in the sarcoplasmic reticulum results in reductions in muscle calcium handling [13], compromising the contractile property of the muscle [14].

Fat oxidation appears to increase progressively during a game, partially compensating for the progressive lowering of muscle glycogen. Increased levels of triglycerides might occur in the second half due to elevated catecholamine concentrations. The decline in blood lactate concentration associated to an increase in plasma free fatty acids during the game confirms the change in substrate utilization during the game [8, 9].


52.2 Fatigue


Match-related fatigue is determined by a combination of central and peripheral factors. The decline in performance observed at the end of a match arises from a combination of several factors involving mechanisms from the central nervous system to the muscle cell itself and energy production [15]. Fatigue in football seems to occur at three different stages in the game: (1) after short-term intense periods in both halves, (2) in the initial phase of second half, and (3) toward the end of the game [16]. The first two stages are not directly related to nutrition issues, but fatigue at the end of the game is associated with low glycogen concentrations in a considerable number of muscle fibers.

Data from the 2014/15 Italian Serie A, English Premier League, and Spanish La Liga shows that the final 15 min of a match is the period when more goals occur and that top teams always have a better goal difference [17]. Then, it seems crucial to optimize nutritional strategies in order to reduce fatigue and maintain physical and technical performance throughout the match. In this context, it seems well established that high carbohydrate intake in order to maximize glycogen storage is a crucial strategy to enhance performance in a football match.


52.3 Carbohydrate


Carbohydrate and fat are the main fuels for training and competition, and its relative contribution to energy demands depends on several factors, such as pre-exercise carbohydrate storage, exercise frequency, intensity and duration, or even athletes’ training status [18]. Since carbohydrate availability to muscle and central nervous system can be compromised when the cost of the exercise exceeds endogenous carbohydrate storage, provision of additional carbohydrate may be crucial to enhance performance in high-intensity sports [19].

Carbohydrate daily intake necessary to recover from daily training sessions depends on its intensity and duration, and it must be carefully estimated. Louise Burke and colleagues defined, in 2011, general recommendations for carbohydrate intake for daily training recovery [20]. For a highly active athlete (e.g., moderate-to-high-intensity exercise of 1–3 h/day), a 6–10 g/kg/day carbohydrate intake must be achieved. The large interval provided covers many exercise durations and intensities, and these general recommendations should be fine-tuned with individual consideration of total energy expenditure, specific training needs, and feedback from training performance [20].


52.3.1 Pre-exercise Carbohydrate Intake


For events lasting longer than 90 min of sustained/intermittent exercise, Burke et al. recommend a carbohydrate-loading strategy, consisting on a carbohydrate intake of 10–12 g/kg/day for 36–48 h [20]. It is important to choose compact carbohydrate-rich sources, low in fiber and residues, in order to meet fuel targets without compromising gut comfort. Carbohydrate loading can enhance performance of prolonged team games involving repeated high-intensity sprints, such as football [21]. Regarding the precompetitive meal, the recommendations target an intake of 1–4 g/kg of carbohydrates 1–4 h before game [22].

Consuming a carbohydrate-rich meal in the hour before a game is still a matter of debate. Most recent studies conclude that there is no effect of pre-exercise (<60 min) carbohydrate feeding on performance [23]. Furthermore, some studies claim the development of hypoglycemia in some athletes. In these individuals, it is important to plan meals in order not to develop this condition. Some options include choosing low glycaemic index (GI) carbohydrates, ingesting carbohydrate just before exercise or during a warm-up, or avoiding carbohydrate in the 90 min before exercise altogether [23].


52.3.2 Carbohydrate During a Match


The consumption of carbohydrate during a match represents an effective way of providing exogenous fuel to the muscle and central nervous system [23]. Several studies have shown a performance enhancement when carbohydrates are consumed prior and during exercise, not only in physical performance [24, 25] but also in football-related skills, such as passing, dribbling, and shooting [2628].

Strategies providing 60 g of carbohydrate per hour seem to be effective in a football game, but it can be modified according to players’ preferences. Bars, chews, gels, or drinks are effective ways for providing carbohydrate during the game [29]. Although some sports allow frequent ingestion of carbohydrate during a game, football limits the opportunity to ingest carbohydrate. Therefore, the minutes before the game and the half-time period are crucial to meet the recommendations [30].

There is accumulating evidence that the benefit from carbohydrate consumptions is due to a central effect as well. Actually, carbohydrate mouth rinse seems to improve performance during moderate- to high-intensity exercise (~60–75% VO2max), of at least 1 h duration [31]. The mechanism is probably neural, via oral receptors that activate brain regions related to the sensation of reward and pleasure. The sweetness of carbohydrate (CHO) does not influence the activation of the oral receptors [32].


