Electrodiagnosis in Neuromuscular Disease




Electromyography (EMG) is an important diagnostic tool for the assessment of individuals with various neuromuscular diseases. It should be an extension of a thorough history and physical examination. Some prototypical characteristics and findings of EMG and nerve conduction studies are discussed; however, a more thorough discussion can be found in the textbooks and resources sited in the article. With an increase in molecular genetic diagnostics, EMG continues to play an important role in the diagnosis and management of patients with neuromuscular diseases and also provides a cost-effective diagnostic workup before ordering a battery of costly genetic tests.








  • The electrodiagnostic examination (EDX) remains an important diagnostic tool to assist in the diagnosis of many neuromuscular diseases despite the increasing availability of molecular genetic testing.



  • Peripheral neuropathies may be classified by cause, acquired and inherited, or through electrophysiologic findings.



  • Various forms of motor neuron disease, including the spinal muscular atrophies, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and polio, share several electrodiagnostic features but differ clinically, particularly with respect to disease progression.



  • Special tests, such as repetitive nerve stimulation and single fiber electromyography, are available for the evaluation of neuromuscular junction disorders.



  • The EDX examination is less sensitive for detecting myopathies compared with other groups of neuromuscular diseases and is rarely helpful in differentiating between the various myopathic disorders.



Key Points
The electrodiagnostic examination (EDX) remains an important diagnostic tool to assist in the diagnosis of many neuromuscular diseases despite the increasing availability of molecular genetic testing. Challenges exist when conducting an EDX in the setting of neuromuscular disease. The distribution of abnormalities may be patchy, findings may be subtle (especially with myopathies), and the use of special techniques, such as repetitive stimulation studies and single fiber electromyography (SFEMG), may be required. This article presumes a basic knowledge of EDX and presents a general approach to the electrodiagnosis of patients with neuromuscular diseases followed by a description of the unique EDX features of polyneuropathies, motor neuron disease, neuromuscular junction disorders, and myopathies.


A general approach to the electrodiagnostic evaluation of patients with neuromuscular diseases


Before undergoing the EDX, a detailed history and physical examination should be performed. The electromyographer should then have an idea of whether the disease process is primarily neuropathic, myopathic, or of neuromuscular junction to help focus the ensuing EDX studies. Knowledge of clinically weak muscles based on the physical examination will also increase the diagnostic yield.


The evaluation of patients suspected of having peripheral neuropathy or motor neuron disease can typically begin with nerve conduction studies (NCS) in the bilateral lower limbs and one upper limb, generally beginning the EDX on the side of the body that is most affected if the process is asymmetric. Motor NCS typically include the peroneal, tibial, and ulnar nerves. Sensory NCS include the sural, ulnar, and radial nerves. If the sural response is present, the electromyographer may attempt to elicit a medial plantar mixed nerve or sensory response; loss of the medial plantar response can be an early sign of peripheral neuropathy. NCS may also include at least one upper and one lower extremity F wave and an H reflex. F waves are useful in detecting demyelinating neuropathies. Any abnormalities detected by NCS that seem inconsistent with the overall findings should prompt a comparison in the contralateral limb. For example, finding a low amplitude ulnar compound muscle action potential (CMAP) in a mild generalized sensorimotor polyneuropathy suggests a concomitant focal ulnar nerve lesion. Comparison with the contralateral ulnar nerve may help clarify the situation.


The needle electrode examination (NEE) in the evaluation of a neuropathic process should focus on distal muscles, especially in the lower extremities. In most generalized peripheral polyneuropathies, distal lower limb muscles are affected first. Typical lower limb muscles for evaluation can include the extensor digitorum brevis, tibialis posterior, medial gastrocnemius, tibialis anterior, vastus lateralis, and gluteus medius muscles in the distal to proximal direction. Additional muscles can then be examined depending on the areas of weakness noted on the examination and EDX abnormalities of the aforementioned muscles. For mild generalized polyneuropathies, proximal upper limb muscles need not be studied if the intrinsic muscles of the hand are normal. If the hand intrinsic muscles are abnormal, the remainder of the upper limb should be studied. As an upper extremity screen, typical muscles for examination include the first dorsal interosseous, extensor indices proprius, pronator teres, biceps, triceps, and deltoid muscles, with lower cervical paraspinals when needed. In cases of suspected motor neuron disease, proximal and distal muscles in both the upper and lower limbs should be examined.


In general, fewer NCS are needed for the evaluation of a myopathic process. In most myopathies, the NCS are normal unless significant distal atrophy has occurred. An NCS screen should include at least one upper and one lower limb motor and sensory nerve. The choice of specific nerves may vary; at a minimum, the authors typically perform sural sensory, peroneal motor, ulnar sensory, and ulnar motor NCS. If a very low CMAP is obtained, the study should be repeated after a 10-second maximal isometric contraction of the target muscle to look for facilitation, as in seen in Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome. An abnormal result in only one nerve should prompt a comparison with the contralateral NCS.


In suspected myopathy, the NEE should generally focus on proximal muscles and muscles that are weak. Other muscles for examination should include the paraspinals and a few targeted distal muscles. The initial examination includes the supraspinatus, deltoid, triceps, biceps, brachioradialis, pronator teres, first dorsal interosseous, gluteus medius, iliopsoas, vastus lateralis, adductor longus, short head of biceps femoris, tibialis anterior, medial gastrocnemius, and cervical and lumbar paraspinals. Any clinically weak muscle should be examined. If no abnormalities are seen in a clinically weak muscle, a second or third needle insertion at another site within the same muscle may reveal abnormalities. Inflammatory myopathies have patchy involvement, even within the same muscle. If a needle biopsy is anticipated in the near future, the limb to be biopsied should not undergo NEE.




Neuropathies


Peripheral neuropathies may be classified by cause, acquired and inherited, or through electrophysiologic findings. Electrophysiologically, neuropathies may be divided into 6 major categories: (1) uniform demyelinating; (2) segmental demyelinating; (3) axonal, sensorimotor; (4) axonal, motor, sensory, (5) axonal, sensory; and (6) combined axonal and demyelinating. The EDX helps to categorize neuropathic disorders into one of these 6 categories, suggesting a limited differential diagnosis but seldom can identify the exact underlying cause. Within each of the 6 categories, the differential diagnosis requires knowledge of the history, physical examination, laboratory testing, molecular genetic testing, and occasionally nerve biopsy. Electrodiagnostic findings of the 6 categories of peripheral neuropathies are further described.


Uniform Demyelinating Neuropathies


The uniform demyelinating neuropathies are all hereditary and are characterized by conduction velocity slowing, prolonged distal latencies, prolonged F waves, absent or reduced sensory nerve action potential (SNAP), and absent or reduced CMAPs when recording over distal muscles. Temporal dispersion and conduction block (CB) are not seen because the demyelination is uniform. This characteristic differentiates hereditary from acquired demyelinating neuropathies. NEE shows characteristic neuropathic findings, such as decreased recruitment, motor unit action potentials (MUAPs) of increased duration and amplitude, and fibrillation potentials and positive sharp waves (PSWs) in distal muscles.


Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) disease subtypes are many and as a group represent the most common and well known of the hereditary neuropathies ( Table 1 ). CMT is also referred to as hereditary motor sensory neuropathies (HMSN). Table 2 shows some common and typical electrodiagnostic characteristics for different CMT subtypes and acquired forms of neuropathies for comparison. In the demyelinating form of CMT, velocity slowing is symmetric and nearly identical in both proximal and distal nerve segments. Conduction blocks are rare in CMT1A (the most common form) but are seen in CMT1 types B and C and acquired demyelinating neuropathies. SNAPs are usually absent after 10 years of age. Nerve conduction velocities generally reach their nadir by 5 years of age and distal latencies by 10 years of age, but CMAP amplitudes may continue to decline throughout life and are often unrecordable in the distal lower limb muscles of adults. Motor conduction velocities are 20 to 25 m/s but may drop as low as 10 to 15 m/s in the lower limbs. As in all demyelinating neuropathies, clinical weakness correlates with the degree of reduction in CMAP amplitude but not with the extent of conduction velocity slowing. Low nerve conduction velocities (NCVs) can even be detected in asymptomatic individuals and as early as 1 year of age. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs are common in distal muscles of the upper and lower limbs. Dejerine-Sottas syndrome (HMSN III) is the most severe form of demyelinating neuropathy and is characterized by conduction velocities less than 10 m/s and often as low as 2 to 3 m/s. SNAPs cannot be recorded, and CMAP amplitudes are very low. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs are seen in proximal and distal muscles. Nerves have elevated electrical thresholds and, therefore, require a long stimulus duration in attempts to achieve supramaximal stimulation (see Tables 1 and 2 ).



Table 1

Summary of the genetic basis for Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease














































































































































Chromosome Gene Locus Inheritance Gene Abnormality
Charcot-Marie-Tooth I
CMT 1A 17p11.2-12 PMP22 AD Duplication/point mutation
CMT 1B 1q22-23 P 0 AD Point mutation
CMT 1C 16p12-p13 SIMPLE AD Point mutation
CMT 1D 10q21-q22 EGR2 AD/AR Point mutation
Charcot-Marie-Tooth 2
CMT 2A 1p35-36 MFN2 AD Point mutation
CMT 2B 3q13-q22 RAB7 AD Point mutation
CMT 2C 12q23-q24 Unknown AD Unknown
CMT 2D 7p14 GARS AD Point mutation
CMT 2E 8p21 NF-L AD Point mutation
Dejerine-Sottas disease
DSDA 17p11.2-12 PMP22 AD Point mutation
DSDB 1q22-23 P 0 AD Point mutation
DSDC 10q21-q22 EGR2 AD Point mutation
DSDD 19q13 PRX AD Point mutation
Charcot-Marie-Tooth 4
CMT4A 8q13-q21 GDAP1 AR Point mutation
CMT4B1 11q22 MTMR2 AR Point mutation
CMT4B2 11p15 SBF2 AR Point mutation
CMT4D (HMSN-Lom) 8q24 NDRG1 AR Point mutation
CMT4F 19q13 PRX AR Point mutation
Charcot-Marie-Tooth X
CMTX Xq13.1 Connexin 32 XD Point mutation
HNPP
HNPP 17p11.2 PMP22 AD Deletion/point mutation

Genetic spectrum of inherited neuropathies.

Abbreviations: AD, autosomal dominant; AR, autosomal recessive; Cx32, connexin32; EGR2 or Krox-20, early growth response 2 gene; GARS, glycyl tRNA synthase; GDAP1, ganglioside-induced differentiation-associated protein-1; HMSN, hereditary motor sensory neuropathies; HNPP, hereditary neuropathy with liability to pressure palsies; Inheritance: LAMN, lamin A/C; MFN2, Mitofusin; MTMR2, myotubularin-related protein-2; NDRG1, N-myc-downstream regulated gene 1; NEF-L, neurofilament; P 0 , myelin protein zero; PMP22, peripheral myelin protein 22; PRX, periaxin; RAB7, small GTP-ase late endosomal protein gene 7, light chain; SBF2, set binding factor 2; SIMPLE, small integral membrane protein of late endosome; XD, X-linked dominant.

Data from Carter GT, Weiss MD, Han JJ, et al. Charcot Marie Tooth Disease. Curr Treat Options Neurol 2008 Mar;10(2):94–102.


Table 2

Electrodiagnostic characteristics of the hereditary and acquired motor and sensory neuropathies



































































Neuropathy Form Conduction Velocity Characteristics Axonal Loss Conduction Block Temporal Dispersion Focal Slowing
CMT 1 Uniform slowing, usually <38 m/s but may be faster Yes No No No
CMT 2 Minimal slowing to normal Yes (primary) No No No
CMT X1 Heterogeneous slowing (30–40 m/s); temporal dispersion Yes No Occasionally Occasionally
HNPP Nonuniform, intermediate slowing, distal >proximal Yes Yes Yes Yes
Dejerine-Sottas Uniform, severe
Slowing (<20 m/s)
Yes No Yes No
Diabetic Neuropathy Nonuniform, intermediate to severe slowing Yes Maybe a Maybe a Yes
CIDP Nonuniform, multifocal, asymmetric, intermediate to severe slowing Yes Often Often Yes
AIDP Nonuniform, segmental slowing No Yes Yes Yes

Abbreviations: CIDP, chronic inflammatory demyelinating neuropathy; HNPP, hereditary neuropathy with liability to pressure palsies; m/s, meters per second.

Data from Carter GT, Weiss MD, Han JJ, et al. Charcot Marie Tooth Disease. Curr Treat Options Neurol.

a If superimposed focal compression or entrapment present (compression can occur in the absence of entrapment).



Segmental Demyelinating Neuropathies


All of the segmental demyelinating neuropathies, with the exception of hereditary neuropathy with liability to pressure palsies (HNPP), are acquired. HNPP typically presents as a mononeuropathy involving a nerve at a common entrapment site or as a multiple mononeuropathies, often following an episode of minor trauma. Conduction velocity is slowed to 10% to 70% of normal across the injured nerve segment. CB and temporal dispersion can also be demonstrated across sites of compression. In addition to findings associated with the focal nerve injury, there is a distinctive mild generalized sensorimotor peripheral neuropathy. It is characterized by diffuse sensory NCV slowing and prolongation of distal motor latencies with an infrequent and minor reduction of motor nerve conduction velocities. The amplitudes of CMAPs are normal or only slightly reduced.


Three subtypes of Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) have been described: acute inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (AIDP), acute motor axonal neuropathy, and acute motor and sensory axonal neuropathy. In North America and Europe, typical patients with GBS usually have AIDP as the underlying subtype and about 5% of patients have axonal subtypes. Large studies in Northern China, Japan, Central America, and South America show that axonal forms of the syndrome constitute 30% to 47% of cases. AIDP and the 2 axonal subtypes usually affect all 4 limbs and can involve the cranial nerves and respiration.


AIDP is the classic example of an acquired segmental demyelinating neuropathy. Motor nerve conduction abnormalities occur before sensory nerve abnormalities, with a nadir of abnormality occurring at week 3. Sensory nerve conduction abnormalities peak during week 4. Electrodiagnostic criteria for AIDP is summarized in Box 1 .



Box 1




  • 1.

    At least 1 of the following in 2 nerves:



    • a.

      Motor conduction velocity less than 90% of the lower limit of normal (LLN) (85% if distal CMAP amplitude <50% LLN)


    • b.

      Distal motor latency greater than 110% of the upper limit of normal (>120% if distal CMAP amplitude <100% LLN)


    • c.

      Proximal CMAP amplitude/distal CMAP amplitude ratio less than 0.5 and distal CMAP amplitude greater than 20% LLN


    • d.

      F-response latency greater than 120% of the upper limit of normal




or



  • 2.

    At least 2 of the following in 1 nerve if all others are unexcitable and distal CMAP amplitude is greater than 10% LLN:



    • a.

      Motor conduction velocity less than 90% LLN (85% if distal CMAP amplitude <50% LLN)


    • b.

      Distal motor latency greater than 110% of the upper limit of normal (>120% if distal CMAP amplitude <100% LLN)


    • c.

      Proximal CMAP amplitude/distal CMAP amplitude ratio less than 0.5 and distal CMAP amplitude greater than 20% of the LLN


    • d.

      F-response latency greater than 120% of the upper limit of normal




Electrodiagnostic criteria for AIDP

Data from Hughes RA, Cornblath DR. Guillain-Barré syndrome. Lancet 2005;366(9497):1653–66.


