3 Fractures of the Ulna and Radius
Overview of Ulnar and Radial Fractures
Anatomic Features
The ulna and radius are the bony structures of the forearm that form the elbow joint proximally with the humerus and the wrist joint distally with the carpals. The radius and ulna are joined by the proximal and distal radioulnar joints and by the interosseous membrane (IOM). The radioulnar joints are pivot joints where movements of supination and pronation take place. If one bone shows a fracture with displacement or angulation, usually the other bone will also have a fracture or displacement. Both the radius and ulna are long bones, prismatic in form, and lie roughly parallel to each other when the forearm is supinated. The ulna is relatively straight, while the radius is slightly curved longitudinally (▶ Fig. 3.1).
AO Classification and Coding System for Fractures of Ulna and Radius
Based on the AO classification, the ulna/radius should be considered as one unit of bone, with the location coding number “2.” The anatomic delineation of the segments, proximal, shaft, and distal, is performed according to the “Heim’s Square,” with assigned numbers of “21, 22, and 23,” respectively (▶ Fig. 3.2; ▶ Fig. 3.3).
Epidemiologic Features of Radial/Ulnar Fractures in the China National Fracture Study
A total of 355 patients with 356 radial/ulnar fractures were investigated in the China National Fracture Study (CNFS). The fractures accounted for 20.14% of all patients with fractures and 19.42% of all types of fractures. The population-weighted incidence rate of radial/ulnar fractures was 63 per 100,000 population in 2014. The epidemiologic features of radial/ulnar fractures in the CNFS are as follows:
• More females than males
• More right-side injuries than left-side injuries
• The highest-risk age group is 15–64 years
• Distal fracture of the radius/ulna is the most common forearm fracture
• Injuries occurred most commonly via slips, trips, or falls
Radial/Ulnar Fracture by Sex
See ▶ Table 3.1 and ▶ Fig. 3.4.
Sex | Number of patients | Percentage |
Male | 153 | 43.10 |
Female | 202 | 56.90 |
Total | 355 | 100.00 |
Fig. 3.4 Sex distribution of 355 patients with radial/ulnar fractures in the China National Fracture Study (CNFS).
Radial/Ulnar Fracture by Injury Side
See ▶ Table 3.2 and ▶ Fig. 3.5.
Injured side | Number of patients | Percentage |
Left | 169 | 47.61 |
Right | 185 | 52.11 |
Bilateral | 1 | 0.28 |
Total | 355 | 100.00 |
Fig. 3.5 Injury side distribution of 355 patients with radial/ulnar fractures in the China National Fracture Study (CNFS).
Radial/Ulnar Fracture by Age Group and Sex
See ▶ Table 3.3 and ▶ Fig. 3.6.
Fig. 3.6 (a) Age distribution of 355 patients with radial/ulnar fractures in the China National Fracture Study (CNFS). (b) Age and sex distribution of 355 patients with radial/ulnar fractures in the CNFS.
Radial/Ulnar Fracture by Location
See ▶ Table 3.4 and ▶ Fig. 3.7.
Fig. 3.7 Segment distribution of 355 patients with radial/ulnar fractures in the China National Fracture Study (CNFS) based on AO classification.
Radial/Ulnar Fracture by Causal Mechanisms
See ▶ Table 3.5 and ▶ Fig. 3.8.
Fig. 3.8 Causal mechanisms distribution of 355 patients with radial/ulnar fractures in the China National Fracture Study.
Clinical Epidemiologic Features of Radial/Ulnar Fractures
A total of 75,850 patients with 76,550 radial/ulnar fractures were treated in 83 hospitals of China over a 2-year period from 2010 to 2011. All cases were reviewed and statistically studied; the fractures accounted for 18.28% of all patients with fractures and 17.73% of all types of fractures, respectively. Among these 75,850 patients, 18,274 were children with 18,334 fractures, and 57,576 were adults with 58,216 fractures. Epidemiologic features of radial/ulnar fractures are as follows:
• More males than females
• More left sides involved than right sides
• The highest-risk age group is 11–15 years; the most affected female age group is 56–60 years, while males between the ages of 11 and 15 years have the highest risk
• Distal fracture of the radius/ulna is the most common forearm fracture
Radial/Ulnar Fractures by Sex
See ▶ Table 3.6 and ▶ Fig. 3.9.
Sex | Number of patients | Percentage |
Male | 41,592 | 54.83 |
Female | 34,258 | 45.17 |
Total | 75,850 | 100.00 |
Radial/Ulnar Fractures by Injured Side
See ▶ Table 3.7 and ▶ Fig. 3.10.
Injury side | Number of patients | Percentage |
Left | 40,576 | 53.50 |
Right | 34,936 | 46.06 |
Bilateral | 338 | 0.45 |
Total | 75,850 | 100.00 |
Radial/Ulnar Fractures by Age Group
See ▶ Table 3.8 and ▶ Fig. 3.11.
Fig. 3.11 (a) Age distribution of 75,850 patients with radial/ulnar fractures. (b) Age and sex distribution of 75,850 patients with radial/ulnar fractures.