52.3.3 Carbohydrate for Recovery


After exercise, timing and amount of carbohydrate consumption depend on several factors, such as the recovery period. With less than 8 h between exercise sessions, it is recommended a carbohydrate ingestion of 1.0–1.2 g/kg/h. for the first 4 h, in order to maximize glycogen synthesis [20]. The consumption of moderate to high glycemic index foods post exercise is recommended, although a recent study showed no differences in 5 km time trial performance 3 h after a low or a high glycemic index meal, consumed after a glycogen-depleting exercise [33]. When there is a large recovery period between two exercise sessions, meal frequency and carbohydrate intake are not so relevant.

Adding protein to these meals may enhance glycogen synthesis, especially when carbohydrate intake isn’t high enough [20].


52.4 Hydration in Football


In a sport played outdoor like football, dehydration can have a negative impact on performance, especially when combined with heat stress. Although some individuals may be more or less sensitive to dehydration, the level generally accepted that is capable to induce performance degradations approximates >2% decrease in body mass [34]. In a football practice or match, dehydration values from 0.5% to 3.4% of body mass loss were reported [35], with higher losses being associated with temperatures from 27 °C [3] to 35 °C [36]. Data concerning dehydration and football performance is relatively scarce and inconclusive. Higher Ratings of Perceived Exertion (RPE) and slower sprint times at the end of LIST as well as a decrease of 5% on dribbling skills were observed with dehydration of 2.5% compared with 1.4% [37]. More recently after a LIST protocol, football skills and intermittent high-intensity exercise performance were similar with 2.5%, 1.1% and 0.3% of dehydration [38]. When another exercise protocol was used (Yo-Yo Intermittent Recovery Test), dehydration by 2.4% led to an increase in RPE and to a lower performance compared to 0.7% [39]. Interestingly, in this study, when players washed their mouths with plain water in a volume corresponding to 2 ml/kg body mass, without swallowing the fluid, mouth rinse resulted in 2.1% dehydration but also reduced the total distance run by the football players during the Yo-Yo Test.

Even with conflicting data, it is prudent to assess hydration status of players and try to avoid body mass losses above 2%, especially when it is known that football players start a practice or match play already in a dehydrated state, probably as a result of cumulative dehydration from previous training practices [36]. Moreover, the intake of sports beverages during a match can supply an additional source of carbohydrates, very useful in players that do not initiate the game with glycogen stores completely full.


52.5 Nutritional Interventions to Improve Skills Performance


Although the vast majority of studies regarding nutritional interventions have focused on physical performance, the possible impact of nutrition on technical performance (commonly known as skills) has become a matter of interest for the scientific community.

The results altogether are somewhat equivocal, but it seems evident that skill performance is affected by some factors which might threaten homeostasis, such as fatigue [40, 41], dehydration [42], and reductions in blood glucose concentrations [20]. The most important skills in a football match are passing and dribbling, due to its frequency, and shooting, due to its ability to decide the final result [43, 44]. The second half of a football match is usually associated with a decrease in technical skills, particularly in passing and shooting [45], with total possession and total ball distribution also suffering a reduction [41]. Proficiency in match-related skills might be even more important than high-intensity activity. A study with Premier League players found that overall technical and tactical effectiveness of the team rather than high levels of physical performance per se is a more important success determinant in football [46].


52.5.1 Carbohydrate


Although there is a lot of evidence on carbohydrate and physical performance, only a few studies evaluated its effect on football-specific technical performance. The majority of these studies used a 6–8% carbohydrate beverage before and during the exercise to investigate its effects on skills during a match simulation, and some were able to find an improved performance in dribbling [28, 47], shooting [26, 28, 48], and passing [27].

Based on the available studies, it is hard to determine an optimal dose of carbohydrate to enhance technical performance, and it remains to be determined if the current recommendations for carbohydrate intake are optimal for preservation of skills that require cognitive input. However, following the recommendations of some authors, exogenous carbohydrate intake must exceed a rate of 50 g/h [27], but the amount associated with an improvement in performance varies according to the skill observed [26].

It remains unclear whether reductions in blood glucose concentrations lead to decreased technical performance, as the influence of rebound hypoglycemia has only been studied from a physical perspective. As the glycemic response to a subsequent bout of exercise appears to be independent of carbohydrate dose [49], and high glycemic index carbohydrate intake appears to blunt rebound hypoglycemic responses [50], the provision of additional carbohydrates may enhance technical performance, particularly in the latter stages of a match.

In all studies examining carbohydrate and technical performance the mode of carbohydrate administration was a beverage, given before and during the match. Although absorption at the lower gastrointestinal tract is important to elicit carbohydrate effects on performance, carbohydrate mouth rinse without ingestion has been shown to elicit ergogenic effects [31]. In a recent review, 9 out of 11 studies regarding carbohydrate mouth rinse showed an increased performance (range from 1.50% to 11.59%) during moderate to high-intensity exercise (~75% Wmax or 65% VO2max, ~1 h duration) [31]. However, investigations on mouth rinse and football skill performance are lacking.

