Contractures and stiffness
Mark Lombardi
How can we explain the aging of a system built of non-aging elements?
LEONID AND NATALIA GAVRILOVA, HANDBOOK OF THE BIOLOGY OF AGING (2006, P 9)
Introduction
Stiffness, or the loss of joint mobility, is a common complaint of sedentary and elderly patients. Stiffness limits numerous functional activities in the daily life of an elderly individual by interfering with the initiation and completion of movement patterns. Decreased activity increases the incidence of frailty (Wilson, 2004). Frail individuals are at a significantly greater risk for poor outcomes in rehabilitation, and have also been reported to have higher levels of markers related to inflammation and clotting than do non-frail individuals. Frail individuals are clinically identified from those individuals having three of the five attributes of frailty: unintentional weight loss, muscle weakness, slow walking speed, exhaustion and low physical activity (Wilson, 2004).
In the elderly, exudation of fibrinogen into extracellular tissue spaces increases with decreased levels of activity, so more fibrin, an elastic filamentous protein, tends to be deposited in the tissue spaces of older persons. Protein aggregation, while widely reported to be a common physiological feature of aging, is not clearly understood. If physical activity is not maintained a complete breakdown of fibrin may not occur, and increased amounts of sticky fibrin may accumulate in the tissue spaces, producing the lesions that restrict movement between adjacent structures. Fibrinous adhesions also form in a localized area following damage to tissues. These fibrinous adhesions, commonly referred to as ‘cross-links’, occur naturally during periods of immobilization or inactivity (Pickles, 1983).
In many cases, restoration of normal physical activity is sufficient to cause the breakdown of fibrous adhesions. In some cases, when the mass has become consolidated, it may be necessary to intervene with massage, PNF, stretching (using low-load sustained, passive over-pressure), graded mobilization or manipulation techniques under anesthesia.
Common causes of stiffness
Traditionally, the clinician has accepted stiffness to be a natural part of the aging process, perhaps without identifying the actual causes, some of which may be prevented and/or treated. Four common causes of stiffness are:
• biomechanical changes in connective tissue and related structures
• hypokinesis (diminished or abnormally slow movement)
• arthritis (seen in both rheumatoid and osteoarthritis)
• trauma.
Biomechanical changes in connective tissue and related structures
Changes in the numerous properties of connective tissue and related structures contribute to the onset of stiffness in the elderly; a select few are highlighted here.
Myofibroblasts
Connective tissue cells that produce unusually large amounts of contractile proteins are termed myofibroblasts. When damage occurs in connective tissue, there are two stages of response: cell multiplication and increased cellular secretion. If hyperplasia creates excessive production of actomyosin, the resulting contractile force may be significant enough to prevent normal range of motion in the affected area.
In addition, numerous studies describe the natural loss of muscle mass in the aged. Mayer et al. note that muscle strength decreases gradually between the third and fifth decade of life (Mayer et al., 2011: 359). They describe an ‘accelerated, non-linear decrease of muscle mass up to 15% that has been shown to increase to as much as 30% by the 8th decade in sedentary geriatric patients’. Other studies (Watson, 2000; Brennan, 2002) report the rate of muscle mass loss to be more gradual, stating that losses of 3–5% are seen following the sixth decade of life. In their studies, Watson (2000) and Brennan (2002) also reported strength loss as high as 30% per decade after age 60.
Strength loss studies suggest that traditional aerobic and endurance training activities employed in rehabilitation, while effective in the reduction of coronary heart disease, may also contribute to positive changes in both muscle strength and bone density (Wallace & Cumming, 2000; Kean et al., 2004).
Mayer et al. (2011) cite several studies supporting these findings, suggesting that muscle mass may be increased with training intensities ranging from 60% to 85% of a patient’s maximum voluntary strength (Mayer et al., 2011). In their research, Mayer et al. cite training effects having a positive effect on the maintenance of muscle strength through gains in muscle mass. Unfortunately, they also report compliance as clinicians’ greatest obstacle, noting that current studies show that only 10–15% of the elderly participate in regular training sessions.
