Fig. 12.1
a–b X-rays of very small proximal pole nonunion. (Published with kind permission of ©Christophe Mathoulin 2015. All Rights Reserved)
Management Options
Conventional grafting by open techniques does not always achieve a satisfactory union rate. The advent of vascularized grafts was an indisputable technical advancement that enhanced the vascularity of the proximal pole and improved the union rate. However, the surgical technique is challenging, especially in the case of a small proximal pole fragment.
Management Chosen
After a discussion with the patient, he agreed to completely stop smoking for a minimum of 1 month before surgery. The surgical procedure consisted of a fixation method that captured the body and proximal pole of the scaphoid, along with the lunate in the radio-ulnar axis, in combination with insertion of cancellous bone autograft .
Surgical Procedure
The patient was operated 1 month and a half after smoking cessation. The procedure was performed on an outpatient basis under regional anesthesia and with an arm tourniquet.
First Step: Graft Harvesting
The graft was harvested from the lateral radius through a longitudinal incision centered over the radial styloid process. The cutaneous and sensory branches of the radial nerve were protected. Subperiosteal dissection between the first and second extensor compartments was carried out to keep the tendon sheaths intact. A three-sided osteotomy was made on the lateral cortex of the radial styloid; a bone lid was created that had a proximal hinge. The graft was harvested with a curette and about twice the estimated volume of the defect was taken. The bone lid was then repositioned and the first and second compartments were spontaneously repositioned so as to stabilize the harvest site.
Second Step: Arthroscopic Bone Grafting
Axial traction was placed on the wrist. The arthroscope was inserted into the midcarpal joint through the ulnar midcarpal portal (2 cm distal and 2 cm ulnar to Lister’s tubercle) to explore the distal aspect of the scaphoid. The nonunion was confirmed. Reduction was achieved using simple axial traction on the thumb. Thorough cleaning and curettage of the two scaphoid surfaces was carried out using a curette and shaver through the radial midcarpal portal (2 cm distal to Lister’s tubercle). This step can be done with or without fluid; however, dry arthroscopy is required for graft insertion. The cannula from a 3.0-mm burr was inserted through the radial midcarpal portal up to the defect between the proximal pole and the body of the scaphoid. The graft material was pushed using the head of the burr into the bone defect site, and then compacted using a spatula (Figs. 12.2a, b).
Fig. 12.2
a Drawing and b arthroscopic view showing the way to push the cancellous bone graft into the bone loss of the scaphoid nonunion, using the burr. (Published with kind permission of ©Christophe Mathoulin 2015. All Rights Reserved)
Third Step: Fixation by Scapholunate Pinning
We used a typical percutaneous scapholunate pinning method under arthroscopic and fluoroscopic control. Two pins were driven percutaneously into the radial aspect of the wrist, through the distal body of the scaphoid, so as to bridge the graft area, secure the proximal pole and then was advanced into the lunate (Fig. 12.3)