(1)
University of Amsterdam, Academic Medical Center, Meibergdreef, 1105 AZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
(2)
Department of Radiology, Division of Musculoskeletal Radiology Amsterdam Movement Sciences, Academic Center for Evidence Based Sports Medicine, Meibergdreef 9, 1105 AZ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Ankle Anatomy
The osteology of the ankle joint comprises three bones and three articulations. The tibia and the fibula both articulate at their distal ends with the talus, making the true ankle articulation. On the proximal part, there is a tiny surface connection between fibula and tibia, the so called syndesmosis that is extending from the articular surface of the distal fibula (i.e., lateral malleolus), including a small synovial recess. This explains why synovial joint fluid might extend into a completely normal syndesmosis. Lateral malleolus extents 1 cm more distal than the medial malleolus, the distal part of the tibia. This medial malleolus consists of two colliculi separated by a groove. The ventral colliculus extends 0.5 cm farther then the posterior colliculus. The third malleolus is the prominence of the distal tibia, known as posterior malleolus or malleolus tertius. The tibia and fibula are tightly bound, constituting a fork: medial malleolus, tibial plafond and lateral malleolus cover the talus on three sides. This is known as the “mortise” configuration. So the talus is intercalated, no tendons attach. Talus is cylindrical with more convexity in the a-p direction. Trochlea of talus is more wide anterior than posterior. This morphology leads to movements of talus in the mortise of 20 degree dorsiflexion and 50 degree of plantar flexion.
This intercalated talar bone firmly is attached to tibia, fibula and calcaneus by ligamentous network. On the medial side there is the important deltoid ligament, consisting of a deep layer connecting tibia with posteromedial talus. More superficial the deltoid comprises of less strong components making connection with navicular, spring ligament and calcaneus. On the lateral side tibia and fibula connect anterior to posterior with anterior tibiofibular ligament (ATiFL), interosseous membrane and the posterior tibiofibular ligament (PTiFL): together the syndesmotic complex. Posterior tibiofibular ligament is considered a posterior labrum, with two separate components superior band and deep transverse band. Final ligaments on the lateral side attach the fibula to the talus, with anterior (ATFL) and posterior (PTFL) talofibular ligament and to the calcaneus with the calcaneofibular ligament (CFL).
The cartilage of the tibiotalar joint comprises of three separate compartments, the tibiotalar compartment, the medial compartment and the lateral compartment. In analyzing pathology each compartment needs a separate check.
Extra articular structures that are of interest to us as radiologists are muscles and more specifically accompanying tendons (Fig. 1). Following the anatomy anteriorly we find from medial to lateral the tendons Tibialis anterior, the Extensor Hallucis and the Extensor Digitorum (Tom Hates Dick) tendon. Originating posterior and extending into the medial aspect of the ankle we encounter from anterior to posterior the tendons of the Tibialis Posterior, Flexor Digitorum, Flexor Hallucis Longus (Tom Dick and Harry). It is important to recognize that these tendon originate posteriorly, implying that posterior ankle pain can easily be caused by them. Posterior we encounter the Achilles tendon, a tendon that lies far back from the ankle joint, yet cause of severe posterior ankle pain. The Achilles tendon is anatomically different from the other tendon around the ankle for the absence of a tendon sheet, instead it is enveloped within a tiny highly permeable peritendinium. The lateral compartment comprises the peroneal tendons, peroneal Longus on the outside and the peroneal brevis on the inside. From an anatomical point of view this side of the ankle hosts anatomical variations quite often with additional peroneal muscles and tendons.
Fig. 1
Axial PD weighted 3 T image showing the normal appearance of the tendons medial, anterior lateral and the Achilles tendon posterior
Ankle Pathology
From a patients perspective the above mentioned anatomical separation is quite irrelevant. The patient almost always presents itself with a specific location of the ankle problem. This may be extremely obvious, such as inversion injury with immediate lateral ankle pain, or less obvious, such as an inversion injury with late posteromedial ankle pain or deep ankle pain. After a careful anamnesis and clinical assessment the referring medical specialist might know the anatomical structure that is suspected of pathology, yet quite often the request for MR lists a suggested Differential Diagnosis. We, as reading radiologists might feel the need to clear all mentioned anatomical structures. In my opinion the knowledge of the several pathological entities, distributed by their anatomical location, is more helpful in arriving at the right diagnosis.
I choose to focus the pathology section on some pathological entities that are frequently seen in our tertiary referral center for ankle and sports pathology.
Impingement Syndromes
Ankle impingement (AI) is an important cause of chronic ankle pain. AI is a painful mechanical limitation of full-ankle movement, secondary to osseous and/or soft-tissue pathology. Radiologists are frequently encountered with requests for MRI of the ankle, an investigation that needs to answer important preoperative questions. The presence of multiple ligaments, tendons and joint extensions make interpretation of MRI challenging. Anatomy of this small joint is considered difficult, yet crucial knowledge to interpret these MRI’s adequately. Using anatomical landmarks, AI is divided as (1) anterior impingement, with a subdivision in anteromedial and anterolateral impingement and (2) posterior impingement, also divided in posterior and posteromedial impingement.
Anterior impingement can be caused both by osseous as well as soft tissue pathology. In our experience the osseous pathology often occurs medial and soft tissue impingement anterolateral. Both axial and sagittal planes are needed. Be aware: soft tissue impingement can be of a low signal intensity due to fibrotic changes. So the chosen protocol in the axial plane needs not only fat suppressed images.
Posteromedial impingement is very frequently overlooked. Because of a traumatized deep deltoid ligament fibers secondary fibrosis. This fibrotic tissue is more form, will not easily adapt to the various movement and will cause pain and blockage. Secondary reaction of the deep flexors can occur, leading to the diagnosis of tenosynovitis, and with the help of the Satisfaction of search mechanism we might fail to detect the ligamentous abnormality.
Although plain film is mainstay in daily practice AI is not easily detected. Guidelines on improving use of plain film are provided. Also value of easy to perform additional plain films with low costs are explained, of which the posterior impingement view in 25 degrees of exorotation is one of (Fig. 2). Since MR is thought essential in workup of chronic ankle pain, guidelines for standardized interpretation and reporting are provided. Together with demonstrating the typical imaging features, the reading radiologist is comfortable to be able to provide the surgeon with the necessary answers. In our daily practice, MRI holds several orthopedic limitations, which are discussed. MDCT of both ankles, in neutral and maximal plantar flexion are thought of important additional value. Typical MDCT features of various AI subtypes are displayed. When radiologists are able to closely interact with the clinical colleagues, optimal care in chronic ankle pain can be provided.
Fig. 2
New lateral film, posterior Impingement view, with 25 degrees of exorotation. So called PIM, posterior impingement view
Osteochondral Defects
An osteochondral defect (OCD) is a lesion of the joint involving the cartilage and the subchondral bone plate. Already in 1743 it was stated: “if we consult the standard chirurgical writers from Hippocrates down to the present age we shall find that an ulcerated cartilage is universally allowed to be a very troublesome disease; that is admits of a cure with more difficulty than a carious bone and that when destroyed will never recover”. So it is considered an ongoing quest. An ankle trauma is widely accepted as the most important etiological factor of OCD of the talus. Berndt and Harty clearly described in cadaveric ankles the occurrence of lateral defects by strong inversion of sa dorsiflexed ankle.leading to compression of the lateral border against the fibula. A medial lesion was reproduced by plantarflexion of the ankle in combination with a slight anterior displacement of the talus on the tibia.