At initial presentation, too few EDX criteria of demyelination may be present for a definite diagnosis of AIDP. Repeating the examination in 7 to 10 days may be helpful in these cases. The most common electrophysiological findings in early GBS include decreased CMAP amplitudes, abnormal F waves, and abnormal H reflexes. In equivocal cases, observed disintegration of the CMAP over time strongly suggests a demyelinating disorder. The most sensitive EDX parameter in patients with early GBS is CB in the most proximal segments of the peripheral nervous system, directly determined in the Erb-to-axilla segment or indirectly as an absent H reflex. The lowest mean distal CMAP amplitude recorded within the first 30 days of onset is the best single electrodiagnostic predictor of prognosis. A value less than 20% of the lower limit of normal is associated with a poor functional outcome.


SNAP amplitude abnormalities are much more common than sensory distal latency or sensory conduction velocity abnormalities. Unlike the pattern in most other neuropathies, the median nerve tends to be affected earlier and more severely than the sural nerve. Approximately half of patients have a normal sural sensory study with abnormal median sensory study, which is referred to as the normal sural-abnormal median pattern.


In early AIDP, NEE typically shows decreased recruitment that is most prominent distally. Despite the primary and initial demyelinating process, fibrillation potentials and PSWs can appear 2 to 4 weeks after the onset of symptoms and are most prominent between weeks 6 to 10. Polyphasic MUAPs are most prominent between weeks 9 and 15.


The time course and evolution of symptoms as well as the electrophysiologic abnormalities distinguishes chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP) from AIDP. In general, the prevalence of CIDP may be underestimated because of the limitations in clinical, serologic, and electrophysiologic diagnostic criteria. There is a range of diagnostic criteria for CIDP. There are stringent diagnostic criteria for research purposes and more sensitive criteria that can identify a broader range of patients with CIDP who may benefit from treatment. There is no consensus on one criterion standard for making the diagnosis. Early in the course of CIDP, sensory abnormalities may appear in the median nerve before the sural nerve. In long-standing CIDP, all sensory responses may be absent. The combination of absent or abnormal SNAPS with normal sural responses occurs but is uncommon in CIDP compared with AIDP. Motor conduction velocities may be markedly reduced, F response latencies are very prolonged (or absent), and temporal dispersion is more prominent than observed in AIDP. Although motor conduction velocities are reduced by a greater percentage in the upper limb than in the lower limb, CMAP amplitudes tend to be more severely reduced in the lower limbs. NEE may show fibrillation potentials and PSWs in distal and proximal muscles, including the paraspinals, depending on disease severity Box 2 .



Box 2





  • Evaluation should satisfy at least 3 of the following in motor nerves (exceptions noted later):


  • 1.

    Conduction velocity less than 75% of the lower limit of normal (2 or more nerves) a


  • 2.

    Distal latency exceeding 130% of the upper limit of normal (2 or more nerves) b


  • 3.

    Evidence of unequivocal temporal dispersion or CB on proximal stimulation consisting of a proximal-to-distal amplitude ratio less than 0.7 (1 or more nerves) b,c


  • 4.

    F-response latency exceeding 130% of the upper limit of normal (1 or more nerves) a,b



a Excluding isolated ulnar or peroneal nerve abnormalities at the elbow or knee, respectively.


b Excluding isolated median nerve abnormality at the wrist.


c Excluding the presence of anomalous innervation (eg, median to ulnar nerve crossover).


Criteria suggestive of demyelination in the electrodiagnostic evaluation of CIDP

Data from Albers JW, et al. Acquired inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathies: clinical and electrodiagnostic features. Muscle Nerve 1989;12:435–51.


POEMS syndrome (polyneuropathy, organomegaly, endocrinopathy, monoclonal protein and skin changes) is a paraneoplastic disorder with a demyelinating peripheral neuropathy that is often mistaken for CIDP. Compared with CIDP, there is greater axonal loss (reduction of motor amplitudes and increased fibrillation potentials), greater slowing of the intermediate nerve segments, less common temporal dispersion and conduction block, and absent sural sparing.


There are several variants of CIDP that may also respond to treatment and are, therefore, important to recognize. One variant is multifocal motor neuropathy (MMN) with CB. An EDX evaluation shows motor CB at sites other than those of common entrapment, absence of temporal dispersion, normal distal motor latencies, and normal or mildly slow motor conduction velocities. Sensory-nerve-conduction studies are needed to exclude sensory abnormalities at the sites of CB in MMN and can help to differentiate MMN from CIDP. CB is not present in sensory nerves. Fasciculations are common on NEE, and MMN occasionally is misdiagnosed as motor neuron disease.


Axonal Mixed Sensorimotor Neuropathies


The axonal mixed sensorimotor neuropathies encompass the category of neuropathies with the longest differential diagnosis and include nutritional, toxic, and connective tissue disease–related neuropathies. They are electrodiagnostically indistinguishable and findings are typically symmetric. Sensory nerves are affected earlier than motor nerves, and distal lower limb nerves are affected before upper limb nerves. The earliest abnormality is a decrease in sural SNAP amplitude followed by the disappearance of the sural SNAP and H reflex. Subsequent abnormalities include decreased ulnar and median SNAPs along with decreased CMAP amplitude recording from the intrinsic foot muscles. There may be a slight prolongation of distal latencies and slowing of conduction velocities caused by the loss of the fastest conducting fibers but these changes do not overlap with criteria for demyelination. On NEE, fibrillation potentials, PSWs, and decreased recruitment appear first in the most distal lower limb muscles and much later in the distal upper limb muscles. Fibrillation potentials usually are not seen in the upper limb until after they are found in the tibialis anterior and gastrocnemius muscles. Motor unit remodeling occurs to varying degrees depending on the time course and severity of the disease and results in MUAP changes.


Axonal Neuropathies with Predominant Motor Involvement


Axonal neuropathies with predominant motor involvement may be hereditary or acquired. The hereditary neuropathies in this group are distal hereditary motor neuropathies (dHMN) and porphyria.


The dHMN compose a heterogeneous group of diseases that share the common feature of a length-dependent, predominantly motor neuropathy and present as a slowly progressive, length-dependent condition often starting in the first 2 decades. Several forms of dHMN have minor sensory abnormalities and may also have a significant upper-motor-neuron component. Overlap with the axonal forms of CMT disease (CMT2), juvenile forms of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), and hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP) exist. The CMAP from the extensor digitorum brevis muscle usually is low, but the CMAP recorded from more proximal muscles usually is normal or slightly slowed. NEE shows evidence of denervation in intrinsic foot and distal leg muscles.


DHMN types I and II are typical distal motor neuropathies beginning in the lower limbs and presenting in either childhood or adulthood respectively. If there is sensory involvement, the disease is termed CMT2F if it is caused by mutations in HSPB1 and CMT2L if the mutation is in HSPB8 . Type V is characterized by upper limb onset and can be caused by mutations in BSCL2 or GARS . If it is caused by a mutation in GARS and there is sensory involvement, it is termed CMT2D. Types III and IV have been linked to the same loci and are chronic forms of dHMN. They are differentiated by the presence of diaphragmatic palsy in type IV. Type VI occurs in infancy and is characterized by distal weakness and respiratory failure.


Porphyria presents with acute abdominal pain, agitation, and restlessness. Within 48 to 72 hours, weakness can develop. Weakness can occur distally or proximally and may start in either the upper or lower limb. The primary abnormality on NCS is reduction of CMAP amplitudes. SNAPs are reduced in approximately 50% of patients. NEE during the acute attack may show reduced recruitment. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs in affected muscles typically occur 4 to 6 weeks after the onset of an attack. Abnormal spontaneous activity can be present in both distal and proximal muscles, including the paraspinal muscles. Patients who have had multiple attacks may develop complex repetitive discharges (CRDs) and evidence of motor unit remodeling.


