Anterior Cruciate Transection/Disruption Models of Post-Traumatic Arthritis


Strain

ACL-T type

Surgery age

Exp. time

Results

Reference

Unknown

Stab incision

Unknown

1–26 weeks

OA changes in articular cartilage (fibrillation, loss of cells in superficial layer); synovitis subsides within 1 week

[4]

Varies

Stab incision

Adult

1–48 weeks

Periarticular osteophytes seen weeks 3–48 in marginal zone

[5]

Varies

Stab incision

2 years

3, 6, 9, 48 weeks

Thicker cartilage observed; chondrocytes synthesize GAGs with more chondroitin sulfate vs. keratin sulfate than normal

[8]

Foxhounds, Collies, Alsatians

Stab incision

2 years

1–48 weeks

Experimental, biochemical, morphological changes observed

[7]

Greyhounds

Stab incision

2–3 years

6, 12 weeks

Significant ↓ in tension, compression, shear; significant ↑ in hydraulic permeability, hydration of cartilage matrix

[10]

Mongrel dog

Stab incision

2–3 years

12 weeks

↑ chondrocyte apoptosis, caspase 3, and Bcl-2 in articular cartilage; L-NIL (NO inhibitor) group showed ↓ apoptosis, caspase 3 after ACL-T

[12]

Mongrel dog

Stab incision

2–3 years

12 weeks

↑ IL-1-converting enzyme (ICE), IL-18 in articular cartilage; ↓ PI-9; ICE not regulated by NO

[6]

Mongrel dog

Stab incision

2–3 years

8 weeks

↑ gene expression of MMP-13, cathepsin K, ADAMTS-4, ADAMTS-5, 5-lipoxygenase in OA; ↑ bone loss and osteoclast staining of MMP-13, cathepsin K; licofelone ↓ OA changes

[9, 13]

Mongrel dog

Stab incision

2–3 years

8, 12 weeks

↑ osteocalcin week 8; ↑ MMP, PGE2 at week 12; ↓ NO levels in trabecular bone at week 12

[14]

Beagle

Stab incision

1 year

6, 12, 24, 48 weeks

Subchondral bone edema in tibia by week 6; articular cartilage erosion by week 12; menisci degeneration by week 24; osteophytes by week 48

[11]

Beagle

Stab incision

1–2 years

6, 12, 24, 48 weeks

Elevation of collagen I, II early; ↑ MMP-13 week 24; ↑ aggrecan, tenascin C week 48

[15]



After the introduction of the Pond-Nuki transection model (stab incision), other methods of ACL-T were studied. Brandt published a review validating the use of the canine ACL-T model for the study of arthritis [16], and open induction models were implemented, where the ACL was visualized and transected either through an arthrotomy or arthroscopically. A wide range of studies followed, looking at aspects of open-induction ACL-T such as biochemical changes and gene expression [1724], bone morphological changes [2528], biomarkers [2931], and imaging techniques [32, 33]. O’Connor and coworkers published two studies looking at the combined effect of nerve removal and ACL-T on the development of PTA [34, 35]. Two therapeutic studies used the open-induction ACL-T model, including a doxycycline therapy study [36] and an MMP inhibitor study [37]. Doom and coworkers published a review of immunopathological mechanisms that result from the ACL-T model, leading to PTA [38]. A summary of the studies using the open-induction canine ACL-T model are listed in Table 6.2 below.


Table 6.2
Canine ACL-T model (open induction)























































































































































Strain

ACL-T type

Surgery age

Exp. time

Results

Reference

Varies

Arthrotomy

Adult

45, 54 months

Articular cartilage thicker at month 36, focal loss at month 45; osteophyte formation; ulceration of articular cartilage on medial side; fibrous thickening of capsule

[27, 28]

Varies

Not specified

Adult

Unknown

Neurectomy + ACL-T resulted in significantly higher OA scores than neurectomy without ACL-T, ACL-T

[35]

Varies

Not specified

Adult

72 weeks

Dorsal root ganglionectomy (DRG) + ACL-T after results in significantly severe OA compared to ACL-T, ACL-T + DRG, DRG

[34]

Beagles

Arthroscopic

Adult

16 weeks

Loss of tensile properties and remodeling of collagen network in surface zone of articular cartilage

[18]

Mixed breeds

Cranial transection

2–7 years

4, 10, 32 weeks

Aggrecan mRNA ↑ weeks 10, 32; collagen type II mRNA ↑ at all time points; transcription mechanisms must differ

[20]

Mongrel dog

Lateral arthrotomy

1–3 years

3, 12 weeks

Structural changes in trabeculae in cancellous bone at 3 weeks, more prominent at 12 weeks; ↓ anisotropy-accompanied changes

[25]

Mixed breeds

Lateral arthrotomy

2–7 years

3, 12 weeks

20–38-fold ↑ collagen type I, VI at 3 weeks; 11–19-fold ↑ at 12 weeks; higher concentrations in medial menisci versus lateral

