Exercise for Athletes with Diabetes


Contraindicated exercise

Recommended exercise
 
Swimming

Treadmill

Bicycling

Prolonged walking

Rowing

Jogging

Chair exercises

Step exercises

Arm exercises
 
Other non-weight-bearing exercises





15.6.3 Autonomic Neuropathy


The presence of autonomic neuropathy may limit an individual’s exercise capacity and increase the risk of an adverse cardiovascular event during or after exercise. Cardiac autonomic neuropathy (CAN) may be indicated by resting tachycardia (>100 beats per minute), orthostasis (lowering of systolic blood pressure >20 mmHg upon standing), or other disturbances in autonomic nervous system function involving the skin, pupils, or gastrointestinal or genitourinary systems. Sudden death and silent myocardial ischemia have been attributed to CAN in diabetes [27]. Resting or stress thallium myocardial scintigraphy is an appropriate noninvasive test for the presence and extent of macrovascular coronary artery disease in these individuals. Hypotension and hypertension after vigorous exercise are more likely to develop in patients with autonomic neuropathy, particularly when starting an exercise program. Because these individuals may have difficulty with thermoregulation, they should be advised to avoid exercise in hot or cold environments and to be vigilant about adequate hydration. Adequate hydration prior to exercise is recommended (e.g., 17 oz of fluid consumed 2 h before exercise). During exercise fluids should be taken early and frequently in an amount sufficient to compensate for losses in sweat. The reader is referred to Chap. 6 of this textbook for specific detailed scientific base research regarding adequate hydration recommendations.


15.6.4 Peripheral Arterial Disease


Evaluation of PAD is based on signs and symptoms, including intermittent claudication, cold feet, decreased or absent pulses, atrophy of subcutaneous tissue, and hair loss.


15.6.5 Retinopathy


The eye examination schedule should follow the American Diabetes Association’s Clinical Practice Guidelines [28]. For patients who have proliferative diabetic retinopathy (PDR) that is active, strenuous activity may precipitate vitreous hemorrhage or traction retinal detachment. High-volume moderate-resistance exercise has been shown to result in fluctuation in systolic blood pressure to generally less than 180 mm and is probably safe. However, athletes with proliferative retinopathy should exercise caution when attempting exercises that involve Valsalva maneuvers or sudden jarring motions.

On the basis of Joslin Clinic experience, the degree of diabetic retinopathy has been used to stratify the risk of exercise and to individually tailor the exercise recommendations. Table 15.2 noted below provides viable considerations for activity limitations in diabetic retinopathy clients.


Table 15.2
Considerations for activity limitation in diabetic retinopathy (DR)


















Mild nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy

reevaluation suggested in 6–12 months
 

Moderate nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy

reevaluation in 4–6 months

Discourage activities that dramatically elevate blood pressure

– Power lifting

– Heavy Valsalva

Severe nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy

reevaluation in 2–4 months

Discourage activities that substantially increase systolic blood pressure, Valsalva maneuvers, and active jarring:

– Boxing

– Heavy competitive sports

Proliferative diabetic retinopathy-acceptable activities:

– Low-impact cardiovascular conditioning

– Swimming (not diving)

– Walking

– Low-impact aerobics

– Stationary cycling

– Endurance exercises

Reevaluation in 1–2 months (may require laser surgery)

Discourage strenuous activities,

Valsalva maneuvers, pounding, or jarring:

– Weight lifting

– Jogging

– High-impact aerobics

– Racket sports

– Strenuous trumpet playing


15.6.6 Nephropathy


Many patients with long-standing diabetes mellitus and no proteinuria at rest will develop significant proteinuria after an intensive exercise session. Active individuals should be instructed not to engage in intensive activity prior to assessment for proteinuria. The predictive value for such exercise-related increments of urinary protein on the subsequent development of renal disease is still undetermined.

Athletes with diabetes do not have a higher incidence of end-stage renal disease in cross-sectional studies. Specific exercise recommendations have not been developed for patients with incipient (microalbuminuria >20 albumin excretion) or overt nephropathy (>200 mg/min) [29]. Patients with overt nephropathy often have a reduced capacity for exercise which leads to self-limitation in activity level. Although there is no clear reason to limit low to moderate intensity forms of activity, very high-intensity or strenuous exercises should probably be discouraged as the hemodynamic consequences are likely to be detrimental. Many athletes use dietary supplements very high in protein and these should be avoided in the presence of renal disease as high protein intake may accelerate loss of renal function.



