Cementless Acetabular Fixation





The first total hip arthroplasty was performed in 1938 in London more than 20 years before polymethylmethacrylate would be introduced as a bone cement. With the introduction of his cemented hip prosthesis in the 1960s, Charnley forever changed the future of total hip arthroplasty. Although the early results with cemented cups were excellent, it became clear with long-term follow-up studies that cemented acetabular components develop high rates of loosening and migration ( Table 18-1 ). The pathologic process involved in the loosening of cemented acetabular components came to be known as cement disease. Many in the field believed that cement represented the major obstacle to long-term fixation, and attempts were made to eliminate the use of polymethylmethacrylate in the hope that this would limit aseptic loosening.



TABLE 18-1

LONG-TERM RESULTS OF CEMENTLESS ACETABULAR COMPONENTS





















































Authors Implant Cups (No.) Years of Follow-up Revisions Pelvic Osteolysis Survival
Gaffey et al. HG-1 * 72 13-15 4.2% 7.1% 94% ± 8%
Udomkiat et al. APR 110 10.2 4.5% 3.6% 99.1%
Clohisy and Harris HG-1 § 196 10.2 4.1% 4.7% 96%
Engh et al. AML | 174 10-13 2.2% 92% ± 3% *
Della Valle et al. Trilogy 308 4 0.3% 5%

Endpoint defined as revision for clinical failure.


* Endpoint defined as revision of the acetabular component.


§ Harris Galante-1 (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN).


Anatomic Porous Replacement (Sulzer Orthopedics, Austin, TX).


| Anatomic Medullary Locking Prosthesis (Depuy, Warsaw, IN).


Trilogy Acetabular System (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN).



It is clear that if an arthroplasty is to have durable long-term function it must develop a biologic and mechanical equilibrium with the host bone. In 1979, Morscher described several special requirements for an endoprosthesis to be fixed without cement. The first requirement is to create as small a defect as possible, such as to disrupt the physiologic biomechanics of the bone as little as possible. The design, stabilization, and mechanical properties of the prosthesis must take into consideration the forces acting on the system in all directions to avoid micromotion during physiologic loading of the implant. Lastly, the biologic nature of the bone should be respected, taking care to avoid excessive damage to the surrounding tissues during preparation and insertion.




DESIGN


The transmission of forces in an artificial joint should be as physiologic as possible. The ideal implant therefore would be one that interferes least with the physiologic stress patterns of the native hip and pelvis. Morscher outlined the five major cup designs that have been used for cementless fixation in total hip arthroplasty since 1974 ( Table 18-2 ). The five principal designs included cylindrical, square, conical, ellipsoid threaded ring, and hemispherical cups. Data regarding cementless acetabular fixation have shown the hemispherical cup with a porous ingrowth surface is the most successful design. A hemispherical cup provides a contact surface on which the forces that develop between the pelvis and femoral head can be transmitted in a physiologic balance between compression and shear. The hemispherical shape also eliminates undesired stress concentrations that occur with cement fixation or in cups that deviate from this design. Finally, this design most closely mimics the anatomy of the acetabulum and allows for the least bony resection.



TABLE 18-2

SHAPES AND TYPES OF ACETABULAR COMPONENTS FOR CEMENTLESS FIXATION OF HIP ENDOPROSTHESES


























































Shape Literature Trademark, Material, Remarks (date of first use)
Cylinder Griss and Heimke (1981)


Lindenhof, ceramic
R. Judet (1975)


Judet, porometal, Cr-Cr-Mo
Square Griss et al. (1978)


Friedrichsfeld, ceramic (for dysplastic hip joints)
Conus Ring (1982)


Polyethylene
Obtuse cone with external thread Mittelmeier (1974)


Ceramic
Cone with external thread Endler and Endler (1982)


Endler-cup, polyethylene
Cone with threaded screw Parhofer and Mönch (1982)


PM-prosthesis—outer cup, Ti-Al-V; inner cup, polyethylene
Truncated ellipsoid, threaded ring Lord and Bancel (1983)


Lord prosthesis—outer cup, Co-Cr; inner cup, polyethylene
Hemisphere Boutin (1981)
Morscher et al. (1982)



Ceramic (1971) isoelastic hip endoprosthesis, polyethylene (1977) (polyacetal, 1973, abandoned)
Knahr et al. (1983)
Get Clinical Tree app for offline access