Axonal Sensory Neuropathies


Axonal sensory neuropathies may be hereditary or acquired. They are characterized by absent or decreased SNAPs with normal motor NCS. Minor NEE abnormalities in the intrinsic foot muscle, such as a few fibrillation potentials or chronic neurogenic MUAP changes, may be seen in long-standing cases. In one series of 35 patients found to have sensory neuropathy, nearly 50% of were categorized as idiopathic, with only 6% being hereditary and 11% paraneoplastic. A marked female predominance was also noted. In Friedreich ataxia (FA), antidromic SNAPs may be absent by 6 years of age, whereas CMAPs are preserved even in adulthood. In patients with FA followed over many years, NCS findings do not change significantly despite increasing functional impairment. H reflexes are generally absent, but blink reflexes are present. Mild recruitment abnormalities may be seen on NEE in long-standing disease. Patients with spinocerebellar ataxias (SCA) may also present with a concomitant predominantly sensory neuropathy (SCA1, SCA2, SCA3, SCA4, SCA18, SCA25, SCA27) but the abnormalities are not as severe as those seen in Friedreich ataxia. The hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathies (HSAN 1-V) are rare and have been classified into 5 types by mode of inheritance, age of onset, and clinical features. HSAN I is the most common type. The typical electrodiagnostic finding in HSAN I and II is complete absence of SNAPs in upper and lower extremities with normal motor NCS and NEE. In HSAN IV, NCS are normal but sympathetic skin responses are absent.


Combined Axon Loss and Demyelinating Neuropathies


Combined axon loss and demyelination are seen in diabetes mellitus and uremia.


Diabetic polyneuropathy presents in many forms, including distal symmetric form, cranial diabetic neuropathy, and focal and multifocal limb neuropathies. A unique feature of uremic neuropathy is that motor and sensory involvement occurs simultaneously rather than the sensory involvement preceding motor involvement. Abnormalities of sural nerve conduction and of late responses are present in all patients. Motor nerve conduction velocities may be slowed to 60% to 70% of the lower limit of normal, and F waves are prolonged early in the course of the neuropathy, indicating both proximal and distal demyelination. Findings on NEE are similar to those seen in other axonal peripheral neuropathies, with fibrillation potentials appearing in the distal upper limb muscles after denervation has reached the tibialis anterior and gastrocnemius in the lower extremity.


Motor Neuron Disease


The various forms of motor neuron disease, including the spinal muscular atrophies (SMA), ALS, and polio, share several electrodiagnostic features but differ clinically particularly with respect to disease progression. General EDX characteristics of motor neuron disease include normal sensory NCS, low motor amplitudes, and normal distal motor latencies and conduction velocities. With profound loss of motor amplitude, conduction velocities may drop because of the loss of the fastest conduction fibers. The NEE reveals a decreased recruitment pattern, either small or large MUAPs (depending on degree of anterior horn cell loss) with or without evidence of remodeling depending on the specific disease process, and spontaneous activity, including positive sharp waves, fibrillation potentials, fasciculations, and CRDs.


SMA


The EDX features of the proximal SMAs I to IV, as classified by Dubowitz, are determined by the rate of anterior horn cell degeneration and the stage in the course of the disease. SMA I, or Werdnig-Hoffmann disease, presents in utero or in infancy, is rapidly progressive and generally leads to death before 2 years of age if ventilatory support and manual or mechanical airway clearance (ie, cough assist) is not provided. SMA II has an age of onset between 6 and 18 months. Children usually achieve independent sitting but not independent ambulation and often survive into adulthood. Cranial nerve innervated muscles are less likely to be involved in SMA II. SMA III, or Kugelberg-Welander disease, has an insidious onset between 3 and 30 years of age and is slowly progressive, with ambulation possible for 10 to 30 years after disease onset.


Sensory NCS are normal in all forms of SMA. CMAPs are decreased in proportion to the degree of muscle atrophy. Motor velocities are most likely to be abnormally slow in SMA I because of the extensive loss of large myelinated axons and slower baseline conduction velocities in children younger than 5 years. Motor conduction velocity slowing is usually no more than 25% less than the lower limit of normal.


The most profound loss of MUAPs is seen in SMA I. With maximal effort, only a few MUAPs may fire at a rapid rate. Small MUAPs are common because reinnervation cannot compensate for the rapid loss of anterior horn cells. Myopathic-appearing, low-amplitude, polyphasic, short-duration MUAPs also may be seen because of muscle fiber degeneration. In the other types of SMA, large-amplitude MUAPs (up to 10–15 mV) may be observed because the number of muscle fibers per motor unit increases as reinnervation occurs. These large units may be polyphasic with increased duration. Satellite potentials appear as remodeling occurs.


On NEE in SMA I, fibrillation potentials and PSWs are diffuse and seen in many muscles, including the paraspinals. Fasciculation potentials are uncommon and are found in less than 35% of children with SMA1. Spontaneously firing MUAPs at 5 to 15 Hz, even during sleep, are a unique EDX feature of both SMA I and II. In more chronic forms of SMA, fibrillation potentials and PSWs are even more common and increase in frequency as age increases. CRDs are often seen in SMA II and III, and fasciculations are more common than in SMA I.


Kennedy disease


Kennedy disease, also known as X-linked bulbospinal muscular atrophy, is a slowly progressive X-linked recessive motor neuron disease characterized by proximal limb and bulbar weakness, tongue atrophy, and prominent muscle cramping and fasciculations. In addition, it is associated with diabetes, gynecomastia, and testicular atrophy because of an androgen receptor defect. Although patients generally do not have sensory complaints, absence or reduction of SNAPs is a common finding. Motor NCS are normal or may show a reduction in amplitude. NEE shows large-amplitude and long-duration MUAPs consistent with an indolent neurogenic disease course. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs may be prominent and present in all muscles examined. Fasciculation potentials are also abundant in limb, facial, and tongue muscles.


Adult nonhereditary motor neuron disease


The most common form of adult nonhereditary motor neuron disease is ALS. Less common forms of adult nonhereditary motor neuron disease include progressive muscular atrophy (PMA) with lower motor neuron findings only, progressive lateral sclerosis (PLS) with upper motor neuron findings only, and progressive bulbar palsy (PBP) with only lower motor neuron bulbar muscle involvement. Over time, individuals initially diagnosed with PMA, PLS, or PBP often develop ALS. Approximately 10% of patients with ALS have familial ALS that can be inherited either as an autosomal dominant or recessive trait. Clinical and electrodiagnostic features of these patients are no different from those with sporadic ALS.


For years, Lambert’s criteria were the standard for the electromyographic diagnosis of ALS. The following 4 criteria must be met to make a definite diagnosis of ALS : (1) positive sharp waves or fibrillation potentials in 3 of 5 limbs, counting the head as a limb (For a limb to be considered affected, at least 2 muscles innervated by different peripheral nerves and roots should show active denervation. ); (2) normal sensory nerve conduction studies ; (3) normal motor conduction studies (However, if the CMAP amplitude is very low, the conduction velocity may decrease as low as 70% of the lower limit of normal. ); and (4) reduced recruitment of MUAPs on needle examination. The EDX findings in PMA are identical to those in ALS; the distinction between the two diagnoses is made by the presence or absence of upper motor neuron signs on physical examination. By definition, the EDX examination is normal in PLS. In PBP, active denervation is found only in the muscles of the head and neck.