Radial/Ulnar Fractures by Location
Radial/Ulnar Fractures in Adults by Segment Based on AO Classification
See ▶ Table 3.9 and ▶ Fig. 3.12.
Segment | Number of fractures | Percentage |
21 | 7,202 | 12.37 |
22 | 7,594 | 13.04 |
23 | 43,420 | 74.58 |
Total | 58,216 | 100.00 |
Fig. 3.12 Segment distribution of 58,216 radial/ulnar fractures in adults based on AO classification.
Radial/Ulnar Fractures in Children by Segment
See ▶ Table 3.10 and ▶ Fig. 3.13.
Segment | Number of fractures | Percentage |
Proximal | 3,427 | 18.69 |
Diaphysis | 6,113 | 33.34 |
Distal | 8,794 | 47.97 |
Total | 18,334 | 100.00 |
Proximal Radial/Ulnar Fractures (Segment 21)
Anatomic Features
The bony structures of the proximal part of the radius/ulna consist of the olecranon, coronoid process, radial head, radial neck, and part of the metaphysis. The bony surfaces of the humeroradial joint constitute an enarthrosis or ball and socket joint, between the radial head and the capitulum of the humerus, while the proximal radioulnar joint is a trochoid or pivot joint between the radial head and the ring formed by the radial notch of the ulna and the annular ligament. These two joints play an important role in the complex action of turning the forearm over as in pronation or supination. The humeroradial joint is considered similar to a lateral column that provides stability to the elbow joint during its motion in flexion or extension.
The articular surfaces of the elbow joint are connected by a capsule that is attached to the radial neck, 1.5 cm distal to the humeroradial joint. The radial tuberosity, also known as the bicipital tuberosity, is the main insertion of the biceps brachii muscle.
The olecranon and the coronoid process form a large depression called the semilunar notch that serves as an articulation site with the trochlea of the humerus. The humeroulnar joint is a simple hinge joint that allows for flexion and extension. The tendon of the triceps brachii muscle inserts into the posterior portion of the upper surface of the olecranon, while the ulnar nerve winds along the olecranon or epicondylar groove.
AO Classification of Proximal Radial/Ulnar Fractures
Based on AO classification, the delineation of the proximal radius/ulna is illustrated by a square whose lateral sides are parallel to the axis of the bone and their length equal to the maximum width of the epiphysis. According to this formula, the proximal radius/ulna is coded as the number 21 (▶ Fig. 3.14).
On the basis of articular surface involvement, the radial/ulnar fracture is further divided into three types: 21-A: extraarticular fracture; 21-B: partial articular fracture; and 21-C: complex articular fracture (▶ Fig. 3.15).
Clinical Epidemiologic Features of the Proximal Radial/Ulnar Fractures (Segment 21)
A total of 7,202 adult proximal radial/ulnar fractures (segment 21) were treated in 83 hospitals of China over a 2-year period from 2010 to 2011. All cases were reviewed and statistically studied; the fractures accounted for 12.37% of all fractures of the radius/ulna in adult. Their epidemiologic features are as follows:
Fractures of Segment 21 by Sex
See ▶ Table 3.11 and ▶ Fig. 3.16.
• More males than females
• The high-risk age group is 21–25 years: the same age group for males, while the most affected female age group is 46–50 years.
• The most common fracture type among segment 21 fractures is type 21-B: the same fracture type for both males and females
• The most common fracture group among segment 21 fractures is group 21-B1: the same fracture group for both males and females
Sex | Number of fractures | Percentage |
Male | 4,526 | 62.84 |
Female | 2,676 | 37.16 |
Total | 7,202 | 100.00 |
Fractures of Segment 21 by Age Group
See ▶ Table 3.12 and ▶ Fig. 3.17.
Fig. 3.17 (a) Age distribution of 7,202 fractures of segment 21. (b) Age and sex distribution of 7,202 fractures of segment 21.
Fractures of Segment 21 by Fracture Type
See ▶ Table 3.13, ▶ Table 3.14, ▶ Fig. 3.18, and ▶ Fig. 3.19.
Fig. 3.18 (a) Fracture type distribution of 7,202 fractures of segment 21. (b) Sex and fracture type distribution of 7,202 fractures of segment 21.
Fig. 3.19 (a) Fracture group distribution of 7,202 fractures of segment 21. (b) Sex and fracture group distribution of 7,202 fractures of segment 21.
