3: Selected topics in systemic lupus erythematosus: B cells in lupus and lupus nephritis

Selected Topics in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: B Cells in Lupus and Lupus Nephritis


Iñaki Sanz, S. Sam Lim


Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA


Introduction


B cells contribute to the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) through multiple actions, including primary autoantibody production as well as antigen presentation, T cell induction, and the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines. Therefore, the development of biologic therapies designed to target B cells in SLE has remained of great interest to researchers. This chapter will review the rationale for B cells as therapeutic targets in SLE, as well as several key trials investigating the efficacy of these biologic agents in treating SLE. Additionally, the classification, treatment, and monitoring of lupus nephritis, one of the most problematic manifestations of SLE, will be reviewed.


B Cell Roles in SLE



  • Autoantibody production results in the formation of immune complexes that accumulate in tissues, inducing a type III hypersensitivity reaction that manifests clinically as nephritis, arthritis, and other disease manifestations

    • Autoantibody-producing cells fall into two categories: short-lived and long-lived populations which have differing CD20 expression and antibody production profiles
    • This separation bears important implications for our understanding of SLE pathogenesis
    • Rational design of therapeutic strategies must take into account the markers differentially expressed by short-lived and long-lived plasma cells, as well as the roles of different classes of autoantibodies

  • Immune complexes, perhaps more powerfully those formed by anti-ribonucleoprotein antibodies, also induce disease due to their ability to co-engage stimulatory Fcγ receptors and Toll-like receptors (TLRs) in dendritic cells, thereby promoting the production of type I interferon and amplification of inflammation
  • Additional antibody-independent functions are increasingly recognized as contributing significantly to disease pathogenesis, including:

    • Promotion of CD4+ and CD8+ effector T cell populations including TH17 induction
    • Inhibition of TREG cell populations
    • Recruitment of dendritic cells
    • Production of proinflammatory cytokines including TNF and IL-6

  • Of note, B cells can also suppress autoimmunity through a variety of functions that often represent the mirror image of their pathogenic functions; whether this balancing act represents a competition between different B cell subsets with a committed phenotype to a given function or instead is achieved by environmental modulation of multi-functional cells remains to be elucidated
  • B cells suppress autoimmunity through the following functions:

    • Induction of T cell anergy
    • Suppression of helper T cells
    • Expansion of TREG cell populations
    • Inhibition of dendritic cells
    • Production of anti-inflammatory cytokines, predominantly IL-10

      • In humans, both transitional B cells and B10 cells (regulatory B cells that produce IL-10) have been shown to be able to downregulate TH cell activation and reduce the production of proinflammatory cytokines by monocytes through the production of IL-10
      • Of significant interest, transitional regulatory B cells, while numerically increased, have been postulated to be functionally deficient in SLE
      • Similarly, B10 cells and their precursors can also be increased in active SLE, suggesting either a functional deficiency or increased resistance of their target cells

Therapies Targeting B Cells


Specific Approaches



  • Direct B cell depletion through depleting antibodies (rituximab)
  • Interference with B cell survival and enforcement of B cell tolerance during early B cell differentiation (belimumab)
  • Inhibition of cytokines known to play an important role in the differentiation and/or survival of memory B cells and plasma cells (IL-21, type 1 interferon, and IL-6)
  • Interruption of B cell receptor signaling or B cell costimulatory receptors including TLRs
  • Engagement of B cell inhibitory receptors

    • If associated with linked recognition of autoantigens, this strategy could theoretically lead to specific inhibition of pathogenic B cells

  • Expansion of regulatory B cells, accomplished either in vivo or in vitro with subsequent reinfusion of expanded regulatory B cells

Existing Therapies for SLE


Rituximab



  • Infusion of rituximab, an anti-CD20 antibody, mediates cell death in all B cells that express CD20 by a combination of mechanisms that include ADCC (antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity), complement-mediated cytotoxicity, and direct induction of apoptosis
  • The EXPLORER and LUNAR trials are two multicenter, randomized trials of rituximab in moderate to severe active SLE

    • EXPLORER examined moderate to severe, active, non-renal SLE patients receiving either rituximab or placebo in addition to steroids and stable background immunosuppressive therapy
    • LUNAR examined class II/IV, active lupus nephritis receiving rituximab or placebo in addition to mycophenolate mofetil
    • Neither trial was able to show that the addition of rituximab in these patients was superior to placebo when added to standard of care

