Abstract
Background
Insertional Achilles tendinopathy (IAT) often necessitates surgery when conservative measures fail. In recent years, minimally invasive (MIS) Zadek osteotomy has emerged as a favourable alternative to open surgeries such as calcaneoplasty and tendon reattachment. This study evaluates our experience with MIS Zadek osteotomy and compares its clinical outcomes with those of open calcaneoplasty and Achilles tendon reattachment in the treatment of recalcitrant IAT.
Methods
A retrospective comparative study was conducted on thirty patients treated surgically for IAT between January 2023 and December 2024. Patients were divided into two groups: Open calcaneoplasty with Achilles tendon reattachment (n = 15), and MIS Zadek osteotomy (n = 15). Inclusion criteria comprised of patients with symptomatic IAT refractory to nonoperative treatment while patients with concomitant foot deformity or inflammatory conditions, and those who have undergone prior surgery to the same ankle were excluded. All patients had a minimum follow-up of twelve months. Primary clinical outcomes analysed include time taken to unrestricted independent ambulation, Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) scores, European Foot and Ankle Society (EFAS) scores, ability to perform unassisted single-legged heel raise (SLHR), satisfaction, and post-operative complications.
Results
Time to unrestricted independent ambulation and ability was significantly shorter in the MIS group (mean=7.1 weeks) versus the open group (mean=13.2 weeks; p < 0.001). More patients who underwent MIS Zadek were able to perform unassisted SLHR at 3 months (46.67 % in the open group vs 86.7 % in the MIS group; p = 0.019). Both groups had significant pain reduction at 12 months (VAS 0.67 vs. 0.20; p = 0.176). EFAS scores improved in both groups, with no significant intergroup differences at six or twelve months. Wound complications occurred in 26.7 % (n = 4) of patients in the open group, including one deep infection requiring readmission and multiple debridement. No wound-related complications were reported in the MIS group (p = 0.032).
Conclusion
MIS Zadek osteotomy is a viable surgical alternative for IAT, offering comparable pain relief and functional improvement while significantly shortening the time to independent ambulation and risk of wound complications. Comparative studies with larger sample sizes and longer term follow-up are warranted to validate these findings.
Level of Evidence
III
1
Introduction
Insertional Achilles tendinopathy (IAT) is a common cause of posterior heel pain, accounting for approximately one-third of Achilles tendon disorders , . It results from overuse, chronic degeneration, and repeated microtrauma at the tendon’s calcaneal insertion .
Conservative treatment remains the first line of management for IAT. It consists of anti-inflammatory medications, activity modification, physical therapy, and shoe wear modification ,,, . Eccentric ankle dorsiflexion exercises, particularly the Alfredson protocol, is widely recommended . Extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) has demonstrated promising outcomes, with studies reporting improvements in pain and function, particularly when combined with physical therapy . Corticosteroid injections, though believed to provide temporary symptomatic relief, are not recommended due to insufficient evidence, and they pose the risk of tendon degeneration and rupture , . Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections, on the other hand, have shown some improvement in symptoms; however, current evidence remains inconclusive, with inconsistent outcomes . These non-operative measures fail in up to 20–40 % of patients, necessitating surgical intervention .
Surgical options for IAT includes, but are not limited to, open or arthroscopic debridement of the Achilles tendon, Zadek osteotomy, ultrasound-guided osteotomy, and tendon scraping ,,, . Open calcaneoplasty with Achilles tendon debridement and reattachment is widely performed due to its direct visualization and ability to address associated bony deformities. However, it is associated with notable wound complications such as delayed healing, paraesthesia, stiffness, and even delayed Achilles tendon rupture , .
Zadek osteotomy was first described by Isadore Zadek in 1939 and later popularised in the 1960s through the work of Keck and Kelly as a viable surgical option in the treatment of Haglund’s deformity and Achilles tendinopathy. The procedure reduces impingement between the bone-tendon interface by altering the calcaneal slope and elongating the Achilles tendon’s moment arm without disrupting the tendon itself , . Although it initially lost in favour due to the morbidity associated with an extended lateral incision, advances in minimally invasive surgery (MIS) have enabled a percutaneous approach, potentially reducing soft tissue trauma, expediting rehabilitation, and lowering wound complication rates ,, .
The primary aim of this study is to compare the clinical and functional outcomes of MIS Zadek osteotomy and open calcaneoplasty with tendon reattachment for recalcitrant IAT, with a focus on postoperative recovery, functional scores, and complication rates.
2
Material and methods
This study was approved by SingHealth Institutional Review Board.