21-A1 Ulna, radius intact 777 fractures M: 521 (67.05%) F: 256 (32.95%) 0.21% of total adult fractures 1.33% of adult radius/ulna 10.79% of segment 21 47.09% of type 21-A | 21-A1.1 Avulsion of triceps insertion from the olecranon |
21-A1.2 Metaphyseal simple fracture | |
21-A1.3 metaphyseal multifragmentary fracture | |
806 fractures M: 412 (52.12%) F: 394 (48.88%) 0.22% of total adult fractures 1.38% of adult radius/ulna 11.19% of segment 21 48.85% of type 21-A | 21-A2.1 Avulsion of biceps insertion from the radial tuberosity |
21-A2.2 Radial neck simple fracture | |
21-A2.3 Radial neck multifragmentary fracture | |
67 fractures M: 39 (58.21%) F: 28 (41.79%) 0.22% of total adult fractures 0.12% of adult radius/ulna 0.93% of segment 21 4.06% of type 21-A | 21-A3.1 Both bones simple fracture |
21-A3.2 One bone simple fracture, other bone multifragmentary fracture | |
21-A3.3 Both bones multifragmentary | |
21-B1 Ulna, radius intact 2,773 fractures M: 1,809 (65.24%) F: 964 (34.76%) 0.74% of total adult fractures 4.76% of adult radius/ulna 38.50% of segment 21 52.65% of type 21-B | 21-B1.1 Unifocal simple fracture |
21-B1.2 Bifocal simple fracture | |
21-B1.3 Bifocal multifragmentary | |
2,292 fractures M: 1,426 (62.22%) F: 866 (37.78%) 0.61% of total adult fractures 3.94% of adult radius/ulna 31.82% of segment 21 43.52% of type 21-B | 21-B2.1 Simple fracture with minimal or no displacement |
21-B2.2 Multifragmentary without depression | |
21-B2.3 Multifragmentary with depression | |
21-B3 One bone articular, other bone extra-articular 202 fractures M: 129 (63.86%) F: 73 (36.14%) 0.05% of total adult fractures 0.35% of adult radius/ulna 2.80% of segment 21 3.84% of type 21-B | 21-B3.1 Ulna articular simple, radius extra-articular fracture |
21-B3.2 Radius articular simple, ulna extra-articular fracture | |
21-B3.3 One bone articular multifragmentary, other bone extra-articular fracture | |
21-C1 Both bones, simple fracture 125 fractures M: 76 (60.80%) F: 49 (39.20%) 0.03% of total adult fractures 0.21% of adult radius/ulna 1.74% of segment 21 43.86% of type 21-C | 21-C1.1 Olecranon and radial head |
21-C1.2 Coronoid process and radial head | |
21-C2 Both bones, one articular simple, the other articular multifragmentary 90 fractures M: 66 (73.33%) F: 24 (26.67%) 0.02% of total adult fractures 0.15% of adult radius/ulna 1.25% of segment 21 31.58% of type 21-C | 21-C2.1 Olecranon multifragmentary, radial head simple split |
21-C2.2 Olecranon simple, radial head multifragmentary | |
21-C2.3 Coronoid process simple, radial head multifragmentary | |
21-C3 Both bones, articular multifragmentary 70 fractures M: 48 (68.57%) F: 22 (31.43%) 0.02% of total adult fractures 0.12% of adult radius/ulna 0.97% of segment 21 24.56% of type 21-C | 21-C3.1 Three fragments each bone |
21-C3.2 Ulna more than three fragments, radius three or more fragments | |
21-C3.3 Radius more than three fragments, ulna three or more fragments |
Injury Mechanism
Olecranon Fractures
Olecranon multifragmentary fracture can be caused by direct trauma, as in falls on or blows to the point of the elbow. Such types of fractures also occur during a fall on the semiflexed supinated forearm with the hand striking the ground, and the pull of the triceps muscle leading to a transverse or wedge fracture of the olecranon.
Fractures of Radial Head or Neck of the Radius
This type of injury is usually from a fall on an outstretched arm with the force of impact transmitted up the hand through the forearm to the radial head, which is forced to the capitellum and often causes fractures in the anterolateral aspect of the radial head or neck of the radius. Multifragmentary fractures or dislocation may occur by high energy trauma.
Coronoid Fractures
Coronoid fracture, rarely seen in isolation, usually occurs in combination with olecranon fracture; this type of fracture results from an avulsion fracture of the bony structure of the coronoid, by contraction of the joint capsule with the elbow in hyperextension.
Diagnosis
The insertion of the triceps muscle on the olecranon is usually compromised when olecranon fractures occur. In most cases, patients cannot fully strengthen their arm due to the pain and are unable to overcome any resistance. The movement of supination aggravates the pain from fractures in the radial head or neck of the radius and limits the range of motion.
The radiographic examination should include anteroposterior (AP) and lateral views of the elbow. If the patient has marked physical signs but inconclusive X-rays, then computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans may be required to clarify the nature and extent of the injury. Note that the individual will be unable to fully extend the forearm when taking the AP view of the elbow, so the beam must be placed perpendicularly to the radial head (▶ Fig. 3.20).
Treatment
Olecranon fractures are unstable fractures, usually requiring surgical intervention. Plate fixation, tension band wiring, and other internal fixators can be utilized in stabilizing the fracture, depending on the fracture type. Stable fractures of the radial head or the neck of radius with no displacement can be managed nonsurgically, but with close monitoring of fracture progression within 4 weeks. Minimal invasive internal fixation is preferable for fractures with dislocation or when nonsurgical treatment fails. Based on fracture type, patient’s age, and general condition, various internal fixators can be selected, including screws, absorbable screws, and Kirschner wires (K-wires). Anatomic reduction to the utmost, rigid fixation, and early mobilization are applied even for complex fractures. Excision of the radial head and replacement with a prosthesis should be considered only as a last resort.