  • Given the reported benefit of rituximab in clinical practice in off-label use, these results have been disappointing to researchers; many feel that the diversity of disease among patients and difficulty designing a study to assess a multisystem, heterogeneous disease process are to blame for the lack of evidence of benefit
  • There are several additional considerations tied specifically to rituximab that are currently under study

    • Pre-specified subset analyses in the EXPLORER trial have shown benefit in African-American and Hispanic patients
    • Similar analysis of the LUNAR trial also showed clinical benefit in African-American nephritis patients, although the small numbers of such patients in the study precluded more definitive conclusions
    • Also of significant importance, the primary endpoint of LUNAR failed to incorporate patients with partial renal remission, a clinical outcome of substantial relevance that is likely to portend long-term outcomes
    • Neither trial analyzed if complete B cell depletion occurred in each patient receiving rituximab; lower depletion levels have been shown to correlate with increased response to the drug

      • Thus, these studies cannot differentiate between lack of benefit from complete B cell depletion and failure to achieve this immunological outcome

Belimumab



  • Belimumab is a monoclonal antibody that binds to and inhibits BLys, a soluble B lymphocyte stimulator (also known as BAFF), that is necessary for B cell survival

    • In addition, excess BAFF, a common SLE abnormality, promotes the survival and maturation of immature and naïve B cells, thereby contributing to the accumulation of these cells in the mature peripheral compartment

  • BLISS-52 and BLISS-76 are two recent, large-scale, phase III clinical trials of belimumab for the treatment of SLE whose success led to the FDA approval of this drug for the treatment of SLE

    • Both used the SLE Responder Index (SRI) as the measure of the primary efficacy endpoint; this index was designed specifically for use in these trials
    • Results from both trials showed that belimumab modestly reduced disease activity and increased time to flare compared to placebo as well as reduced the need for corticosteroid treatment

      • BLISS-52: SRI response rate of 58% for belimumab, 44% for placebo at 52 weeks (10 mg/kg; p = 0.0006)
      • BLISS-76: SRI response rate of 43% for belimumab, 34% for placebo at 52 weeks (10 mg/kg; p = 0.017)

        1. Of note, BLISS-76 did not show superiority for lower doses of belimumab (1 mg/kg; p = 0.089) in contrast to BLISS-52 (p = 0.0129)
        2. BLISS-76 was performed in western Europe and North America, while BLISS-52 was carried out in eastern Europe and Asia

    • Belimumab was not associated with increased rates of serious infection
    • Belimumab has not yet been studied in patients with severe, active lupus nephritis or CNS lupus
    • Few African-Americans were included in BLISS-76

Additional Therapies Targeting B Cells in SLE under Investigation



  • Atacicept, a recombinant TACI-FC receptor fusion protein capable of binding to both BLyS as well as APRIL, a cytokine that powerfully mediates memory B cell and plasma cell survival, impacts the survival of a broader swath of B cells and plasma cells and has a more powerful effect on antibody titers

    • The promise of this agent has been compromised by the occurrence of serious infectious complications that led to the interruption of clinical trials both in rheumatoid arthritis and SLE (the latter when combined with mycophenolate mofetil)

  • Epratuzumab is an anti-CD22 antibody that inhibits B cell activation and maturation and induces a more modest degree of B cell depletion

    • Early, small studies show a steroid-sparing effect at 24 weeks

  • Bortezomib is a proteosome inhibitor commonly used to treat multiple myeloma

    • By selectively inhibiting the 26s proteasome, resulting in apoptosis, bortezomib has shown promise in triggering plasma cell apoptosis and modifying the proinflammatory response
    • Dramatic improvement of lupus nephritis has been demonstrated with this agent in mouse models
    • The unique mechanism of action of this class of agents, the importance of autoantibody-producing plasma cells (not directly affected by rituximab or belimumab) and the availability of new-generation proteasome inhibitors (such as carfilzomib) with significantly reduced incidence of painful peripheral neuropathy, all illustrate the promise of this approach for the treatment of SLE

Lupus Nephritis

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 3, 2016 | Posted by in RHEUMATOLOGY | Comments Off on 3: Selected topics in systemic lupus erythematosus: B cells in lupus and lupus nephritis

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access