Osteoporosis
Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA
Introduction
Osteoporosis is a large-scale issue among the general population, affecting more than 10 million Americans. Osteoporosis-related fractures occur at a rate of 1.5 million/year in the US, and are a significant economic burden related to surgery, hospital stay, rehab, disability, and long-term care. Patients with rheumatic diseases are at increased risk of osteoporosis due to glucocorticoid and other medications, decreased activity, and decreased vitamin D.
Diagnosis
- Patients who have suffered a fragility or insufficiency fracture have osteoporosis by definition, regardless of DEXA (dual energy x-ray absorptiometry) results
- DEXA is used to diagnose patients with osteoporosis before a fragility fracture is sustained
- Plain films are not appropriate for early screening of osteoporosis as 30% of bone mineral density is lost before this is apparent on x-ray!
- WHO criteria for osteoporosis based on DEXA (Table 10.1)
- Osteoporosis if T score is ≤ −2.5
- Severe osteoporosis if T score is ≤ −2.5 and presence of fragility fracture
- Osteopenia if T score is between −1 and −2.5
- Osteoporosis if T score is ≤ −2.5
- Limitations of DEXA scanning
- WHO criteria for osteoporosis are based on a postmenopausal, white female study population; applicability to other ethnic groups or males is unknown
- Peripheral sites of DEXA scanning (i.e. wrist) are less sensitive than central sites (hip, spine); if suspicion is high, a normal study at the wrist should prompt testing of central sites for osteoporosis
- Low bone mineral density (BMD) is not always primary osteoporosis and may indicate another medical condition, see Causes of secondary osteoporosis
- Spine measurements may be falsely elevated or normal in patients with significant osteophytes or aortic calcification at the site of measurement
- Peripheral sites of DEXA scanning (i.e. wrist) are less sensitive than central sites (hip, spine); if suspicion is high, a normal study at the wrist should prompt testing of central sites for osteoporosis
- WHO criteria for osteoporosis are based on a postmenopausal, white female study population; applicability to other ethnic groups or males is unknown
- Fracture Risk Assessment Tool (FRAX)
- Developed because DEXA scanning in clinical practice has proven specific, but not sensitive, for identification of patients at high risk of fracture – retrospective studies showed that up to 50% of women with postmenopausal fragility fractures did not have osteoporosis by DEXA scan
- FRAX incorporates clinical risk factors (Table 10.2) to predict the 10-year risk of hip or other major osteoporotic fracture in an individual patient
- The National Osteoporosis Foundation (NOF) FRAX tool is available for clinician use at www.shef.ac.uk/FRAX
- Limitations of FRAX assessment:
- Does not include bone turnover markers due to lack of data, although the authors propose this may be included in the future
- Does not include DEXA measured at peripheral sites (but peripheral site measurements lack sensitivity anyway)
- Study population is still mostly women, limiting generalizability
- Does not include bone turnover markers due to lack of data, although the authors propose this may be included in the future
- Developed because DEXA scanning in clinical practice has proven specific, but not sensitive, for identification of patients at high risk of fracture – retrospective studies showed that up to 50% of women with postmenopausal fragility fractures did not have osteoporosis by DEXA scan
- Who should be screened for osteoporosis?
- All females aged >65 years, males >70 years
- Postmenopausal women and men aged >50 years based on risk factor profile
- Anyone with an insufficiency fracture, to determine severity of disease
- Females on hormone replacement therapy
- Patients on glucocorticoid therapy of >7.5 mg/day for longer than 3 months
- All females aged >65 years, males >70 years
- Who should be treated for osteoporosis? National Osteoporosis Foundation (NOF) guidelines
- Any patient who has suffered an insufficiency fracture
- Osteoporosis defined by BMD T score ≤ −2.5
- Postmenopausal women and men aged >50 with T score between −1 and −2.5 with a FRAX score showing 10-year hip fracture risk >3% or 10-year major osteoporotic fracture risk >20%
- Any patient who has suffered an insufficiency fracture
- Markers of bone resorption: a biomarker for osteoporosis?
- NTx, CTx are collagen X-linked telopeptides of type I collagen that are released during osteoclast activity and subsequent collagen breakdown
- Elevated levels >50 ng/mL may suggest faster bone turnover and increased fracture risk
- Lower levels after initiation of osteoporosis treatment may suggest treatment response or be used to judge treatment adherence
- Limitations:
- Marked physiologic variability and diurnal variability makes a single value difficult to interpret
- Clinical relevance not well established
- Marked physiologic variability and diurnal variability makes a single value difficult to interpret
- NTx, CTx are collagen X-linked telopeptides of type I collagen that are released during osteoclast activity and subsequent collagen breakdown
Result | Clinical correlation |
---|---|
T score | Compares patient’s BMD with peak bone mass in young normal subjects |
Z score | Compares patient’s BMD with BMD of age-matched subjects |
Absolute BMD | Best for long-term individual follow-up and determining a patient’s response to therapy |
Table 10.1 Interpreting DEXA scan results.
Age |
Sex |
Current smoking |
Alcohol intake |
BMI |
Previous fragility fracture |
Previous glucocorticoid exposure (>5 mg daily for 3 months or more) |
History of hip fracture in parents |
Diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis |
Diagnosis of secondary osteoporosis |
Table 10.2 Clinical risk factors assessed in FRAX.