In 1990, a special task force of the World Federation of Neurology developed the El Escorial Criteria for diagnosing ALS in response to the stringency of the Lambert criteria. The EDX portion of the criteria differs somewhat from Lambert’s criteria. The criteria stated that electrodiagnostic findings must be present in at least 2 of 4 regions (bulbar, cervical, thoracic, and lumbar) for a diagnosis of ALS. Electrophysiologic features required to define clinically definite disease include the following: (1) reduced recruitment, (2) large MUAPs, and (3) fibrillations potentials. The revised El Escorial Criteria was developed in 2000 and categorizes patients into 4 levels of certainty : clinically definite ALS, clinically probable ALS, clinically probable laboratory–supported ALS, and clinically possible ALS. For electromyogram (EMG) findings to support a diagnosis of ALS, there must be signs of chronic and active denervation in at least 2 muscles in the cervical and lumbosacral regions and 1 muscle in the brainstem and thoracic regions.


In December 2006, an International Federation of Clinical Neurophysiology-sponsored consensus conference was convened on Awaji Island, Japan to consider how clinical neurophysiology could be used more effectively to facilitate early diagnosis. An evidence-based approach was used and consensus recommendations were made ( Box 3 ). They concluded that because needle EMG is essentially an extension of the clinical examination in detecting features of denervation and reinnervation, the finding of neurogenic EMG changes in a muscle should have the same diagnostic significance as clinical features of neurogenic change in an individual muscle. Specific EMG features suggestive of ALS were found to be the following: (1) chronic neurogenic change (MUAPs of increased amplitude and duration, usually with an increased number of phases, as assessed by qualitative or quantitative studies); (2) decreased motor unit recruitment, defined by rapid firing of a reduced number of motor units; (3) presence of unstable and complex MUAPs using a narrow band pass filter (500 Hz to 5 kHz); (4) fibrillations and PSWs recorded in strong, nonwasted muscles; and (5) fasciculation potentials (preferably of complex morphology) are equivalent to fibrillations and PSWs in their clinical significance (see Box 3 ).



Box 3





  • 1. Principles (from the Airlie House criteria)



  • The diagnosis of ALS requires


  • 1.

    The presence of



    • a.

      Evidence of lower motor neuron (LMN) degeneration by clinical, electrophysiological, or neuropathological examination


    • b.

      Evidence of upper motor neuron (UMN) degeneration by clinical examination


    • c.

      Progressive spread of symptoms or signs within a region or to other regions, as determined by history, physical examination, or electrophysiological tests



  • 2.

    The absence of



    • a.

      Electrophysiological or pathologic evidence of other disease processes that might explain the signs of LMN or UMN degeneration


    • b.

      Neuroimaging evidence of other disease processes that might explain the observed clinical and electrophysiological signs





  • 2. Diagnostic categories



  • Clinically definite ALS is defined by clinical or electrophysiological evidence by the presence of LMN and UMN signs in the bulbar region and at least 2 spinal regions or the presence of LMN and UMN signs in 3 spinal regions.



  • Clinically probable ALS is defined on clinical or electrophysiological evidence by LMN and UMN signs in at least 2 regions, with some UMN signs necessarily rostral to (above) the LMN signs.



  • Clinically possible ALS is defined when clinical or electrophysiological signs of UMN and LMN dysfunction are found in only one region, or UMN signs are found alone in 2 or more regions, or LMN signs are found rostral to UMN signs. Neuroimaging and clinical laboratory studies will have been performed and other diagnoses must have been excluded.



These recommendations emphasize the equivalence of clinical and electrophysiological tests in establishing neurogenic change in bodily regions. The category of clinically probable laboratory-supported ALS is redundant.


Awaji-shima consensus recommendations for the application of electrophysiological tests to the diagnosis of ALS, as applied to the revised El Escorial Criteria (Airlie House 1998)

Data from de Carvalho M, et al. Electrodiagnostic criteria for diagnosis of ALS. Clin Neurophysiol 2008;119:497–503.


Early in the progression of ALS, many patients with a suspected clinical diagnosis of ALS do not meet the electrodiagnostic criteria for a definite diagnosis. A repeat study several months later will often fulfill the EDX criteria for diagnosis. On the other hand, some patients who do not fulfill the clinical criteria for diagnosis because of the limited distribution of muscle weakness may have evidence of widespread denervation on EDX, allowing a diagnosis of ALS to be made based on the Awaji-shima consensus. This diagnosis is important when determining eligibility for clinical trial participation.


NCS changes in ALS are characterized by decreased CMAP amplitudes. The mild slowing of motor conduction velocity and the prolongation of F-wave latencies is attributed to the loss of the fastest conducting fibers. An interesting phenomenon observed in many patients is that of the split hand whereby CMAP amplitudes are decreased to a greater degree on the radial side of the hand than on the ulnar side. CMAPs obtained from the abductor pollicis brevis and first dorsal interosseous are much lower than those obtained from the abductor digit minimi. More than 2 stimulation sites should be used in the evaluation of motor nerves to exclude the presence of CB because MMN with CB occasionally can be misdiagnosed as ALS. The ulnar nerve can be stimulated easily at the wrist, below and above the elbow, in the axilla and in the supraclavicular fossa. In limbs with upper motor neuron signs, H reflexes may be elicited from muscles in which they normally cannot be obtained. SNAP amplitudes may be abnormal in a small percentage of patients with otherwise typical ALS. There have been case reports of concomitant sporadic ALS and a sensory neuropathy for which alternative causes could not be identified. Repetitive stimulation studies may show decrement in CMAP with stimulation at 3 Hz. This decrement is caused by the instability of neuromuscular transmission in collateral nerve terminal sprouts. Some degree of decrement occurs in more than half of patients with ALS, and the amplitude decrement is usually less than 10%.


The NEE is the most important part of the EDX in suspected ALS. Fasciculation potentials are seen in most patients with ALS but they are not necessary to meet diagnostic criteria. The significance of fasciculations depends on the company they keep and are pathologic only when accompanied by fibrillation potentials, PSWs, or the appropriate neurogenic MUAP changes. In patients with advanced disease, fibrillations potentials and PSWs are prominent in most muscles but they may be sparse early in the course of the disease when collateral sprouting can keep up with denervation. Occasionally, CRDs and doublets or triplets are seen in patients with ALS but these are not typical findings. The thoracic paraspinals should be examined on NEE because they are typically spared in cervical and lumbar spinal stenosis. The primary NEE finding in ALS in involved muscles is decreased recruitment. If the disease is progressing slowly, MUAP amplitudes and durations become increased as a result of collateral sprouting. If the disease course is rapid, denervation outpaces reinnervation and enlarged MUAPs do not develop. The density and distribution of fasciculations and fibrillations does not correlate with the disease course or prognosis. Serial EDX are not useful for monitoring disease progression once a definite diagnosis has been made.


Polio


Acute poliomyelitis is an acquired disease of the anterior horn cells that most electromyographers likely will not encounter. However, the sequelae of previous polio frequently are encountered in the EMG laboratory and make the diagnosis of any superimposed neuromuscular problem difficult. In both acute and old polio, the NCS findings are similar to those of other motor neuron diseases: normal sensory studies, normal motor conduction velocities, and low CMAP amplitudes in atrophic muscles. Patients with postpolio frequently have superimposed entrapment neuropathies, such as median or ulnar mononeuropathies, from years of using assistive ambulatory devices.


The NEE in acute polio will begin to show fibrillation potentials and PSWs in affected muscles 2 to 3 weeks after the onset of weakness. Fasciculation potentials may appear before fibrillation potentials. Initially, the recruitment pattern is decreased, but MUAP size is normal because remodeling of the motor units has not yet had time to occur. As time passes, collateral sprouting and motor unit remodeling occur, creating giant MUAPs with amplitudes up to 20 mV. Fibrillation potentials may persist indefinitely but are small (<100 uV) in chronic polio.


When patients with a history of polio are examined 20 to 30 years later, reduced recruitment, giant MUAPs, and fibrillation potentials may be seen diffusely, not just in muscles clinically involved in the acute polio episode. For this reason, superimposed neuromuscular disorders can be impossible to diagnose by EDX. A superimposed neuropathy may be diagnosed if sensory conduction studies are abnormal, but one cannot distinguish accurately between a pure sensory and a sensorimotor neuropathy. SFEMG studies in patients with chronic polio show increased jitter, blocking, and fiber density.