15.7 Preparing for Exercise


A standard recommendation for athletes with diabetes is that exercises include a proper warm-up and cooldown period. A warm-up should consist of 5–10 min of aerobic activity (walking, cycling, etc.) at low-intensity level.

After a short warm-up, muscles should be gently stretched for another 5–10 min. Following the activity session, a cooldown should be structured similarly to the warm-up. The cooldown should last about 5–10 min and gradually bring the heart rate down to its pre-exercise level. Many exercise-related arrhythmias occur during the postexercise recovery period and it has been suggested the high levels of FFA that occur when exercise is abruptly terminated may contribute. A cooldown period will blunt this response.

There are several considerations that are particularly important and specific for the individuals with diabetes.



  • High-resistance exercise using weights may be acceptable for young individuals with diabetes, but not for older individuals or those with long-standing diabetes. Moderate weight training programs that utilize light weights and high repetitions can be used for maintaining or enhancing muscle strength in nearly all patients with diabetes.


  • Readily digestible, well-tolerated foods and suitable timing prevent exercising with a full stomach. Meals should contain complex carbohydrates and proteins for satiety. Hypertonic drinks (high carbohydrates) reduce gastric emptying speed leading to gastric dilatation. This can cause nausea and impair performance in athletic activity. These drinks also cause a sharp spike in blood glucose level. Instead isotonic drinks with 5–8 g of carbohydrates/100 ml are more advisable for rehydration.


15.8 Exercise Prescription


The recommendations given below may be useful for previously sedentary patients with diabetes who wish to initiate serious programs of physical activity. These exercise prescription categories include the following considerations:


15.8.1 Type of Exercise


Aerobic-type activities, for example, swimming, cycling, and brisk walking, are usually recommended to patients with diabetes mellitus. These exercises result in improved insulin sensitivity and enhanced glucose disposal per unit of muscle mass. Recent studies [11] suggest that a single bout of resistance-type exercise reduced the prevalence of hyperglycemia by as much as 35 ± 7 % during the 24 h postexercise period when compared with the control (no-exercise) experiment. A similar 33 ± 11 % reduction in the prevalence of hyperglycemia was observed following a corresponding 45 min bout of endurance-type exercise. Previously, the benefits of resistance-type exercise training on glycemic control have often been ascribed to an increase in muscle mass over time and concomitant expansion of glucose disposal capacity [12]. However, recent studies have shown that a single bout of resistance-type exercise improves glycemic control for up to 24 h following exercise, without changes in muscle mass.

Studies [30] have shown that athletes with type 1 diabetes mellitus might benefit from resistance exercise. Resistance exercise is associated with improvements in muscular strength [31], improved lipid profiles, lower insulin needs, and lower self-monitored blood glucose levels in individuals with type 1 diabetes mellitus. More exercise-associated glycemic fluctuations were observed with aerobic exercise compared with resistance exercise. Resistance exercise may be more beneficial as far as glucose stability is concerned. Meanwhile, it should also be noted that postexercise hypoglycemia might occur more frequently in individuals who have changed their exercise routine to incorporate resistance training or for patients unaccustomed to exercise.

To summarize, a single session of resistance- or endurance-type exercise substantially reduces the prevalence of hyperglycemia and improves glycemic control during the subsequent 24 h period.


15.8.2 Intensity and Duration of Exercise


There have been few studies regarding the optimal duration of exercise necessary to maximize beneficial metabolic effects. Exercise of less than 15–20 min duration generally results in poor training effect, whereas sessions of greater than 45 min are associated with an increased incidence of musculoskeletal injuries. Interestingly, rest periods of up to 90 s every 5 min have little effect on improved fitness for a given total amount of exercise, and frequent brief rest periods are probably a good strategy for older and more sedentary patients who cannot tolerate sustained exercise of even low intensity [32].

