CHAPTER TEN Case studies in mental health
Introduction
Physiotherapy should ‘promote, maintain and restore physical, psychological and social well-being’ (Chartered Society of Physiotherapy 2002a).
‘Mental health problems affect one in four of us at some time in our lives. They can also be the result of drug or alcohol dependency, illness or long-term physical disability’ (Chartered Society of Physiotherapy 2005).
Provision of, and access to, a specialist, physiotherapy, mental health service varies dramatically dependent upon geographical location. Some services focus on older adults while others have input into all age groups. ‘Care-group’-specific services may occur for eating disorders, personality disorder, primary care anxiety disorders or addictive behaviours. There are specific facilities for forensic mental health, which deal with people who are detained in a special hospital or secure unit following a court judgement that their offence was wholly or partially due to their mental ill health.
Wherever the physiotherapist works effective input occurs when the wider team together with the client and carers are involved, as stated in ‘New Ways of Working for Psychiatrists, Enhancing Person Centred Care by…True Multidisciplinary Working’ (DoH 2005).
Skills transfer between other specialties and mental health can range from musculoskeletal to continence, from neurological to respiratory but specific skills of anxiety management, massage, communication in challenging situations may best be learnt in the mental health environment. Our work correlates with the government drivers of the wellbeing agenda which include the National Service Framework (NSF) for Mental Health (DoH 1999) and the NSF for Older Adults (DoH 2001) along with Our Health, Our Care, Our Say (DoH 2006).
CASE STUDY 1 Back pain and lifestyle, a holistic approach
Subjective assessment
Psychiatric history
37-year-old man experiencing a psychotic depression
He has been under the care of mental health services for the past 5 years following an unsuccessful suicide attempt. As a result of which the patient was admitted to an acute psychiatric ward under a section 3 of the Mental Health Act 1983. This allowed a period in which to assess and treat him
He was discharged from the ward after 3/12 and has since been under the care of a CMHT
He is seen regularly by a community psychiatric nurse (CPN) who helps him to take his medication
He is currently reviewed at 6/12 intervals. The CPA meeting is an opportunity for all people involved in the patients care to come together and discuss his progress and ongoing needs (Mental Health Act 1983 Code of Practice (1999))
He has been referred to a mental health physiotherapist by the CPN for back pain
HPC
Has gained approximately 4 stone over the past 3 years since starting an antipsychotic medication
Investigations
X-ray – taken 2 years ago at the initial onset of back pain. This showed no abnormality
SH
Lives alone in a one-bedroom flat and has few friends
Once a week he plays snooker at a voluntary sector mental health drop-in centre
Has a very sedentary life and does not engage in any other physical activity
Diet consists entirely of takeaways
Unable do his own shopping as he gets very anxious in busy environments
Objective assessment
Lumbar ROM
Flexion was half normal range as was side flexion bilaterally
Extension was approximately three-quarters normal range
Pain was reported at end of available range flexion and extension
CASE STUDY 2 Chronic back and leg pain
He was also referred on by the physiotherapist to the psychiatrist for further assessment of his mental health.
Subjective assessment
Patient’s perception
Feels unable to cope with the pain and the disability as he is in pain when doing ‘everything’
Believes the reason for his condition worsening is general deterioration
SH
Lives with his wife, no children
His wife has given up her job to look after him. She is extremely supportive and admits to having a major role in supporting and assisting 24 hours per day, including all aspects of daily living including driving him to appointments with his solicitor or to hospitals, making all meals and drinks, managing his medication, dealing with solicitor and appointments
He has no social life, no hobbies and spends little time out of the home
He has no contact with his family but does see his mother and father-in-law weekly
The patient worked as a car mechanic for 15 years but has been off sick for the last 4 years
He has a claim against employers for an accident which is being dealt with by his solicitor
Mental health assessment
Good eye contact and speech normal in flow and content
Gives a comprehensive picture of his symptoms
Concentration was good throughout the assessment
Orientated to time, place and person
There were no thoughts or plans of suicide or self-harm
He describes feeling hopeless about his situation
Has no enjoyment of meals but no weight loss
Objective assessment
On questioning no evidence of any red flags.
Thoracic spine: unable to achieve full extension. Pain at half range.
Lumbar spine: unable to achieve full extension. Pain at half range.
Axial loading was positive – eliciting pain when pressing down on the top of the patient’s head.
He complained of superficial tenderness – skin discomfort on light palpation.
Screening tools
The distress and risk assessment method (DRAM; Main 1992) combines screening tools of the modified somatic perception questionnaire (MSPQ; Main 1983) and the Zung self-rating depression scale (Zung 1965).
CASE STUDY 3 Somatization
Subjective assessment
PC
20-year-old woman admitted to a specialist mental health unit for a period of assessment and rehabilitation
Functional movement in right arm sufficient to drink through a straw and to eat
Presented no movement in her left arm and legs
Extensive investigations failed to identify an organic cause for this level of disability
SH
2 years ago moved into a boarding school for disabled children
Presently awaiting her A level results prior to taking up a university place
Parents divorced when she was 3 years old
Objective assessment
Dependent on nursing staff using the hoist to transfer her from bed to chair
No apparent movement in her legs and poorly defined muscle bulk throughout lower limbs
Barthel Index score (indicates how independently patient is managing ADLs) – 15/20
Writhing movements of her right arm frequently taking her out of her base of support
Her head moved continuously in a nodding motion
Right shoulder and arm also moved constantly
Predominant posture – flexed elbow with flexion and medially deviation at the wrist