[24]

Varies

Naturally occurring

1–13 years

N/A

MMP-3, TIMP-1 ↑ in SF of arthritic groups; KS ↑ in SF after ACL rupture

[29]

Mixed breeds

Lateral arthrotomy

Adult

3, 12 weeks

↑ aggrecan, collagen type II mRNA in cartilage; amount of collagen type II > aggrecan for OA

[21]

Foxhound

Medial arthrotomy

2 years

2 years

Cartilage changes of decorin, fibromodulin, aggrecan differ in models

[19]

Mongrel dog

Cranial transection

Adult

12 weeks

Significant changes from μMRI: depth of maximum T2, ↓ SF zone thickness, ↑ total cartilage thickness; PLM confirmed

[32]

Mixed breeds

Cranial transection

Adult

3, 12 weeks

Collagen type II markers ↑ in SF; collagen type II, aggrecan markers ↑ in serum; collagen type II markers ↑ in urine

[30]

Mixed breed

Lateral arthrotomy

Adult

36, 72 weeks

Mechanical changes in ACL-T group at 36 weeks less noticeable in both ACL-T and ACL-T + Dox group; Dox therapy limited bone loss at week 72

[36]

Walker hounds

Arthroscopic

Adult

2, 10, 18 weeks

PGE2 levels ↑ through study; correlated with gait, pain

[31]

Foxhound

Not specified

2–3 years

2 years

Minor/severe articular cartilage damage in medial compartment; joint space significantly ↑ for minor group, no change for severe group; minor group had 73 % of observed osteophytes; severity of damage of menisci and cartilage related

[33]

Varies

Naturally occurring

Adult

N/A

↑ cathepsin-K+ cells in CCL-ruptured group; TRAP+ cell levels correlate with inflammation

[17]

Varies

Naturally occurring

3–8 years

N/A

Treatment of CCL-explant cells with COL-3 (MMP inhibitor) led to ↓ collagen fragment generation

[37]

Varies

Naturally occurring

Adult

N/A

↑ Cathepsin-KMMP-9, TRAP in SF of OA group; TRAP ↑ OA versus other arthritis groups; matrix turnover/immune response genes ↑ in OA

[23]

Varies

Naturally occurring

Adult

N/A

CD4+, CD8+, CD3 + CD4-CD8-lymphocytes ↑ in CCL-ruptured dogs; CD3 + CD4-CD8-lymphocyte levels in SF inversely correlated to radiographic OA

[22]



Sheep Model


The use of sheep has not been widely utilized for the study of PTA; however, sheep may provide advantages because of their large joint size, which allows for the analysis of biochemical and biomechanical measures that may not be able to be performed in human subjects [3941]. As with other large animals, sheep can readily undergo arthroscopic surgery and MRI observation, allowing for more direct translation of studies to the clinic. However, there are limited reagents and antibodies available, and until recently, a limited mapped genome for sheep, making it difficult for genetic studies [13]. Furthermore, their large size is a disadvantage in testing novel pharmacologic interventions. Most studies utilizing the ACL-T model in sheep have focused on radiographic tracking and kinematics of PTA. O’Brien and coworkers examined the effects of immediate reconstruction of the transected ACL on cartilage degeneration and osteophyte formation [41], while Atarod and coworkers examined the kinematic loads placed on soft tissue after ACL-T in the sheep [39]. A summary of the use of ovine ACL-T models is in Table 6.3 below.


Table 6.3
Ovine ACL-T models
































Strain

ACL-T type

Surgery age

Exp. time

Results

Reference

Suffolk-cross

Arthrotomy + reconstruction

3–4 months

4, 20 weeks

ACL-R group had ↑ cartilage + osteophyte scores compared to controls; some OA development

[41]

Suffolk-cross

Arthroscopic

3 years

20 weeks

Load redistribution after ACL-T led to a significant ↓ in both PCL and LCL loads; no change in MCL loads

[39]


Cat Model


Neuromuscular control has been extensively studied in cats, as well as muscle mechanics and locomotion [42]. Logically, cats would be well suited to study interventions towards musculoskeletal diseases, such as PTA that results from an ACL-T injury. Cats are advantageous to use because of their large size and known genome. However, like dogs, cats can be costly to house during experiments, and public perception and their role as companion animals discourage the use of cats for research [13].

Herzog and coworkers first studied the effect of ACL-T in cats on hindlimb loading and changes in articular cartilage [42]. Khalsa and coworkers studied the effect of severing the nerves associated with the joint capsule after ACL-T [43]. Herzog and coworkers monitored cats for a year, using force testing plates and radiographs to track kinematic and radiographic changes due to OA [44, 45]. Boyd and coworkers studied the changes to the periarticular bone as a result of ACL-T, while Clark and coworkers studied the adaptive response of cartilage after ACL-T [46, 47]. A summary of the studies utilizing feline ACL-T models follow in Table 6.4.