2.1
Patient selection
A retrospective comparative study was conducted at a tertiary teaching hospital in Singapore, involving patients who underwent surgical treatment for IAT. A total of 30 patients were included in the analysis. The diagnosis of IAT was confirmed based on the clinical presentation and supporting radiographic findings. The inclusion criteria include patients with at least 6 months of recalcitrant IAT that is refractory to conservative treatment, such as activity alteration, footwear modification, and physiotherapy. Patients with concomitant foot deformity or inflammatory conditions, and those who have undergone prior surgery to the same ankle, were excluded from the study.
Fifteen patients underwent MIS Zadek osteotomy between January 2023 and June 2024 (study group) and were compared with a control group of 15 patients who underwent open resection of Haglund deformity with Achilles tendon debridement and reattachment. The study recruitment process is illustrated in Fig. 1 .
Flow diagram illustrating patient recruitment. Abbreviations: IAT, Insertional Achilles tendonitis; MIS, Minimally invasive.
2.2
Surgical technique
2.2.1
MIS Zadek osteotomy (study group)
Patients were positioned in the lateral decubitus position with the operative leg on an elevated bone foam over a radiolucent table, and a thigh tourniquet was applied. The non-operative leg was flexed out of the surgical field. Under fluoroscopic guidance, a Kirschner wire was used to mark the trajectory for a 10 mm dorsal closing wedge osteotomy on the lateral calcaneus ( Fig. 2 A).
(A) Intraoperative fluoroscopic image of K-wire used to plan osteotomy trajectory. (B) K wire marking on skin of planned osteotomy trajectory and high-speed burr inserted through percutaneous incision.
A 5 mm incision was made at the apex of the osteotomy over the lateral calcaneus, 5–8 mm from the plantar cortex, just anterior to the calcaneal tuberosity. Blunt dissection to the bone was performed using a straight haemostat. A 3.1 mm calcaneal wedge burr was advanced into the lateral calcaneus to create a V-shaped dorsal closing wedge osteotomy ( Fig. 2 B). Continuous saline irrigation was used with burring, paused every 10–15 s for cooling and cleaning.
The ankle was dorsiflexed to close the osteotomy and temporarily stabilized with two vertically stacked guidewires under fluoroscopy. Two 6.5 mm headless compression screws (HCS) were inserted across the osteotomy site with the ankle in maximal dorsiflexion, and implant position was confirmed fluoroscopically ( Fig. 3 A and B).
(A) Surgeon maximally dorsiflexing the ankle to close the osteotomy gap (B) Two 6.5 mm headless compression screws inserted to compress the osteotomy site.
2.2.2
Open calcaneoplasty and achilles tendon reattachment (control group)
Patients were positioned prone on a radiolucent table with a thigh tourniquet applied. A longitudinal midline skin incision was made, and the Achilles tendon was centrally split and partially detached from the calcaneus, preserving the medial and lateral tendon attachments to maintain tension.
The diseased tendon was debrided, the retrocalcaneal bursa excised, and the Haglund’s prominence was resected using an oscillating saw and rongeurs as shown in Fig. 4 .
Midline tendon splitting approach with visualized calcaneum. Haglund deformity in this patient was already excised with oscillating saw.
The Achilles tendon was then reattached to the posterior calcaneus using two suture anchors with the foot in a plantigrade position ( Fig. 5 ).
Reattached Achilles tendon into the calcaneum using suture anchors.
2.2.3
Closure technique
Skin closure was standardized for both groups using non-absorbable synthetic sutures. All patients received firm bandaging postoperatively and three doses of intravenous antibiotics, per institutional protocol.
2.3
Post-operative management
The postoperative rehabilitation protocols used for each of the two procedures are detailed as follows.
2.3.1
MIS Zadek osteotomy (study group)
Postoperatively, patients were fitted with a Darco shoe and allowed toe-touch to partial weight-bearing with ankle range-of-motion (ROM) exercises during the first 2 weeks. Progressive weight-bearing in a controlled ankle movement (CAM) boot was initiated after and gradually weaned off. Open-chain lower-limb exercises were permitted during the first 6 weeks, followed by closed-chain exercises under the supervision of physiotherapy. High-impact and strenuous activities were avoided for 3 months, with a gradual return thereafter.
2.3.2
Open calcaneoplasty and Achilles tendon reattachment (control group)
Patients were immobilized for the first 2 weeks in an above-the-ankle plaster cast with the foot in a plantigrade position and non-weight-bearing to protect the Achilles tendon reattachment. After cast removal, they transitioned to a CAM boot with heel wedges, which are gradually removed over the next 4 weeks. This is followed by progressive strengthening under the guidance of a physiotherapist, which includes Achilles tendon stretching, ankle ROM, and proprioception exercises.
Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel
Full access? Get Clinical Tree




