Hallux interphalangeal joint arthrodesis for healing of chronic hallux ulcers: outcomes, complications, and predictors

Abstract

Background

Chronic plantar hallux interphalangeal joint (IPJ) ulcers are difficult to heal and prone to recurrence. The surgical literature is dominated by resection arthroplasty; hallux IPJ arthrodesis has been explicitly excluded from recent systematic reviews, and outcomes of arthrodesis performed specifically as an ulcer-healing intervention have not been reported.

Purpose

To determine the proportion of chronic plantar hallux IPJ ulcers that heal completely within 6 months of hallux IPJ arthrodesis, and to characterize time to healing, radiographic union, complications, and recurrence.

Study design

Single-center retrospective case series; Level 4 evidence.

Methods

Consecutive patients who underwent hallux IPJ arthrodesis with documented intent to heal a chronic plantar hallux IPJ ulcer between January 2019 and April 2026 were reviewed. Of 18 cases screened, 5 patients (6 feet, including 1 staged bilateral procedure) met inclusion criteria. All feet underwent arthrodesis with a single intramedullary cannulated compression screw after curettage joint preparation. The primary outcome was complete ulcer healing; secondary outcomes were time to healing, radiographic union, and complications.

Results

Complete healing was achieved in all 6 feet (100%), with a median time to healing of 5 weeks (range 2–11). Ultimate radiographic union was achieved in all 6 feet (100%), and union by 6 months following the index procedure in 4 of 6 (67%). Complications included wound dehiscence in 2 of 6 (33%), revision arthrodesis in 1 of 6 (17%), and a single transfer lesion attributed to postoperative bandage pressure. No foot developed recurrence of the index ulcer, and no patient required major amputation. Median follow-up was 9.7 months (range 1.5–35.8).

Conclusions

In this small series, hallux IPJ arthrodesis achieved complete healing and ultimate union in all chronically ulcerated feet, without recurrence or major amputation, supporting its use as a viable limb-preservation procedure for refractory chronic plantar hallux IPJ ulcers.

Level of clinical evidence

4

Introduction

Diabetes-related foot ulcers affect approximately one in three persons with diabetes during their lifetime and are the leading non-traumatic cause of lower-extremity amputation worldwide. The hallux is the most common site of diabetic foot ulceration, accounting for up to one-third of cases. Ulcers localized to the plantar interphalangeal joint (IPJ) are particularly difficult to heal, frequently recur, and develop osteomyelitis at high rates despite optimal conservative care. ,,

The pathomechanics are well characterized. First metatarsophalangeal joint stiffness, sensorimotor neuropathy, and a dynamic IPJ flexion deformity concentrate plantar pressure and shear beneath the joint during propulsion. , When the flexor hallucis longus is contracted the deformity becomes structural, and the peak-pressure point persists despite total-contact casting, custom shoegear, or wound care. Surgical correction is therefore advocated when ulcers prove refractory.

The literature for this ulcer is dominated by resection arthroplasty. Modified Keller and dedicated hallux IPJ arthroplasty achieve high healing rates but introduce toe shortening, instability, and transfer lesions ,,, ; a recent systematic review judged both effective for chronic non-complicated diabetic hallux ulcers but explicitly excluded arthrodesis and infection-complicated ulcers. Arthrodesis is mechanically distinct, eliminating dynamic IPJ flexion while preserving toe length and a stable propulsive lever, with theoretical potential to reduce transfer lesions and recurrence. Yet the largest published arthrodesis series included only 16 ulcer cases, not analyzed separately, and none has reported outcomes of the procedure performed specifically to heal an ulcer. ,

We undertook a single-center retrospective case series to address this gap. Our primary aim was to determine the proportion of chronic plantar hallux IPJ ulcers that healed completely within 6 months of arthrodesis; secondary aims were to characterize time to healing, radiographic union, complications, and ulcer recurrence.

Patients and methods

Study design and setting

This single-center retrospective case series included consecutive patients who underwent hallux interphalangeal joint (IPJ) arthrodesis with the documented intent of healing a chronic plantar hallux IPJ ulcer at one academic medical center between January 2019 and April 2026. The institutional review board approved the study and waived individual informed consent for use of de-identified retrospective data.

Patient selection

All cases performed by a single surgeon were identified by the Current Procedural Terminology code for hallux IPJ arthrodesis (28,755). Of 18 consecutive cases screened, inclusion required age 18 years or older, arthrodesis performed specifically to heal an active chronic plantar hallux IPJ ulcer (documented in both the preoperative note and operative report), and ulcer duration of at least 4 weeks. Cases performed for other indications, those with concurrent toe amputation precluding hallux preservation, and those with insufficient documentation of the primary outcome were excluded. Five patients accounting for 6 feet (including 1 staged bilateral arthrodesis) constituted the final cohort.

Surgical technique

All procedures were performed under monitored or general anesthesia in the supine position without tourniquet. Through a dorsal “T-shaped” incision, commencing just distal to the hallux IPJ and extending to the midshaft of the proximal phalanx, the joint was exposed, residual cartilage removed with rongeurs and curettes, and the subchondral plate perforated to viable bleeding bone. The joint was reduced into neutral sagittal alignment with slight plantarflexion to recreate a stable propulsive lever and fixed with a single intramedullary cannulated compression screw. The plantar ulcer was sharply debrided to a clean granular bed, an acellular skin substitute applied, and a non-adherent compressive dressing placed. Concurrent procedures—gastrocnemius recession, sesamoidectomy, Akin osteotomy, chevron bunionectomy, distal plantar fasciotomy, and lesser-digit corrections—were performed at the surgeon’s discretion to address contributing deformity and offloading needs.