Optimization of a specific physiological or metabolic effect may require different levels of exercise intensity. In terms of glucose disposal, exercise of 30 % of their maximum aerobic capacity or less has been associated with little benefit. At exercise intensities of greater than 50 % of maximum aerobic capacity, improvements in glucose disposal are related to the total work performed. Thus, a decrease in intensity can be compensated for to some degree by an increase in duration of exercise. Other metabolic parameters, e.g., lipid metabolism and coagulation parameters, may require workloads of different intensities and frequencies. At any rate, it appears reasonable to recommend an exercise intensity of 50–70 % of maximum aerobic capacity for most individuals. This can be prescribed in terms of heart rate, which can easily be monitored by patients.

An estimate of the target pulse can be obtained using the following formula [32]:



$$ \begin{array}{l}\mathrm{Target}\;\mathrm{pulse}=0.5\;\mathrm{t}\mathrm{o}\;0.7\\ {}\kern3.72em \left(\mathrm{maximal}\;\mathrm{heart}\;\mathrm{rate}-\mathrm{resting}\;\mathrm{heart}\;\mathrm{rate}\right)\;\\ {}\kern9.599999em +\mathrm{resting}\;\mathrm{heart}\;\mathrm{rate}.\end{array} $$

Resting heart rate should be measured by the patient before getting out of bed in the morning. It should be kept in mind that estimates of maximal heart rate derived from standard tables based on normal populations correlate poorly with maximal heart rates of patients with diabetes. The exercise program can be initiated at a target pulse corresponding to about 50 % of maximum aerobic capacity and gradually increased to the desired range over a 3–4-week period.


15.8.3 Frequency of Exercise


The optimal frequency of exercise regimens is unknown. If transient effects of individual exercise bouts are of paramount importance, it is likely that exercise of greater frequency will result in maximal metabolic benefit. One cannot fully compensate for a decreased frequency of exercise by increasing the intensity of individual exercise sessions, and, in general, exercise frequencies of less than 3–4 times a week do not result in substantial benefits. For many type 1 diabetes mellitus patients, a daily exercise regimen will allow for more predictable insulin dosing and more stable metabolic control. For some patients brief, intense interval exercise bouts undertaken immediately before breakfast, lunch, and dinner had a greater impact on postprandial and subsequent 24 h glucose concentrations then a single bout of continuous exercise [33].


15.8.4 Time of Day


In general, patient convenience is the major determinant of time of exercise. However, insulin resistance is greater early in the day, and because of the relatively transient effects of exercise on glucose disposal, it is likely that exercise done in the morning will have the greatest impact on glycemic excursions throughout the day. Exercise sessions in the evening may be associated with a higher risk of unappreciated hypoglycemia overnight, and assessment of glucose in the early morning hours may be necessary.


15.8.5 Exercise and Cardiovascular Disease


Studies done in the past have uniformly shown that exercise training restores myocardial structure and performance, with increasing resistance to ischemia and favorable metabolic effects. A recent study showed that weight loss in patients enrolled in an exercise program may have a beneficial effect on myocardial function, but the relative roles of exercise and weight loss require further definition [34, 35].


15.8.6 Effects on the Components of the Metabolic Syndrome



15.8.6.1 Hypertension


Physical training is associated with a modest (5–10 mmHg) decrease in systolic and diastolic blood pressure and a modest decrease in the percentage of patients who go on to require antihypertensive medication. Benefits are at least as good and possibly better in older subjects and women. Improvements are most likely to be noted in the more insulin-resistant hyperinsulinemic patients.


15.8.6.2 Hyperlipidemia


The most consistent effect of regular exercise is a transient decrease in plasma triglyceride levels, which often fall by up to 30 %. Changes in LDL cholesterol have not been consistently demonstrated, but exercise does appear to diminish the concentration of a small, dense subclass of LDL that may be more strongly associated with atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease [36]. Effects are greatest in more insulin-resistant hypertriglyceridemic patients. Increases in HDL cholesterol can occur but this generally required exercise of an intensity and duration seen in athletes but rarely achieved by most patients.


15.8.7 Role of Exercise in Prevention of Type 2 Diabetes


Research studies have shown that exercise prevents the progression to overt type 2 diabetes mellitus [37, 38]. Analysis of select populations has shown that the occurrence of type 2 diabetes mellitus is higher in sedentary as compared to physically active men. Regular exercise improves insulin sensitivity and decreases visceral adiposity. Although obesity is generally regarded as the major risk factor for development of type 2 diabetes mellitus [39], decreased physical activity independent of obesity has also been identified as an important predictor of the disease. Several studies have shown that exercise, by reversing insulin resistance, might delay the progression to type 2 diabetes mellitus.


