2.12 Bone grafting
Author Mamoun Kremli
2.12 Bone grafting
2.12.1 Introduction
Bone grafting refers to a wide variety of surgical methods for augmenting or stimulating the formation of new bone wherever this is required, and is a common procedure in orthopaedic surgery. After blood, bone is the second most commonly transplanted tissue with more than 2 million bone graft procedures performed worldwide every year.
This chapter describes the indications for using bone graft and bone graft substitutes, and the materials available together with an outline of how they help the formation of new bone. Some of the surgical techniques used for harvesting bone allograft are presented.
2.12.2 Indications
There are five broad clinical indications for bone grafting:
Fresh fractures: In fresh fractures bone grafts and bone graft substitutes are used for two main reasons. They may be used to provide mechanical support or be used to speed up healing. Mechanical support is frequently required in the fixation of depressed articular fractures of the proximal and distal tibia and the distal radius. Speeding up of the healing process is required when the fracture treated is likely to take a long time to heal and it is possible that the implant will fail before fracture healing has occurred. Classically this is seen in plating of shaft fracture using absolute stability techniques when it is not possible to restore the bone surface opposite the plate.
Delayed union and nonunion of fractures: Bone grafting is one of the principal ways of managing fractures that have failed to heal after initial treatment. It is particularly important when the reason for delay in healing is because of poor biological environment at the fracture site caused by inadequate blood supply or bone defects.
To regenerate lost or missing bone: Bone grafting may be used when there is bone defect because of trauma, when a segment of diseased bone has been excised (eg, osteomyelitis), or when excision or curettage of a bone cyst has left a defect.
To help the process of arthrodesis (fusing) of a diseased joint: This is particularly common in spinal fusion. The addition of bone graft can also assist in the fusion of other damaged joints, including the ankle or wrist.
To improve the bone stock around a prosthesis: This is usually only required in revision procedures for total hip or total knee replacements.
2.12.3 Methods of bone stimulation
Bone grafting enhances the formation of new bone by three naturally occurring methods of bone stimulation:
Osteogenic stimulation
This is the ability to stimulate local bone-forming cells, osteoblasts, to produce new bone. Osteoblasts are present in fresh bone autograft taken from the same patient. Osteoblasts can also form from primitive stem cells, in bone marrow aspirated from a patient, when subjected to an osteoinductive stimulus (see below). Bone marrow can be injected into an autograft or allograft site or mixed with bone substitutes before being used in that patient.
Osteoconductive stimulation
Osteoconduction is the ability of material to serve as a scaffold on which bone cells can attach, migrate, and divide. Osteoconductive materials improve the ability of bone cells to fill the gap between two-bone ends. They also serve as a spacer that reduces the ability of fibrous tissue around the graft site from growing into the site. Bone grafts are the best osteoconductive material. Other naturally occurring and synthetic osteoconductive materials are also available.
Osteoinductive stimulation
Osteoinduction is the ability to stimulate primitive nondifferentiated bone cells to grow and mature into bone-forming osteoblasts. A number of growth factors present in normal human bone have been demonstrated to be osteoinductive. These are proteins which were first discovered in 1965 by Marshall Urist who coined the term “bone morphogenetic protein” (BMP). Subsequent studies have identified many different BMPs as well as other naturally occurring factors that stimulate bone growth.
2.12.4 Types of bone grafts
There are three types of bone graft, ie, autograft, allograft, and xenograft, depending from whom the graft has been taken. Each has advantages and disadvantages.
Autografts
Autografts are bone taken from and inserted into the same individual. They are osteoconductive, osteoinductive, and osteogenic and have become the standard by which all other biological methods of bone stimulation are measured. Autograft is usually harvested as fragments of cancellous or corticocancellous bone from the anterior or posterior iliac crest. Smaller amounts can be obtained from the proximal tibia, the greater trochanter, the distal radius, and the olecranon. In spinal surgery, spinous processes and ribs can be used. As dry air kills cells, autografts are best harvested shortly before they are required for use. The graft may be temporarily covered and stored with saline or blood-soaked gauze for up to 2 hours.
Occasionally a large segment of bone with its nutrient blood vessels and with or without its soft-tissue attachments can be transferred as a free-vascularized autograft to fill a large-bone defect. The vessels are reanastomosed to local vessels to provide the graft with a blood supply. This procedure is demanding and is usually performed by plastic surgeons.
Cortical and strut bones, usually the fibula, may be used when a graft requires additional strength for load bearing. Cancellous bone incorporates faster than cortical bone but cannot be expected to take much load. Corticocancellous block grafts are useful when there is a need to provide a structural support that heals quickly, usually filling defects in and around joints, particularly when there are missing pieces of bone or joint surface. Most of the time it is harvested by cutting out a suitably shaped section of the anterior iliac crest.
The advantages of autografts include their availability in all patients, the fact that there is no risk of disease transmission or graft rejection, and that it requires no special processing technique. Disadvantages include the variability of graft quality (particularly poor in osteoporotic patients), and the limited quantity of the donor-site bone. Harvesting autograft tends to increase operating time and graft donor sites have complications of varying severity occurring in about 10–35% of patients.