Postoperative protocol

5 of the 6 patients were placed in a postoperative surgical shoe with heel weight-bearing; 1 was placed in a controlled ankle motion boot. Sutures were removed at 2 to 3 weeks, and patients transitioned to protective footwear as the site epithelialized. Serial weight-bearing radiographs were obtained at standard intervals.

Outcome definitions

The primary outcome was complete healing of the index ulcer, defined as full re-epithelialization without dressings sustained at 2 consecutive visits at least 2 weeks apart. Secondary outcomes were time to healing; radiographic union, defined as bridging trabeculation across at least 3 of 4 cortices on weight-bearing radiographs; and complications. Because 1 foot required revision for nonunion, two union endpoints were pre-specified: union by 6 months after the index procedure (primary union at index) and union at any time including after revision (ultimate union). Delayed union was union after 12 weeks but within 6 months at the index procedure; nonunion was failure of union by 6 months at the index procedure. Recorded complications included wound dehiscence, surgical site infection, hardware removal, revision arthrodesis, index-site ulcer recurrence, transfer lesion (defined a priori as new ulceration at a different forefoot location attributed to altered mechanics), new ulcer at another location, minor amputation (toe or ray), major amputation (transmetatarsal or more proximal), and mortality.

Data collection and statistical analysis

Demographic, clinical, ulcer, biomechanical, operative, and postoperative variables were abstracted from the medical record by a single reviewer onto a standardized form; the hallux abductus interphalangeus angle was measured on weight-bearing anteroposterior radiographs. Given the cohort size, no inferential testing or multivariable modeling was performed, and the predictor analyses pre-specified in the original protocol were not pursued because outcome events were insufficient under the conventional 10-events-per-variable rule. Continuous variables are reported as median (range) and categorical variables as counts (percentages). Site-level outcomes used foot-level denominators (n = 6) and patient-level events (major amputation, mortality) used patient-level denominators (n = 5); the staged bilateral patient contributed 2 foot-level and 1 patient-level observations. Missing data were not imputed and are noted in the tables.

Results

Cohort characteristics

Of 18 screened arthrodeses, 5 patients (6 feet) met inclusion criteria; 1 underwent staged bilateral arthrodesis ( Table 1 ). Median age was 55 years (range 40–78), 2 of 5 (40%) were women, and 4 of 5 (80%) were White. Median body mass index, available in 4 of 5, was 32.6 kg/m² (range 24.9–43.7). All 5 had diabetes (1 type 1, 4 type 2), with median duration 9 years (range 3–25) and median preoperative hemoglobin A1c 7.6% (range 4.7–9.5). All had documented peripheral neuropathy; none had peripheral arterial disease, Charcot neuroarthropathy, or prior lower-extremity amputation. No patient smoked. Three of 5 (60%) had a contralateral hallux ulcer history and 2 of 5 (40%) had prior ipsilateral foot surgery.

Table 1

Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients undergoing hallux interphalangeal joint arthrodesis for chronic plantar hallux ulcer (N = 5 patients).

Variable Pt 1 Pt 2 Pt 3 Pt 4 Pt 5
Age at surgery, yrs 78 55 40/ 41 62 41
Sex F M M F M
Race White White White White Black
BMI, kg/m² 32.7 32.4 43.7 24.9
Smoking status Never Never Never Never Never
Alcohol use Social Social Heavy Social Social
Ambulatory status Community Community Community Community Community
Diabetes mellitus Y Y Y Y Y
DM type 1 2 2 2 2
DM duration, yrs 20 25 4 9 3
HbA1c preop, % 7.6 8.9 4.7 6.2 9.5
Peripheral neuropathy Y Y Y Y Y
Peripheral arterial disease N N N N N
Charcot neuroarthropathy N N N N N
Cardiovascular disease N N N Y N
Hypertension Y Y N Y N
Hyperlipidemia Y Y N Y N
Immunosuppression N N N N N
Rheumatologic disease N N N N N
Prior LE amputation N N N N N
Contralateral hallux ulcer history N Y Y N Y
Prior foot surgery Y Y N N N

Ulcer and biomechanical characteristics

All 6 ulcers were plantar to the hallux IPJ. Median preoperative duration was 50 weeks (range 20–57), with median dimensions of 1.25 cm length (0.5–1.5), 0.9 cm width (0.3–2.0), and 0.2 cm depth (0.1–0.2). No ulcer was probe-to-bone positive and none had osteomyelitis. Median hallux abductus interphalangeus angle was 23.4° (range 4.5°–35.5°). Hammered hallux was present in 2 of 6 feet (33%), equinus in 1 of 6 (17%), and hallux valgus in 1 of 6 (17%); none had hallux rigidus or limitus.

Operative details

All 6 feet underwent arthrodesis with a single intramedullary cannulated compression screw after curettage preparation, with split-thickness skin graft coverage of the plantar bed. Concurrent procedures included gastrocnemius recession in 1 of 6 (17%) and sesamoidectomy in 2 of 6 (33%). Median operative time was 65 min (range 53–105). Offloading was a postoperative surgical shoe in 5 of 6 feet (83%) and a controlled ankle motion boot in 1 of 6 (17%).

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Sep 5, 2026 | Posted by in ORTHOPEDIC | Comments Off on Hallux interphalangeal joint arthrodesis for healing of chronic hallux ulcers: outcomes, complications, and predictors

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access