Fifteen percent to 80% of patients with a history of polio develop postpolio syndrome years after their acute illness. Halstead’s criteria for a diagnosis of postpolio syndrome include: (1) history of acute polio; (2) a period of at least 15 years of neurologic and functional stability before the onset of new problems; (3) gradual or abrupt onset of new neurogenic weakness; and (4) no apparent medical, orthopedic, or neurologic cause for the new weakness. EDX is not useful in differentiating between chronic polio with and without postpolio syndrome because both groups have similar findings of NEE and SFEMG studies. The only useful role of EDX in diagnosing postpolio syndrome is to confirm that patients did indeed have polio in the past.


Neuromuscular junction disorders


Disorders of the neuromuscular junction (NMJ) may be classified as presynaptic (Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome [LEMS] and botulism) or postsynaptic (myasthenia gravis [MG]) depending on the location of the defect. NMJ transmission disorders may also be acquired or inherited (congenital myasthenic syndromes). Presynaptic or postsynaptic dysfunction influences the electrophysiologic response to repetitive nerve stimulation (RNS), a technique developed to assist in the EDX of NMJ disorders. In general, findings on routine NCS and NEE in the NMJ disorders are similar to the findings in myopathies. Motor and sensory NCS are normal, with the exception of reduced CMAP amplitudes in presynaptic disorders. MUAPs in affected muscles are either normal or polyphasic with low amplitudes or decreased duration. Small MUAPs are caused by decreased neuromuscular transmission and are not truly myopathic. A unique feature of NMJ disorders is that cooling the muscle may minimize abnormalities seen with RNS and may cause an increase in duration and amplitude in myopathic-appearing MUAPs. Recruitment pattern is full with a submaximal muscle contraction. Moment-to-moment amplitude variation, unstable motor unit, is seen on NEE when a single MUAP is isolated. Fibrillation potentials are seen only in severe disease with complete disintegration of the NMJ. Table 3 outlines the EDX findings in various disorders of the NMJ transmission.



Table 3

Electrodiagnostic findings in NMJ transmission disorders
































































Parameter MG LEMS Botulism
Distal latency nL nL nL
Conduction velocity nL nL nL
SNAP amplitude nL nL nL
CMAP amplitude Usually nL Decreased nL or decreased
Slow RNS Decrement Decrement ± Decrement
Fast RNS or brief exercise ± Mild increment Large increment (lasting 20–30 s) Intermediate increment (lasting up to 4 min)
Postactivation exhaustion Yes Yes No
MUAP configuration Unstable motor unit (weak muscles) ± dec amplitude & duration Unstable motor unit (all muscles), dec amplitude & duration, inc polyphasics Unstable motor unit (weak muscles), dec amplitude & duration, inc polyphasics
Recruitment nL or early Early Early
Spontaneous activity Fibrillation in severe disease None Fibrillation in severe disease
SFEMG inc jitter & blocking (increases with inc firing rate) inc jitter & blocking (decreases with inc firing rate) inc jitter & blocking (decreases with inc firing rate)

Abbreviations: dec, decreased; inc, increased; nL, normal.

Data from Krivickas LS. Electrodiagnosis in neuromuscular diseases. Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am 1998;9:99.


RNS studies are a technique for evaluating the safety factor of the NMJ. The safety factor refers to the number of acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) that must be opened to generate an end plate potential large enough to depolarize the muscle membrane and produce muscle contraction. In healthy individuals, the safety factor can be reduced by exercise or repetitive nerve activation but not to a degree large enough to prevent the generation of an endplate potential. In presynaptic disorders, acetylcholine release is diminished, resulting in too few postsynaptic AChRs opening, thus decreasing the safety factor. In postsynaptic disorders, a normal amount of acetylcholine is released but too few AChRs are available for binding and the safety factor is again reduced.


RNS studies generally are performed at 2 stimulation rates: slow (2–3 Hz) and fast (20–30 Hz). With slow stimulation, each successive stimulus results in fewer vesicles of acetylcholine being released. In individuals with NMJ disorders, the safety factor is reduced. In patients with a baseline low safety factor, the safety factor is reduced to the extent that NMJ block occurs in some single muscle fibers so that fewer fibers contribute to the overall CMAP, thus reducing the CMAP amplitude. To perform slow RNS, a train of 5 supramaximal stimuli is delivered. A decrement in CMAP amplitude of greater than 10% is abnormal. When a decrement occurs, it should be greatest between the first and second recorded stimuli. The patient is then asked to exercise or maximally contract the target muscle for 10 to 20 seconds in the setting of a decrement and 30 to 60 seconds in the setting of no decrement. The normal response is up to a 15% increase in CMAP amplitude immediately following exercise. The train of 5 supramaximal stimuli is repeated immediately after exercise, at 30 seconds and at 1, 2, 3, and 4 minutes after exercise. Patients with defects in NMJ transmission may demonstrate complete or partial repair of the decrement immediately after exercise (postexercise facilitation); after 3 to 4 minutes, the decrement worsens (postactivation exhaustion). If the patient is too weak to exercise or is unable to follow directions concerning exercise, fast repetitive stimulation (20–30 Hz) of 1 or 2 seconds may be substituted for the exercise to produce the same result.


SFEMG is the gold standard for the electrodiagnosis of disorders involving the NMJ when repetitive stimulation studies are negative or nonrevealing. Jitter is increased in both presynaptic and postsynaptic NMJ disorders but is nonspecific because it is also increased in motor neuron diseases, myopathies, and neuropathies in which immature NMJs are present. An SFEMG is most commonly performed in the extensor digitorum communis muscle because it is easy to isolate single MUAPs in this muscle. Twenty pairs of MUAPs are recorded, and the study is considered abnormal if the mean jitter of all pairs is increased, if 2 or more individual pairs have jitter greater than a given parameter (based on age), or if frequent blocking occurs. Blocking of neuromuscular transmission begins to occur when jitter reaches 80 microseconds.


MG


MG is the most commonly encountered NMJ disorder and is a model for the electrophysiologic findings of all postsynaptic NMJ disorders. Other postsynaptic disorders include a subset of postsynaptic congenital myasthenic syndromes, organophosphate poisoning, and poisoning with curarelike compounds. Routine sensory and motor NCS are normal, with the exception of low CMAPs from the most severely weak muscles. When weakness is fairly severe in the muscle from which a CMAP is being recorded, a strong initial stimulus should be delivered to the nerve to avoid the necessity of multiple stimuli, which may result in NMJ fatigue and an even lower CMAP than would be recorded otherwise. A motor NCS should be conducted for every planned repetitive stimulation study. The abductor pollicis brevis and abductor digit minimi are the easiest to study with repetitive stimulation because they can be immobilized more easily than proximal muscles. However, in mild disease, proximal muscles are more likely to show an abnormal response to repetitive stimulation. The slow repetitive stimulation protocol outlined previously is used in an attempt to elicit the classic triad of findings characteristic of MG: (1) CMAP decrement with slow repetitive stimulation, (2) repair of decrement immediately after exercise, and (3) worsening of the decrement 2 to 4 minutes after exercise. If the RNS study of a distal muscle is negative, a proximal muscle should be evaluated; the nasalis and trapezius are commonly used proximal muscles. In patients with ocular myasthenia, it may be necessary to perform repetitive stimulation of the orbicularis oculi muscle. The most significant finding on NEE is MUAP moment-to-moment amplitude variation. This variation must be studied by isolating a single MUAP and observing its morphology over time. Amplitude variation is the needle electrode equivalent of the decrement seen on RNS studies. A small number of patients with severe, chronic disease have fibrillation potentials and PSWs in the weakest muscles because the muscles are functionally denervated at the NMJ. The dropout of single muscle fibers can decrease the amplitude and duration of MUAPs, giving them a myopathic appearance, which occurs more frequently than the presence of fibrillation potentials and PSWs.