15.9 Exercise in Special Athlete Groups



15.9.1 Swimming


Principles outlined for other types of exercise apply for swimming. In addition, athletes should note that their insulin absorption might decrease when swimming in cooler water. Heat increases absorption of insulin while cold decreases absorption. Extreme ambient temperatures (<36 F or >86 F) can affect insulin housed within the pump and interfere with insulin action.


15.9.2 Scuba Diving


The effects of scuba diving on those with diabetes have not been well established. Diabetes is listed as a contraindication by many scuba diving certification agencies. This is apparently based on the risk and subsequent consequences of hypoglycemia while diving. The interplay of diabetic complications, e.g., micro/macrovascular diseases, with diving physiology has not been considered the major limiting factor to diving. People with diabetes need to be primarily concerned with the prevention of hypoglycemia while scuba diving (and be prepared for in-water treatment of hypoglycemia), the possible relationship between diabetic complications and diving physiology (pressure, circulatory, and respiratory), and adequate training to anticipate and treat diabetes-related problems during diving.

For further details, please refer to ADA recommendations in “The Health Professional’s Guide to Diabetes and Exercise” [40].


15.10 Interaction of Commonly Used Drugs with Exercise



15.10.1 Alcohol


Some alcoholic beverages are used by athletes for hydration. Beer, for example, is a rich source of carbohydrate and can contribute to electrolyte replacement as well as water [41]. The contraindicated concerns with alcohol are as follows:

1.

It has a diuretic effect and can lead to dehydration.

 

2.

Alcohol is a glycogenolytic agent and initially causes a short-lived hyperglycemia. Subsequently, hypoglycemia is a more important consideration (due to exhaustion of glycogen stores and inhibition of hepatic glucose production). As little as two “shots” or two beers can inhibit gluconeogenesis by 80 %.

 


15.10.2 Beta Blockers


These agents have been reported to increase the incidence of hypoglycemia in some individuals. It is a rare side effect of the drug in type 2 diabetes mellitus where glucagon is preserved, but in long-standing type 1 diabetes mellitus or following pancreatectomy where there is a loss of glucagon, beta blockers may predispose to hypoglycemia and delay recovery from hypoglycemic events, especially in the presence of autonomic dysfunction. These agents need not be avoided but should be used with caution.


15.10.3 Sulfonylureas


Sulfonylureas work by stimulating the release of insulin from the beta cells of the pancreas and enhancing beta cell sensitivity to glucose. Sulfonylureas are effective in decreasing plasma glucose by 50–70 % and reducing HgA1c by 1.5–1.7. Sulfonylureas have the same general restrictions as insulin. They can cause hypoglycemia and weight gain. Dose reduction may be needed when starting exercise to prevent hypoglycemic episodes.


15.10.4 DPP-4 Inhibitors and GLP-1 Agonists


Both these classes of drug work by enhancing or mimicking the effects of GLP-1, a major gut incretin. DPP-4 inhibitors prevent the degradation of incretion, while GLP-1 agonists mimic the action of incretin. Due to their mechanism of action, the drugs help lower post-meal blood sugars. They have lesser propensity to cause hypoglycemia as compared to sulfonylureas. The average decrease in HgA1c after 24 weeks of therapy with DPP-4 inhibitors varies between 0.65 and 1.4 %. GLP-1 agonists have been shown to decrease HgA1c by 1.23 % in long-term studies.


15.10.5 Acarbose


Acarbose works by inhibiting alpha-glucosidase enzyme in the brush border of the small intestine and alpha amylase. These enzymes hydrolyze complex carbohydrates to glucose and other monosaccharides. Inhibition of the enzyme leads to slower and more prolonged glucose absorption. This helps lower the postprandial blood glucose levels. Since acarbose prevents the degradation of complex carbohydrates into glucose, some carbohydrates will be undigested and be delivered to the colon causing GI side effects like flatulence and diarrhea. While acarbose does not cause hypoglycemia, consumption of complex carbohydrates may fail to increase blood glucose levels when needed to prevent or treat hypoglycemia. Such patients should be instructed to use a simple glucose source such as glucose tablets or gel to treat hypoglycemic events.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Oct 16, 2016 | Posted by in SPORT MEDICINE | Comments Off on Exercise for Athletes with Diabetes

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access