High carbohydrate intake several hours before a match has already been studied. In a recent study [51], football players fed with a high carbohydrate (8 g/kg body mass [BM]) diet for 3.5 days before a match had more favorable score lines than players with a low carbohydrate intake (3 g/kg BM) diet. However, a previous study [52] observed no benefit of a high carbohydrate diet (8 g/kg BM) for 48 h on shooting and dribbling performance. Further investigation is needed to understand the possible impact of high carbohydrate intake several hours before a match on technical performance, acknowledging the fact that a high carbohydrate diet 1–2 days before the match could be beneficial in muscle glycogen loading, decreasing the possibility of fatigue due to glycogen depletion toward the game.


52.5.2 Fluids


Studies regarding hydration status and technical performance are scarce and not clear. In athletes who did not ingest fluids during a 90 min match simulation, performance was deteriorated by 5% (P < 0.05), when compared with athletes who ingested fluids [37]. Mean heart rate, perceived exertion, serum aldosterone, osmolality, sodium, and cortisol responses during the test were also higher (P < 0.05) in dehydrated athletes. A study by Ali et al. [26] also showed a decrease in post-exercise shooting performance when athletes did not properly replace fuel or electrolytes during a 90 min exercise test. It is important to notice that these athletes were in a fasted and energy-depleted state.

Although the results from these studies show the importance of ingesting fluids, the conditions did not mimic real-life usual practices, and the effects of dehydration upon technical performances in football players remain unclear.


52.6 Nutritional Intake


Based on studies assessing physiological demands of football players, specific nutritional recommendations have been developed. In order to evaluate the adequacy of nutrient and energy intake in these athletes, some studies tried to analyze it using food records (weighed or estimated), food frequency questionnaires, and other less detailed methods.


52.6.1 Energy Intake and Expenditure


Most of the available investigation on energy expenditure and intake focused on adolescent and young adult football players. Overviewing available studies with accurate methodologies, we observe that energy intake is higher for male players in comparison to their female counterparts. In male adult players, two studies [53, 54] found different energy intakes: in a fourth division junior team [53], energy intake was 3030 ± 141 kcal/day, and in a first division junior team [54], it was 2796.4 ± 525 kcal/day. When assessing female players, several studies found energy intakes ranging from 1904 ± 366 kcal/day in English international players [55] to 2291 ± 310 kcal/day in American National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I [56].

Although higher-energy intakes are expected in men due to differences in body composition and other physiological parameters, some studies suggest that underreporting is higher in women [57, 58].


52.6.2 Carbohydrates


Most studies have reported daily CHO intakes lower than those recommended. This is somewhat surprising given the well-documented and disseminated importance of an adequate carbohydrate ingestion to maximize performance. Both fourth and first Spanish division junior teams reported mean carbohydrate intakes lower than 5 g/kg BM (4.57 ± 0.2 and 4.7 ± 1.1, respectively) [53, 54]. These intakes are lower than those recommended by Burke et al. [20].

It is necessary to understand at which extent does low to moderate carbohydrate ingestion may negatively affect performance, although it is well established the performance benefits when carbohydrate intake is high before a football match.


52.6.3 Protein


Protein needs of athletes seem to be higher than the recommended for sedentary individuals due to their potential to enhance strength, but also to provide a supply of amino acids for an increased amino acid oxidation that may occur during training and competition [59]. Many factors need to be considered when determining an optimal amount of dietary protein for exercising individuals. These factors include protein quality, energy, and carbohydrate intake, mode and intensity of exercise, and the timing of protein intake. In a review focusing on football players, the recommendation for protein intake was 1.4–1.7 g/kg [60]. Nevertheless, protein intake of adult football players typically ranges from 1.5 to 1.8 g/kg, for males, and 1.2 to 1.4 g/kg, for females [59].

These intakes are lower than the recommended in females and adequate or slightly higher in males. Timing of ingestion [61] and quality of protein intake [62] must also be considered when evaluating protein needs and outline nutritional strategies to enhance performance.


52.6.4 Fat


The dietary reference intakes set an acceptable macronutrient distribution range (AMDR) of fat as 20–35% of total calories from fat. Some authors have suggested football players to ingest <30% of total energy intake in the form of fat. In a 2009 review from the American College of Sports Medicine, athletes in general are advised to consume fats within the AMDR of 20–35% of total calories [63].

Several studies in male football players reported fat intakes over 30% [53, 54, 64], with a Spanish first division junior team reporting consumption of 37 ± 5% of energy intake from fat [54]. These values are higher than most recommendations and may limit the likelihood of achieving carbohydrate intake recommendations. Most studies regarding female athletes intake show fat intakes between 24% and 30% of total daily energy intake, although a study in Spanish teams showed a fat contribution of 37 ± 7% [65].

The proportion of dietary fatty acids and ratio n6:n3 are major factors when assessing fat intake, but only a few studies presented values for saturated, monounsaturated, and polyunsaturated fatty acids [53, 65, 66]. From the analysis of the available literature, both male and female football players consume more saturated fat than recommended (<10% of total energy intake).

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 9, 2017 | Posted by in MUSCULOSKELETAL MEDICINE | Comments Off on Nutritional Guidelines for Football Players

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access