Single fiber EMG is necessary only when repetitive nerve stimulation studies fail to show a decrement, NEE does not show moment-to-moment amplitude variation in affected muscles and AChR antibody testing is negative. Generally, the extensor digitorum communis is examined first. If this study is normal, then a single fiber EMG is performed in the frontalis muscle. Single fiber EMG may be performed without stopping anticholinesterase medications because jitter is usually abnormal even while taking medication. Anticholinesterase medication must be discontinued 12 hours before repetitive nerve stimulation studies in order for accurate and valid assessment of obtained results.


LEMS


LEMS is the most commonly encountered presynaptic disorder of neuromuscular transmission. Botulism, tetanus, and some forms of congenital myasthenia are also presynaptic disorders. Sensory NCS are normal in pure LEMS. Because more than 50% of patients with LEMS have a malignancy, most commonly small cell carcinoma, a concomitant paraneoplastic sensory or sensorimotor neuropathy is common. Motor NCS are characterized by a low CMAP, often only a few 100 μV. After 10 to 20 seconds of exercise (isometric muscle contraction), the CMAP amplitude will increase by more than 100% because of the accumulation of calcium in the presynaptic terminal, which increases ACh release. If exercise is performed for longer than 20 seconds, this facilitation may be replaced by postexercise exhaustion in which no increase in amplitude is seen. Low RNS will produce a decrement similar to that seen in MG except that repair of the decrement following exercise is much pronounced and accompanied by a large increase in amplitude as previously described. This response lasts 20 to 30 seconds and is then once again replaced by a low CMAP, which decreases with repetitive nerve stimulation. In all patients with low CMAPs, a brief period of exercise should be given and another CMAP elicited to look for a presynaptic neuromuscular transmission defect. In severely weak patients who are unable to exercise, rapid repetitive stimulation may be applied for 1 to 2 seconds to generate an increment in CMAP amplitude. In LEMS, an increment in CMAP with exercise usually can be detected in any muscle examined. Once the increment has been demonstrated, there is no need to repeat the study in additional muscles. In mild early cases, an increment may be isolated to proximal muscles.


The hallmark of NEE in patients with LEMS is moment-to-moment amplitude variation in all muscles examined, independent of clinical weakness. Because only a few muscle fibers per motor unit may fire, the MUAPs may be short in duration, low amplitude, and polyphasic, with a myopathic appearance. With sustained voluntary contraction, MUAPs may increase in amplitude and duration, losing their myopathic appearance. This feature can help distinguish them from the firing pattern seen in myopathies. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs are not present. SFEMG shows markedly increased jitter and blocking in all muscles, unlike MG whereby jitter is increased in only the most severely affected muscles. In LEMS, both jitter and blocking decrease as firing rate increases.


Botulism


The EXD findings in botulism are similar to those seen in LEMS with a few key differences. The CMAP amplitude is not as severely reduced, and the incremental response to exercise is somewhat less dramatic but should be at least 40%. The increase in CMAP amplitude persists much longer than in LEMS, often for as long as 4 minutes. In infants, it may last up to 20 minutes. In severe cases of botulism, rapid RNS may not result in facilitation because of the complete block of ACh release by the toxin. In these cases, the endplates break down because of the lack of ACh and functional denervation occurs resulting in the presence of fibrillation potentials and PSWs. Unlike LEMS, only clinically weak muscles show EMG changes. Bulbar muscles should be examined in mild cases because they are usually affected first and most severely.


Myopathies


The myopathic disorders include the progressive muscular dystrophies, congenital myopathies, metabolic myopathies, mitochondrial myopathies, acquired inflammatory myopathies, and some ion channel disorders. The EDX examination is less sensitive for detecting myopathies compared with other groups of neuromuscular diseases. It is also rarely helpful in differentiating between the various myopathic disorders. The patchy distribution of abnormalities presents a challenge during EMG of a suspected myopathy. EDX abnormalities seen with myopathies are nonspecific and are also seen in some nonmyopathic disorders. NCS are usually normal in myopathies unless the underlying muscle being tested is atrophic. Sensory NCS are always normal unless there is an underlying peripheral neuropathy. The NEE may show several types of spontaneous activity, including fibrillations potentials, PSWs, CRDs, and myotonic discharges. Insertional activity may be normal, increased, or decreased depending on the type of myopathy, distribution, and stage of disease. The recruitment pattern is early, with the addition of MUAPs with a low level of effort. In mild disease, the presence of early recruitment is not as obvious. Motor units may be in various stages of demise and may show low amplitudes, increased polyphasia, and decreased duration. Decreased MUAP duration is the most sensitive indicator of a myopathic process and quantitative EMG can assist in the detection. Presentations vary on NEE. Some myopathies present with isolated abnormal spontaneous activity, whereas some severe end-stage chronic myopathies develop a neurogenic appearance when only a few motor units per muscle remain. EMG abnormalities are most likely to be found in the limb girdle muscles and paraspinals.


Progressive muscular dystrophies


With the availability of molecular genetic testing for the identification of increasing numbers of progressive muscular dystrophies, the role of EDX examination is decreasing. In all of the progressive muscular dystrophies, the needle feel on insertion and the ease of needle advancement changes as the muscle is replaced by fat and connective tissue. The muscle develops a gritty feel and physical resistance to needle movement develops over time. The EDX findings in the muscular dystrophies are similar to those found in other myopathies, with a few unique characteristics. In Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) and Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD), fibrillation potentials and PSWs are widespread, although they are somewhat less prominent in BMD. Occasionally, CRDs and myotonic discharges are present but they are not prominent. In addition to myopathic-appearing MUAPs, large-amplitude and increased-duration MUAPs may be seen. These MUAPs are a result of muscle fiber hypertrophy or increased fiber density motor units caused by remodeling following muscle degeneration. In facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD), fibrillation potentials and PSWs may or may not be present. When they are present, they are less abundant than in DMD. Unlike DMD, large-amplitude, long-duration motor units are not seen. The earliest muscles involved are facial muscles, but NEE is often not helpful because typical facial muscle MUAPs may seem myopathic when compared with limb muscles. Other affected muscles that may be tested are the scapular stabilizers, biceps, and triceps. The tibialis anterior is the first muscle affected in the lower limbs. Similar findings can be seen in individuals with limb girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMDs) in clinically weak muscles. The main difference between FSHD and LGMD is that MUAPs amplitudes tend to be larger in the latter. The NEE findings in Emery-Dreifuss muscular dystrophy are similar those found in other progressive muscular dystrophies, with a mixed pattern of small and large MUAPs. A unique characteristic of Emery-Dreifuss is more severe involvement of biceps and triceps than more proximal upper extremity muscles.


Myotonic muscular dystrophy has unique EDX features, including the presence of myotonic discharges and response to high-rate RNS. At low-rate RNS, no CMAP decrement is present. However, at high-rate RNS, a progressive decrement is seen. Myotonic potentials are induced by both needle movement and voluntary muscle contraction. They are most notable in the distal muscles and may not be present in all of the muscles examined. Fibrillation potentials are present and may be caused by spontaneous discharges of innervated single muscle fibers or by denervation. An accompanying peripheral neuropathy has been detected in some individuals with myotonic dystrophy.


Congenital myopathies


The most common congenital myopathies are central core disease, multicore disease, nemaline myopathy, centronuclear myopathy (also called myotubular myopathy), and congenital fiber-type disproportion. In general, the congenital myopathies have nonspecific myopathic changes on EDX. However, a normal examination can be seen with congenital fiber-type disproportion. Abnormal spontaneous activity is uncommon except in centronuclear myopathy, which often has fibrillation potentials, PSWs, CRDs, and occasionally myotonic discharges (Hawkes). A concomitant defect in NMJ transmission has been described in a few patients with centronuclear myopathy.