Collagen
Collagen is the main supportive protein in skin, tendon, bone, cartilage and connective tissue. A decrease in the elasticity of collagen and volume of ground substance is associated with the aging process. In addition, cross-linking between collagen fibers increases with age, inactivity and trauma, thereby restricting mobility of the connective tissue.
The decrease in ground substance creates a loss of critical interfiber distance which restricts the ability of the fibers to move smoothly over each other. With intervertebral disc disease of the spine, decreased collagen mobility may compromise not only spinal mobility, but also spine length. Changes in the length of the spine may also impair breathing patterns in the geriatric patient (Wilson, 2004).
Contractures, frequently the result of tight joint capsules, fibrotic or short muscles, or other scar tissues, are part fibrous adhesions and part collagenous shortening. Newly developed contractures have a greater portion of fibrinous adhesions, whereas chronic contractures are more collagenous. Normal activity may break down fibrinous adhesions, but collagenous shortening often requires heat, prolonged low-load progressive stretching and possible surgical manipulation.
Hyaluronic Acid
Hyaluronic acid is secreted from the hyaline (articular) cartilage that covers the surface of synovial joints. Compression of the joint enhances this secretion which entraps the synovial fluid among the hyaluronic acid molecules and lubricates the joint during movement. Secretion of hylauronic acid decreases with age, thus causing a diminution in the effectiveness of joint lubrication (Pickles, 1983). Another source of joint stiffness is said to occur as a result of ‘articular gelling’. In healthy joints surface-active phospholipids (SAPL) inhibit the ‘gelling’ process (Hills & Thomas, 1998). What triggers the ‘deactivation’ of SAPL in the joint is not known.
Cartilage
Cartilage, having no direct blood supply of its own, receives its nutrients from the blood flow in adjacent bones and the synovial fluid in the joint cavity. Chondroblasts secrete a glycoprotein (chondroitin sulfate) into the surrounding matrix and, through osmosis, attract water containing dissolved gases, inorganic salts and other organic materials necessary for normal cartilage cell metabolism. Dehydration of the cartilage occurs with increasing age due to decreased secretion of chondroitin sulfate (Pickles, 1983). Normal loading and unloading of cartilage is necessary for the movement of nutrients in and out of the chondrocytes. Without joint compression, metabolites remain in the matrix and oxygen content is lowered, causing a reduction in glycoprotein secretion and an increase in the collagen precursor, procollagen. This process may convert hyaline cartilage to fibrocartilage. Degeneration of the cartilage is not reversible. However, further deleterious changes in the cartilage can be avoided through initiation of regular activities that promote alternating compression and expansion (relaxation) of the joint resulting in increased nutrition to the cartilaginous tissue.
Hypokinesis
Too little, or less than normal movement is termed hypokinesis. Joints or muscles left in a lengthened (extension) or shortened (flexion) state for prolonged periods may develop collagenous adhesions. To reduce the incidence of adhesions, physical activity several times during the day should be encouraged. Patient compliance is one major problem confronting clinicians’ successful treatment of their patients (Watson, 2000; Brennan, 2002). Clinicians are encouraged to individualize patient programs, seeking movement patterns that the patient is comfortable with, and interested in, in an effort to increase patient compliance. Recommendations include identifying specific activities (sports, hobbies, life skills) that interest the patient when developing intervention strategies.
Arthritis
Arthritis is reported to be the most common cause of disability in adults aged 18 and over (Kelley et al., 2011). The American Rheumatological Association (Wheeless, 2011) states that for a patient to be diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis they must report at least 5 of the following 7 conditions or symptoms over a period greater than 6 weeks:
• pain on motion, or tenderness in at least one joint
• swelling (soft tissue thickening or fluid, not bony overgrowth alone) in at least one joint
• swelling of at least one other joint (any interval free of joint symptoms between the two joints)
• poor mucin precipitate from synovial fluid
• characteristic histologic changes in synovium