Emergency Fracture Reduction
Vidyadhar Upasani
Sun Min Park
Dennis Wenger
INTRODUCTION
Traditionally simple minimally displaced or non displaced fractures in children were treated in the emergency department (ED) with minimal or no anesthesia. Moderately displaced fractures were sometimes treated in the ED with local anesthesia (hematoma block, propofol, IV lidocaine methods); however, most moderate and all severe fractures were treated in the operating room (OR) with general anesthesia.
With the development of new methods for analgesia and the availability of compact digital imaging units, currently many significantly displaced and angulated children’s fractures can be treated in EDs, clinics, and office-based treatment centers. This has reduced the number of reductions performed in the OR, freeing those rooms for more severe cases.
This chapter will clarify how our hospital has developed and applied these new methods in a region of 5 million people with a clinic/emergency
setting in which thousands of new children’s fractures are evaluated and treated annually. Key elements in this evolution include the following:
setting in which thousands of new children’s fractures are evaluated and treated annually. Key elements in this evolution include the following:
“Those that do not feel pain, seldom think that it is felt”
—Dr. Johnson
ER or ED?
Emergency rooms have grown in size and complexity and have often become departments. As such, they often ask that they be known as the “ED” (emergency department). Yet the overall culture seems to prefer “ER”—perhaps a vestige of the popular television program.
A progressive orthopedic surgery group interested in safe, cost effective fracture care that minimizes OR use and hospitalization
In busy hospital-based systems: residents and advanced care practitioners (ACPs), (nurse practitioners [NPs], and physician assistants [PAs]), trained in fracture care.
Advanced Life Support (ALS) and Pediatric Advanced Life Support (PALS) certified doctors, nurses and medical personnel—Full-time ED medical staff
Development of safe, effective conscious sedation anesthesia techniques (Fig. 4-1)
Compact portable, low-radiation, digital image intensifying machines to guide fracture reduction
Use of telemedicine (taking images that can be loaded on to patient’s chart, also allows efficient triage and institutional transfer)
Certified orthopedic technicians—for cast application and care
“Next morning” dedicated orthopedic trauma room in OR (avoids most “middle of the night” surgery—minimizes “surgeon burnout”)
The combination of these factors has revolutionized fracture care efficiency for children in our center.
Advanced Care Practitioners—Who Are They?
Also referred to as “Allied Health Professionals,” “Mid-level Providers,” and “Physician Extenders.” These advanced care professionals are physician assistants and nurse practitioners who have become experts in children’s orthopedic care. Our service trains them much as residents are trained. They run their own fracture clinics and take calls and form an important part of our care team.
Advanced Care Practitioners (ACPs)
The development of ACPs in specialty care makes children’s fracture care more efficient in centers with the volume to support such a system. In our center, the orthopedic staff train not only orthopedic residents and fellows but also ACPs in fracture management, including closed reductions in the ED. This has helped us deal with resident work requirements and with increased patient volume. Proper training and supervision allows ACPs to manage children’s fractures safely and efficiently.
Current Trends
Today most children’s fractures can be safely reduced in the ED ranging from forearm fractures to femur fractures (in very young children). Initially the treating orthopedic surgeon had the sole responsibility for analgesia, reduction, and casting. With newer methods, most EDs can provide an environment that allows a systematic “team approach” for fracture reduction. The ED staff physician can oversee the administration of conscious sedation, a nurse can monitor the patient, and a portable image intensifier allows one to monitor fracture reduction (Fig. 4-2).
Trends in mechanism of injury for childhood fractures are both consistent and evolving. Although monkey bars and trampolines continue to be a common cause of many pediatric fractures, we have also seen a rise in fractures sustained from hoverboards and “small wheeled” scooters. Seasonal trends are also noted; football-related injuries and fractures occur mostly in the fall season and snow-related (ski, snowboard, sledding) fractures occur mostly in the winter.
Fractures occurring during a patient’s vacation are common because our institution is located in a city considered to be a tourist destination. We provide our services, as appropriate, and direct the patient and family to obtain their imaging studies and records via our Medical Records office for return to their often distant home city. We also assist the family in finding a pediatric orthopedist who can continue their care in a timely manner based on their home city (we use the POSNA site http://orthokids.org to find a pediatric orthopedist).
Fracture Care Involving Orthopedic Residents in Training
In centers with resident training programs, the improvements noted above have allowed residents to provide efficient fracture care, decreasing the need for staff orthopedic surgeons to be present for every reduction. Traditionally, most North American centers required a staff orthopedic surgeon to be present for all reductions performed in the OR. The presence of supervising, attending emergency room physicians (who provide overall supervision for the case) now allows
resident fracture reduction in the ED with the on-call staff orthopedic surgeon in attendance only for problem cases. The staff physician reviews the case by telephone/digital x-ray images prior to treatment in all but the simplest of cases. The same applies to ACPs who reduce fractures.
resident fracture reduction in the ED with the on-call staff orthopedic surgeon in attendance only for problem cases. The staff physician reviews the case by telephone/digital x-ray images prior to treatment in all but the simplest of cases. The same applies to ACPs who reduce fractures.