Mitochondrial myopathies


Mitochondrial myopathies also have nonspecific EDX findings. In mild cases, the EDX can be normal. Despite the common complaint of activity-induced fatigue, RNS studies are normal. Some individuals with mitochondrial disease have EDX findings showing a concomitant peripheral neuropathy.


Metabolic myopathies


The metabolic myopathies include disorders of glycogen metabolism, lipid metabolism, and myoadenylate deaminase deficiency (MADD). There are 5 known glycogen metabolism disorders that have EDX abnormalities: glycogen storage disease (GSD) type II (acid maltase deficiency, Pompe disease), GSD type III (debranching enzyme deficiency), GSD type IV (branching enzyme deficiency), GSD type V (myophosphorylase deficiency, McArdle disease), and type VII (phosphofructokinase deficiency, Tarui disease). Acid maltase deficiency is unique in that it produces profuse spontaneous activity, including fibrillations, PSWs, CRDs, and myotonic discharges. Spontaneous activity is most prominent in the paraspinal muscles. Findings of myotonic discharges in the paraspinal muscles of an adult with proximal limb and respiratory weakness suggest Pompe disease/acid maltase deficiency. Debranching enzyme deficiency (GSD type III) can be distinguished by a concomitant peripheral neuropathy in some patients. They may also have fibrillation potentials and CRDs, although to a lesser degree than GSD type II. Myotonic discharges are not a common finding with debranching enzyme deficiency. Patients diagnosed with McArdle disease experience frequent muscle cramping and contracture. On NEE, muscle contracture is electrically silent despite obvious prolonged muscle contractions. At the onset of a contracture, the interference pattern amplitude declines as does the number of MUAPs firing. Gradually over minutes, electrical silence occurs. In many patients, the NEE is normal when they are not experiencing muscle cramping. When the disease is severe enough to cause permanent weakness, myopathic-appearing MUAPs can be seen. Patients with late-onset disease are likely to have fibrillation potentials, PSWs, and CRDs. An abnormal response to low-rate and high-rate RNS has been reported in some patients with McArdle disease, suggesting a concomitant defect in neuromuscular transmission. Data on the EDX findings in Tarui disease are minimal but may be similar to those found in McArdle disease in some patients.


The EDX findings in lipid metabolism disorders that result in weakness, carnitine deficiency, and carnitine palmitoyltransferase deficiency (CPT) are nonspecific and not well described. In most cases of carnitine deficiency, myopathic-appearing MUAPs are seen. In severe disease, extremely weak muscles show fibrillation potentials, PSWs, and CRDs. A superimposed sensorimotor peripheral neuropathy has also been reported in patients with CPT. The EDX is normal in MADD.


Inflammatory myopathies


Although clinical features and muscle biopsy findings of polymyositis and dermatomyositis can distinguish the two disorders, their electrodiagnostic findings are identical. NEE of proximal muscles and paraspinals at multiple levels should be examined. In some cases, findings are only seen in the paraspinal muscles. Abnormal findings on NEE may be patchy in distribution necessitating multiple needle insertions within the same muscle. If no abnormalities are detected in a clinically weak muscle, then a second or even third insertion site should be evaluated. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs are common and their quantity may be reflective of the severity of disease, although no correlative studies have been done. However, serial EDX studies are not recommended to evaluate the response to treatment. The EDX can be used to help distinguish between exacerbation of the inflammatory myopathy and the progression of weakness as a result of steroid myopathy in those individuals receiving treatment with corticosteroids. CRDs are common in chronic stages of the disease, and the muscle may have a gritty feel on needle insertion because of the replacement of muscle tissue with connective tissue. MUAP morphology changes are similar to those seen in other myopathies. In chronic stages of the disease, there may be some large-amplitude MUAPs among the typical myopathic motor units that are small with polyphasia.


Inclusion body myositis (IBM) may be distinguished from polymyositis by its pattern of muscle weakness, clinic course, EDX findings, and distinctive features on muscle biopsy. EDX findings are similar to those found in polymyositis and dermatomyositis; however, fibrillation potentials and PSWs are more prominent in IBM and may be found in almost every muscle examined. CRDs, myotonic discharges, and fasciculations may also be more prominent in IBM. MUAPs vary in amplitude and duration depending on the chronicity of the illness and may seem myopathic, neuropathic, or mixed. In addition to proximal muscle involvement, distal muscles, including the forearm flexors, hand intrinsics, and tibialis anterior, are involved. The quadriceps muscles are typically involved as seen by NEE, whereas the glutei are often spared.


Channelopathies


The ion channel disorders encompass both myotonic disorders and the periodic paralyses. Myotonic dystrophy involves abnormalities in the sodium channel and calcium-activated potassium channel. Myotonia congenita is a chloride channel disorder, hypokalemic periodic paralysis is a calcium channel disorder, and hyperkalemic periodic paralysis and paramyotonia congenital are sodium channel disorders.


There are 2 variants of myotonia congenita. Thomsen disease is autosomal dominant and Becker disease is autosomal recessive. In both forms, diffuse myotonic discharges are seen in most muscles and may prevent the assessment of individual MUAPs. MUAPs seem normal with Thomsen disease but may be short in duration and amplitude with long-standing Becker disease. Amplitude decrement with rapid RNS is seen in Thomsen disease, whereas a similar decrement is seen with both rapid and slow rates of RNS with Becker disease.


Clinically, paramyotonia congenita and myotonia congenita are often confused. On EDX evaluation, there are distinct differences. In paramyotonia congenita, a decrement in CMAP occurs either after cooling the muscle or immediately after several minutes of forceful exercise and the CMAP amplitude does not return to baseline for more than 1 hour. In myotonia congentia, a smaller decrement is seen following exercise and it often recovers within a few minutes after stopping exercise. On NEE, cooling the limb with ice water or exercising the limb can cause decreased recruitment that approaches an electrically silent contracture in some individuals with paramyotonia congenita. Between episodes of muscle stiffness, MUAPs are normal but may be difficult to assess because of the persistent and diffuse myotonia, particularly in the distal limb muscles. Fibrillation potentials, PSWs, and increased myotonic discharges may be observed during episodes of weakness, before the onset of complete electrical silence. Abnormal spontaneous activity is not observed during asymptomatic periods.


Attacks of hyperkalemic periodic paralysis are triggered by rest following cold exposure, exercise, immobilization, fasting, and heavy meals. After exercise, a CMAP decrement is noted. It is preceded by a CMAP increment and gradually reaches its nadir by 20 minutes following exercise. Clinical and electrical myotonia may or may not be present. Patients may only display electrical myotonia, which is usually present in all muscles on NEE, even during asymptomatic periods. At the beginning of an attack, complete electrical silence may occur. Some affected individuals eventually develop mild weakness, and myopathic-appearing MUAPs are present on NEE between attacks.


Attacks of hypokalemic periodic paralysis are triggered by rest following carbohydrate loading, strenuous exercise, and stress. During attacks, the muscle membrane becomes unexcitable. CMAP amplitudes decline severely or disappear altogether. While the CMAP is in the process of declining, rapid (10 Hz) RNS can be used to reverse the decline in amplitude. As an attack progresses, recruitment and MUAP amplitude and duration decreases. Eventually at the nadir of the attack, electrical silence occurs. Fibrillation potentials and PSWs may be observed between the onset of the attack and electrical silence. Myotonic potentials are not seen. In most patients, the NEE is normal between attacks. A few patients with permanent weakness have myopathic-appearing MUAPs and fibrillation potentials.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Apr 17, 2017 | Posted by in PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION | Comments Off on Electrodiagnosis in Neuromuscular Disease

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access