Table 6.4
Feline ACL-T models




























































Strain

ACL-T type

Surgery age

Exp. time

Results

Reference

Outbred

Anterior capsulotomy

1–3 years

4, 12, 35 weeks

↓ in muscle mass in ACL-T knee; ↑ in cell density, hexuronic acid in articular cartilage at weeks 12 and 35

[42]

Outbred

Lateral arthrotomy

Adult

0 days

Mechanoreceptor neurons in joint capsule are not affected by ACL-T

[43]

Outbred

Arthroscopic

Adult

16 weeks

Significant ↑ in articular cartilage thickness, significant ↓ in stiffness in ACL-T knee

[44]

Outbred

Arthroscopic

Adult

Ongoing (1 year)

↑ in knee instability, osteophyte formation, articular cartilage thickness, joint degeneration

[45]

Outbred

Anterior capsulotomy

Adult

16 weeks, 60 months

Significant ↓ in cancellous bone mass, subchondral bone thickness at 60 months; ACL-T intensified bone changes compared to control

[46]

Outbred

Anterior capsulotomy

Adult

16 weeks

↑ patellar articular cartilage, larger chondrocytes, more chondrocyte clusters, larger chondrocyte volume fraction; no femoral groove cartilage adaptation

[47]


Rabbit Model


Rabbits have been a popular model for use with both ACL-T and meniscus injury models because of their low spontaneous joint degeneration, large joint size, and ease in use for testing new therapeutic agents. Rabbits preferentially load their lateral side, unlike rodents, and have the capability to spontaneous regenerate transected menisci with fibrous tissue, which can cause disadvantages for some studies. Similarly, rabbits have altered joint biomechanics, potentially resulting in a change in disease pathology compared to what may be expected in other animals. However, rabbits have been widely used as a model for OA because they form lesions similar to those seen in clinical OA [13].

The ACL-T model has been used in rabbits to study many aspects of PTA development. Studies have examined articular cartilage and meniscus properties [4850], gene expression and surface receptors [5153], osteophytes [54], bone properties [55, 56], and imaging techniques [57, 58]. The rabbit ACL-T model has also been used to test out therapeutics, such as HA therapy [59] and oral glucosamine supplements [60]. Furthermore, one study compared surgically induced ACL-T versus a blunt trauma ACL-T, which closely resembles clinical ACL-T in humans [61]. Studies using rabbit models of ACL-T are summarized in Table 6.5.


Table 6.5
Rabbit ACL-T models


























































































Strain

ACL-T type

Surgery age

Exp. time

Results

Reference

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

8–12 months

9 weeks

[Articular cartilage] Significant ↓ modulus (18 %); ↓ in GAG density; significant ↑ water content

[50]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

12 months

9 weeks

Menisci from ACL-T knees had degenerative changes; high # of apoptotic cells on medial side of menisci; ↑ nitrotyrosine reactivity

[48]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

9–10 months

2, 4, 9 weeks

Rapid ↑in MMP-1, -3, -13 gene expression in articular cartilage; aggrecanase-1, -2 levels stable

[51]

New Zealand

Anterolateral capsulotomy

12 months

3, 8 weeks

Matrix deterioration; medial menisci showed cell-depleted areas, cell clusters, altered cell distribution; ↑ collagen type I, III staining lat/med; ↑ collagen type II staining on med side only

[49]

New Zealand

Anterolateral capsulotomy

12 months

3, 8 weeks

Significant ↑ RNA yield from med menisci only; significant ↓ DNA yield from med menisci week 8; significant ↑ collagen type I, TIMP-1; significant ↓ decorin, TNF-α, IGF-2; more mRNA changes by medial/lateral side

[52]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

12 months

4, 9, 12 weeks

Osteophytes present in femur and tibia compartments by week 12; hypertrophic chondrocytes in osteophytes produce VEGF; NO production/chondrocyte death during osteophyte formation

[54]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

Adult

2, 8 weeks

Can detect synovial effusion, menisci/ligament lesions, and osteophytes accurately using MRI

[57]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

2.5 years

4, 8, 12 weeks

Bone loss 4 and 8 weeks after, but returns to baseline by week 12; osteophyte volume significantly ↑ at weeks 8 and 12; damage to cartilage correlates to MRI values

[56]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

2.5 years

4, 8, 12 weeks

MRI and μCT can be used to detect changes in articular cartilage, joint space, BMD, calcified tissue associated with OA

[55]

New Zealand

Medial arthrotomy

Adult

9 weeks

Apoptosis ↑ with ACL-T; treatment with HA ↓ apoptosis

[59]

New Zealand

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Nov 27, 2016 | Posted by in RHEUMATOLOGY | Comments Off on Anterior Cruciate Transection/Disruption Models of Post-Traumatic Arthritis

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access