Study
# of feet
Study type
Joint preparation technique
Fixation
Functional improvement
Union rate
Bennett GL and Sabetta J [45]
233
Prospective
Cup-and-cone manual
Dorsal locking plate
AOFAS: 51 ➔ 84
3/233 (98.7%)
Brodsky et al. [3]
60
Retrospective
Cup-and-cone manual
Parallel 3.5 mm cortical screws
98% return to preoperative occupation
Not quoted
Coughlin MJ and Abdo RV [44]
58
Retrospective
Cup-and-cone reamers
Dorsal plate
54/58 (93.1%) “excellent” or “good” satisfaction
57/58 (98.3%)
Doty et al. [4]
51
Prospective
Cup-and-cone reamers
Dorsal plate + lag crew
AOFAS: 45 ➔ 77
VAS: 6.6 ➔ 1.6
50/51 (98%)
Ellington et al. [5]
155
Retrospective
Cup-and-cone reamers
Dorsal plate + lag screw
83.1% patients “good” satisfaction or higher
94/107 patients (87.9%)
Goucher NR and Coughlin MJ [6]
53
Prospective
Cup-and-cone reamers
Dorsal plate + lag screw
AOFAS: 51 ➔ 82
VAS: 6.3 ➔ <1
48/49 (98%) excellent or good final outcome
49/53 (92.5%)
Hyer et al. [9]
45
Retrospective
Cup-and-cone reamers
Dorsal locked plate + lag screw
Not quoted
42/45 (93%)
Kumar et al. [7]
46
Retrospective
Cup-and-cone reamers
Dorsal plate + lag screw
Patient satisfaction = 100%
98%
Van Doeselaar et al. [14]
62
Prospective
Planar excision
Crossed lag screws
Significantly decreased foot function index (less pain and disability)
95%
Wassink S and van den Oever M [8]
109
Retrospective
Planar excision
Single lag screw
74/89 (83%) patients completely pain-free or mild pain
105/109 (96.3%)
Case Example
The patient is a 48-year-old woman who initially presented with a 2-year history of left foot pain secondary to hallux MTP joint arthritis and second toe hammertoe deformity. She had been treated with custom orthotics in the past, but was still having daily pain and difficulty with shoewear with a negative impact on her quality of life. Her examination was significant for stiffness at the first MTP joint, with pain throughout the entire arc of motion. In addition, she had a fixed hammertoe deformity of the second toe along with tenderness and instability at the second MTP joint. Initial weight-bearing radiographs demonstrated global first MTP joint space narrowing with a large dorsal osteophyte (Fig. 9.1). One can also appreciate the fixed second hammertoe deformity with subluxation at the second MTP joint. The patient elected to proceed with first MTP joint fusion and second toe distal metatarsal shortening osteotomy with hammertoe correction.
Fig. 9.1
(a, b) Preoperative AP and lateral radiographs
The standard dorsomedial approach described above was used (Fig. 9.2). Circumferential release was performed, and the proximal phalanx plantarflexed fully for preparation of the metatarsal head. A 0.062 inch K-wire was placed down the metatarsal shaft (Fig. 9.3) and central position confirmed with fluoroscopy (Fig. 9.4). A barrel-shaped starting reamer (Fig. 9.5) was then used to remove osteophytes and excessive bone to produce a smooth distal circumferential surface of the distal first metatarsal (Fig. 9.6). The articular surface of the metatarsal head was reamed with the concave reamer. Another 0.062 inch K-wire was then placed in the central position of the proximal phalanx (confirmed with fluoroscopy) and reamed with the convex reamer (Fig. 9.7). Both reamed surfaces were fenestrated using a 2.0 mm K-wire, which concluded the joint preparation portion of this procedure (Fig. 9.8). Wires from our preferred cannulated screw system were then inserted to the level of the joint, one anterograde through the proximal phalanx prepared surface and the other retrograde through the metatarsal head prepared surface (Fig. 9.9). The toe was positioned using the lid of one of the trays as a guide (Fig. 9.10), and the wires were driven across the joint. Fluoroscopic imaging confirmed a satisfactory position of the wires, and after measuring the appropriate-sized screws were inserted. Acceptable toe position was again confirmed at the conclusion of the case (Figs. 9.11 and 9.12). A 2-week postoperative AP radiograph of the foot is shown in Fig. 9.13.
Fig. 9.2
Incision mark for standard dorsomedial approach
Fig. 9.3
(a) Exposed metatarsal head and (b) K-wire in central metatarsal shaft
Fig. 9.4
(a, b) Central position of K-wire confirmed on fluoroscopy
Fig. 9.5
(a, b) “Barrel” reamer
Fig. 9.6
Metatarsal head after removal of circumferential osteophytes
Fig. 9.7
Reaming proximal phalanx articular surface
Fig. 9.8
Fully prepared proximal phalanx articular surface
Fig. 9.9
Positioning wires for cannulated screws
Fig. 9.10
Confirming appropriate clinical position of great toe
Figs. 9.11 and 9.12
Final clinical position of great toe