Fig. 15.1
(a) Cadaveric specimen of human left knee joint. (1) Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Notice: flat and wide, “ribbonlike” appearance of ACL. (2) Posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). (3) Anterior menisco-femoral ligament. LM lateral meniscus, tl transverse ligament. (b) Schema of “ribbon shape.” Some authors also compare this shape of ACL to “lasagna,” “pappardelle,” “fettuccine” or “kishimen” pasta
This flat appearance was also noted in several previous papers.
In 1980, Welsh [10] describes that femoral ACL attachment “inserts into a broad flat area on the back of the lateral femoral condyle.” It inserts “not as a distinct cord but is splayed over a broad flattened area.”
In 2013, Mochizuki et al. [4] published a paper in which he evaluates anatomical appearance of fanlike extension fibers at the femoral ACL attachment site in 28 cadaveric knees. He distinguished between direct and indirect insertion, based on histological appearance. Direct insertion (midsubstance fibers) has a transitional cartilaginous zone through which ACL fibers attach to the bone. That kind of insertion is typical for areas with great tension applied. The indirect insertion is created by fanlike extension fibers which are directly attached to the bone (Fig. 15.2a, b).
Fig. 15.2
(a) Cadaveric specimen of human right distal femur. LFC lateral femoral condyle, MFC medial femoral condyle. (1) ACL. (2) PCL. (3) Anterior menisco-femoral ligament. (b) Close look to femoral ACL attachment. Notice: Fanlike fibers marked with red arrows. Midsubstance fibers marked with yellow arrows. Own material
The attachment of midsubstance fibers of ACL is in exact continuity of the posterior femoral cortex [7, 9] (Fig. 15.3a–c). Knowing that relationship, the surgeon may double check the position of his femoral tunnel: arthroscopically and intraoperatively with X-ray C-arm. However, one may not talk about tunnel placement without a context of graft and fixation choice (Fig. 15.4a–c). For example, the use of BPTB graft or even a hamstring graft with interference screw fixation allows to “push” the graft to the side of the tunnel. Therefore, if the graft is supposed to arise from the place where midsubstance ACL fibers have their direct attachment, the center of tunnel drilled should be a little “higher” (more toward ventral side).
Fig. 15.3
(a) Cadaveric specimen of the left human distal femur. Medial view on the lateral femoral condyle, after removing (longitudinal cut) of medial femoral condyle. Posterior femoral cortex is marked with black arrows. The direct insertion of midsubstance fibers of ACL (marked with yellow arrows) is in line with posterior femoral cortex. Blue suture marks the borderline of articular cartilage and dorsal borderline of direct ACL insertion. Silver balls mark the ventral borderline of direct ACL insertion. (b, c) Same specimen, lateral X-ray. Notice relationship of direct midsubstance ACL fibers to posterior femoral cortex. Intraoperative X-ray allows for better control of correct localization of tunnel placement
Fig. 15.4
Close look on ACL femoral insertion site. While choosing a perfect spot to drill your tunnel, you must think about your choice of graft and the fixation. In case of hamstring graft and Endo-button fixation, (a) your graft will arise from more or less the center of your tunnel, so the center should be at the level of the direct attachment of ACL midsubstance fibers. On the other hand, in cases of BPTB graft or a hamstring graft with an interference screw fixation, the screw will push your graft to the side of your tunnel (b, c), so your tunnel center should be little above the direct midsubstance ACL attachment