Figure 4-2 Compact image intensifiers allow accurate monitoring of reductions with minimal radiation exposure. |
“To treat a high volume of fractures, an efficient system that coordinates care between the ED staff and the orthopedic team is required”
The continuing development of the electronic medical record (EMR) and picture archiving and communication systems (PACS) help with efficient off-site staff supervision of residents. Also, the resident and ACPs now have the ability to take a photo of a wound with their cell phone that is immediately deposited in the child’s EMR, which is accessible by an off-site staff physician to help guide treatment when needed.
There are many advantages in using this technology; however, there are also pitfalls that can negatively affect patient care. Obtaining a clear and thorough history of present illness and the patient’s physical exam is of utmost importance prior to obtaining and sending digital images. This is especially important in situations when outside facilities are transferring this information to a resident or ACP.
Each fracture reduced during nighttime hours is reviewed with the on-call staff in the morning. Also, all reductions are reviewed in a weekly conference that all orthopedic residents, an ACP representative, and staff in attend. The goals of the conference include ensuring that patients have received appropriate care and timely follow-up, as well as providing constructive feedback to residents regarding closed reduction and cast application quality.
DEVELOPING A CHILDREN’S FRACTURE TREATMENT SYSTEM
To treat a high volume of fractures, an efficient system that coordinates care between the ED staff and the orthopedic team is required, and in this section, we will describe the methods that we have developed (Rady Children’s Hospital, San Diego). These methods can also be applied in a specialized fracture reduction clinic model, if appropriately trained personnel are available to manage conscious sedation.
Prior to beginning their rotation at our center, the orthopedic residents attend an “Ortho Boot Camp.” This 2-day course includes applying casts and splints, suturing, setting up traction and managing traction pins. The course is organized and supervised by our staff orthopedic surgeons, along with our most experienced orthopedic technicians. This is also an opportunity for physician extenders to receive initial or supplemental training.
Efficient fracture care in a busy children’s hospital requires a tiered team that can focus on musculoskeletal problems. In our system, this team is headed by an attending surgeon and includes an orthopedic resident, an advanced care practitioner (NP or PA), and an orthopedic technician.
Table 4-1 Guidelines for Referring Doctors, Clinics, and ERs Send Urgently or Splint and Refer Later? | |
---|---|
“Not all fractures require reduction and not all patients need treatment in the middle of the night”
Moore, a prominent orthopedic surgeon from Philadelphia, created and implemented an effective fracture reduction clinic that met only once a week (every Tuesday). His method proved to be safe and effective, and its principles are still used today. Splinting small fractures with reduction (if needed) in 3-5 days allows swelling to subside, making casting safer.
Arrival
Patients arrive to our ED either through self-referral or referral from an outside facility or from their primary doctor. When a child is sent from an outside facility, a call has usually already been made notifying either the orthopedic team or the ED staff. In some cases, the team may decide (after talking with the referring person/institution) that an expensive emergency visit is not required and the patient can be managed in our early evening “Fracture Clinics” that run daily from 4 to 6 p.m. (Table 4-1).
Simple fractures (or suspected fractures) should be managed with a splint and sent to our outpatient clinic within a few days. Of course, this is often hard to ascertain by telephone, and we note errors weekly. A small puncture wound may not be recognized as an open fracture, and a 1 a.m. transfer for a “severe supracondylar fracture” is sometimes just a buckle fracture.
Who Requires Urgent Treatment
Not all fractures require reduction, and not all patients need treatment in the middle of the night. Even in our very busy system, the full team (NP/PA, resident, and orthopedic technician) is available only until 11 p.m. (the resident continues to be available throughout the night). Fractures that are only modestly displaced or angulated do not require reduction at a very late hour. Such cases can be splinted by your ED staff and brought back for formal reduction in a few days.
Delaying manipulative closed reduction is sometimes difficult to implement because parents are anxious and concerned about their child’s injured extremity. Although most parents want an immediate reduction, in almost every type of fracture, there is no clear evidence that immediate reduction provides a better result.
However, several recent studies have emphasized the need for proper education for residents and ED personnel on splint application. Poorly applied splints can be painful as they do not properly immobilize the fracture or can even cause skin pressure or necrosis. Our system strives to improve patient care and safety; however, with the ever-changing “guard” of ED and orthopedic resident providers, splint-related complications can likely never be reduced to zero.
Streamlining Care—Nurse Triage
Once a patient has been accepted for treatment, both the orthopedic team and the ED staff should be notified so that triage can be started immediately upon arrival. This assures prompt treatment and limits unnecessary waiting time in an already busy ED.
Splinting Fractures
A key element to a sensible musculoskeletal urgent care program is the widespread availability of safe and practical fracture splinting by outlying facilities. Fiberglass-felt-foam composite splints (available on bulk rolls) combined with an elastic wrap roll allow easy application for the trained orthopedist; ERs seem to do it well also. Training primary care doctors to splint safely is a great investment toward rational fracture care. Training sessions for referring practitioners provide a great community service that will save time, money, and frustration for you and the patient.